8 ms·
The value of hitting the HN front page
- 8organicbits 1y agoFor one popular project of mine that hit the front page I had a 2% sign-up rate. It was a free service that used GitHub for authentication, which likely helped. I had a Netlify landing page (CDN), and the web app was a Django app on a single DigitalOcean droplet. I didn't see any complaints of performance issues / resource usage stayed low.
- dirkc 1y agoThat sounds like my preferred setup! I use a static site deployed to cloudfront backed by a Django app on Digital Ocean :) It might not work for all applications, but it tends to hold up great against traffic spikes and the hosting costs stay in the low teens (USD)!
- NaOH 1y agoPreviously: The Value of Hitting the HN Front Page - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44584461 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44584461 - July 2025 (6 comments)
- Waraqa 1y agoThis means that there is one more piece of advice: "If your post didn't hit the front page in the first attempt, try again later".
- Nizoss 1y agoIt's a tough position to be in. I feel that I finally have some expertise worth sharing but at the same time I want to avoid backlash from the community for promoting my own content and projects. At the same time, I really do enjoy reading what others share and think without having to voice my own take. So when I miss the window, I miss the window.
- mooreds 1y agoPlease share your stuff! Just don't spam. If you don't promote cool stuff you write, who will?
- mooreds 1y agoYeah, I will post something 2-3 times, often with days or weeks between them. I've also re-posted some things that others have posted (and others have re-posted stuff I've posted). I think the key thing is to not spam. I share other people's posts mostly. 90-95% of my posts are what I find that I think the community might be interested in, as opposed to posts of my content.
- modeless 1y agoI once got a job from a post on my blog that hit the front page. So the value to me was enormous.
- jader201 1y agoRelevant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7833251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7833251 That was over 11 years ago. I still work there.
- leeoniya 1y agosame. except was an oss lib on github.
- andreabergia 1y agoSame here! I am now actually working in compilers, which is one thing I'm really passionate about, but not something I was doing professionaly. I managed to turn a toy project and some blog posts into an actual job at almost 40, so, thank you HN!
- saagarjha 1y agoIf I might ask what does you employer need compiler experience for?
- andreabergia 1y agoI work at ServiceNow, which sells an enterprise platform and a ton of products built on top of it. Internal teams and customers can extend the platform by writing JavaScript, hence we have a JS runtime in the platform (the venerable https://github.com/mozilla/rhino/ https://github.com/mozilla/rhino/), which our team works on.
- saagarjha 1y agoHuh, interesting. Thanks!
- 1y ago
- czhu12 1y agoAn open source project I was working on was on the front page for about 2 days: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44292103 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44292103 And heres the analytics from that time: https://imgur.com/XGsiot4 https://imgur.com/XGsiot4 I don't reallly bother tracking sign ups as its a totally free app, but from then to now, it looks like i've picked up about 1600 new accounts.
- stared 1y agoPeople fiddle with SEO with a lot of effort and some mixed success. While it takes a single solid hit at the HN (or Reddit) to get on the top. Of course, it means that a post needs to have more than suitable keywords. So, I never sacrifice the quality of a post just too boost its SEO.
- apples_oranges 1y agoAnd the quality of the product must be good I guess? Or at least the right product at the right time
- bemmu 1y agoI used to run a subscription box called "Candy Japan", and got #1 on Google for "japanese candy" for after posting about it on HN. The position lasted for years AFAIK.
- bijant 1y agoAgree with the gist of 1. & 2. but was hoping for a more analytic-scientific approach to measuring the impact of the HN Front Page. That is probably impossible though. If you invent github/sliced bread then hitting the front page might be the best thing to happen to your idea. If your profitable business of scamming grannies gets the same exposure it will probably be removed from the iOS/Android App Stores within minutes. Launching Dropbox here is likely somewhere in the middle.
- dmitrygr 1y agoNot sure if "have a CDN" advice is as sure as is claimed. My projects site has been #1 on the front page many times, and my dinky little $3/mo VPS had no issues at all in any of those cases.
- marginalia_nu 1y agoBack when I hosted my search engine on a PC out of my apartment, it survived several supposed HN death hugs. Seems mostly to be a problem where your website is backed by a DBMS, especially when each page impression generates multiple queries. In that scenario, running out of connections probably isn't particularly difficult. Only time I've actually been knocked offline was when Elon Musk tweeted a link to a blog post I made. That legit drove some real traffic. I'm not sure if it was the filedescriptor ulimit or the number of open connections that killed me, but I did actually blip for a few minutes.
- mooreds 1y agoI'm running wordpress on a weak shared server, so it has fallen over in the past. I think if it was a static site generator (jekyll, hugo, 11ty) then there'd be no issue.
- withinboredom 1y agoThis is likely because the default MySQL connection limit is only 100 connections and your web server is trying to make more than 100 connections (MySQL is not available error). Then if you are using fpm, the default is just a small worker pool. A cheap server can likely handle thousands of requests, but all the defaults will limit you to under 100.
- iamflimflam1 1y agoI made a map of all the request last time I hit the front page. Timestamp 1:40 in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzpU8-jCV7k&t=100s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SzpU8-jCV7k&t=100s
- superfish 1y agoThis post is pretty meta now that it's on the front page. A nice follow-up post would be: The Value of 'The Value of Hitting the HN Front Page' Hitting the HN Front Page I guess the value would be people might be more likely to prepare with CDNs or engage with comments etc. I wonder if that's measurable.
- mooreds 1y agoI'll get busy writing that :)
- FabHK 1y agoA year or so ago, I posted a link that you can help Anna's Archive by seeding their torrents [0]. I monitored (eye-balled) their stats [1] to see whether there was a bump in seeding afterwards, and couldn't see one. So, the "low conversion" comment might be true. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40672215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40672215 [1] https://annas-archive.org/torrents https://annas-archive.org/torrents
- cinntaile 1y agoI don't think you can draw any conclusions from this. Maybe that the avg HNer does not have feel like allocating 500TB of space and bandwidth to host copyrighted material...
- gosub100 1y agoLots of us browse from work where torrents aren't exactly allowed, or mobile where it's not practical
- rfarley04 1y agoYet another "Hitting HN = 30k visits" breakdown from a friend of mine (in 2022): https://www.reproof.app/blog/the-hacker-news-effect https://www.reproof.app/blog/the-hacker-news-effect
- nicbou 1y agoI have made the front page a few times, and I loved it. The discussion is so good, not to mention the random emails and LinkedIn connections. It's very validating when the topic would be too niche for other communities. Having a high-visibility post on Reddit meant a stressful few hours and some of the most toxic interactions I've experienced.
- alixanderwang 1y agoCan definitely concur about the Reddit part. Feels like commenters there are always looking for a gotcha
- amonith 1y agoStill happens here, especially when people publish open source libraries. "Why should I use your library, when there's ABC that does XYZ much better?" and other variants, as if the original poster was selling something. Doesn't happen as often when people publish final projects/products (even closed source). Maybe it's just a dev thing. Some programming languages can have some really toxic fandom :D
- Jensson 1y agoThat is not all people say though, plenty of people are like you and will bring up dropbox etc in response to that. The important part is that HN isn't an echochamber, you get many viewpoints here.
- amonith 1y agoI believe that all platforms with voting eventually become an echochamber. Unless they are partitioned into several smaller chambers, like reddit. Here the partitioning also exists, but is invisible (only some people interact with programming posts, only some with company posts, ai stuff, politics and so on), so that gives a certain "illusion" of many viewpoints. Illusion (imho) because I don't think those viewpoints interact with each other.
- 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- hiAndrewQuinn 1y agoI hit the front page of HN about two years ago with https://andrew-quinn.me/fzf https://andrew-quinn.me/fzf , and I concur with this list. Among other things it taught me the invaluable lesson that only a surprise $100 bill from my (excellent!) hosting provider could have that I really should optimize my GIFs and cache them before that happens. As my father always says, experience is cheap at any cost!
- kaaang 1y ago[dead]
- rossant 1y agoMy blog post reached #1 on HN two years ago. The 1000+ comments were extremely interesting and encouraging. I learned a lot and engaged in highly insightful discussions. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37650402 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37650402
- dirkc 1y agoI can attest to the follow-on traffic. I had a showHN on the front page for a brief moment. A few weeks later it was featured in a popular Chinese newsletter. There's also been a few smaller spikes that is attributable to HN.
- famahar 1y agoA post went viral here for a culture magazine I work for. It led to the writer getting employee of the month at a big all hands meeting, along with our host shutting down our Google indexing thinking that we were under attack.
- dude250711 1y agoIt's nice to see HN relatively safe from the likes of r/gamedev ChatGPT-generated "postmortem post" spray-and-pray marketing.
- Brajeshwar 1y agoEmbarrassingly, I used to submit my own website’s article. A few of them have hit the front-page of Hacker News. I remember, once submitting it and waiting for it to hit, when it did, I recorded a video of the first few minutes. Then I went to sleep. https://brajeshwar.com/2011/how-is-it-like-during-the-first-hour-when-your-site-is-on-top-of-hackernews/ https://brajeshwar.com/2011/how-is-it-like-during-the-first-... Now, I consider my site as something rather personal, bland, just my babbles, and kinda s**t compared to many of the ones that pops up on Hacker News.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 1y ago> I’m on an adventure to create beautiful and meaningful products to improve the world for my daughters and their friends. Keep sharing, please. From my POV there’s a lot of shallow, cliche, group-think-y sites / content shared on HN. If you’re true to this mission, yours would be a refreshing change. Thanks.
- squigz 1y agoSome of the best stuff I read on HN is submitted by the author's themselves - like Jake Seliger's posts from his blog https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jseliger https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jseliger
- hdvr 1y agoA few years ago, on my birthday, I quickly checked the visitor stats for a little side project I had started (r-exercises.com). Instead of the usual 2 or 3 live visitors, there were hundreds. It looked odd to me—more like a glitch—so I quickly returned to the party, serving food and drinks to my guests. Later, while cleaning up after the party, I remembered the unusual spike in visitors and decided to check again. To my surprise, there were still hundreds of live visitors. The total visitor count for the day was around 10,000. After tracking down the source, I discovered that a really kind person had shared the directory/landing page I had created just a few days earlier—right here on Hacker News. It had made it to the front page, with around 200 upvotes and 40 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12153811 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12153811 For me, the value of hitting the HN front page was twofold. First, it felt like validation for my little side project, and it encouraged me to take it more seriously (despite having a busy daily schedule as a freelance data scientist). But perhaps more importantly, it broadened my horizons and introduced me to a whole new world of information, ideas, and discussions here on HN. Thank you HN for this wonderful birthday gift!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- guzik 1y agoGee, today is my birthday (36). I've never managed to get anything I've built to the HN front page. Always wondered if that means my ideas just weren’t that interesting, or if it's just the luck of the draw. *edited my original comment without mentioning my project*
- lloydatkinson 1y agoI'm still happy that a few of my blog posts have hit the frontpage here. Two were rants about fake agile[1] and standups[2], which helped me feel not so unhappily alone at the state of the industry. There were others too, such as my post on why I think browser push notifications are terrible, another one was a stupid kludge to fix Cloudflare breaking my SVGs. There is also another one about dark/light modes that made it to frontpage but got some pretty nasty comments which surprised me, especially from one person in particular who seemed to make it their mission to write absurd comment after absurd comment ironically acting like exactly the kind of person I described in my blog post. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31074861 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31074861 [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40557347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40557347 It's always a pretty scary few minutes suddenly seeing a traffic spike, my usual thought is "oh no today isn't going to be good", which is mostly a thought process I have thanks to Reddit being incredibly toxic and unpleasant almost 100% of the time. Any time my blog posts have made it there I dread taking a look at the comments.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoI’ve had a couple of things make the FP. One was #1 for a while. I submitted them both, but I don’t usually submit stuff, and most of my submissions are one-pointers. These were tutorials or side projects that I thought might be useful to folks. I guess some people agreed. Most of my karma is comments. There’s really almost no value for me, in limelight. My work is usually “below the radar,” so to speak, and I’m retired. I’m not looking for work or notoriety. I actually kind of like hanging around the joint. I spent most of my career, being the dumbest guy in the room, and that’s sort of what I get, here.
- postalcoder 1y agoOP, a friendly heads up: I'm stuck in a recaptcha loop when trying to visit your site on Chrome, Safari, and firefox.
- newscombinatorY 1y agoMost likely a network thing. Changing browsers will not help. Changing a network might. If you have a dynamically allocated IP, just restart the router. Or try connecting using your mobile data plan (if you have one).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- marginalia_nu 1y agoI think I've been on the HN front page something like 30 times now since August 2021, with maybe half of those hitting it out of the park and lingering for over a day. There are real diminishing returns in terms of follow-up traffic and follow-up effects. As to be expected, but it's worth keeping in mind that this is something that generally happens over time as the novelty of whatever you're writing about wears off. The good part is that as part of this you'll gradually get more regular readers, so there's less pronounced feast-or-famine cycles. (Here I don't measure visits as there's so much bot traffic noise especially on anything that hits HN, but mostly focus on whether I get actual engagement, if people reach out to me, send me emails and so on) I think ultimately a blog post isn't interesting because it's on HN, it's on HN because it's interesting. Tryharding with regards to the HN frontpage is more likely to come at a cost of writing quality, and thus reducing the likelihood of making the front page.
- imcritic 1y agoIf HN had some kind of Hall of fame - you would be hanged there as a local (?) celebrity.
- jtbayly 1y agoI hope we wouldn’t hang him... lol
- halfmatthalfcat 1y agoWith how fickle and dichotomous HN can be, don’t put it past them.
- F0UKYOU-HN 1y agoI really don't understand the underlying "rules" here at HN. Yes I've read the "written" rules, but there is some undercurrent stuff that baffles me
- 1y ago
- that_guy_iain 1y agoHaving made the front page more a few times, the value is really minimal. Yes, I've made sales from HN traffic, but not that much in the grand scheme of things. But the value from all the links SEO wise was more valuable. If you make the front page normally people are going to post you in other places, translate it, or something else, which increases your SEO. The hug of death isn't that large. I had a 5 euro DigitalOcean droplet running Nuxt, which handled 30k visitors in a single day without CloudFlare caching it. So if you have a decent setup you should be good.
- BaudouinVH 1y agorelated : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41808941 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41808941
- h1fra 1y agoHit the frontpage maybe 4-5 times, I concur that most people don't convert, especially if you shared a blog post related to your startup; but it's a seal of approval that unlocks a lot of things down the road. A lot of newsletters, twitter accounts, youtubers, etc. will read the front page and highlight it in their respective medium. Usually, those ones are more niche, and the people who come are more interested. Not counting the SEO boost and the marketing opportunities to share that success on linkedin.
- appstorelottery 1y agoI hit the front page with ClassicVideoPoker.com (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37763098 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37763098) and got around 52k hits that day. That was over 1.5 years ago, and to this day, I still get a steady stream of users. A small percentage of them return daily to play, with some racking up hundreds of hours. Unfortunately, I wasn't running any decent stats at the time, but I see now that I'm still getting referrals from "hackernewsletter," although I'm not sure of the source. It was great to see the traction, but at the same time, it terrified me. I had all kinds of plans: logins, contests, a community, and new retro-styled games. Unfortunately, the "HN effect" paralyzed me. I was too afraid to push updates, fearing I might break something and lose the users I had. That fear persists even today, with a much smaller but extremely loyal user base.
- duck 1y agoThat was from my newsletter: https://hackernewsletter.com/ https://hackernewsletter.com/. :) Here was the issue: https://mailchi.mp/hackernewsletter/672 https://mailchi.mp/hackernewsletter/672
- appstorelottery 1y agoWow - thank you!. I'm really grateful for this.
- PaulHoule 1y agoRe: “HN is very fickle“ I have a model that, given a headline, predicts if the story will get >10 votes. It’s a terrible model, for a few reasons. The most fundamental is that if the same article is submitted 10 times it could get wildly different scores, that’s the way it does. The tail end of the model [1] is logistic regression because it deals gracefully with this kind of situation. I wish I knew how to treat this as a regression problem (predict the score), there is probably a better loss function than what I use, but when I treat it at as a regression problem I get an even worse model. The highest score this model ever gives is 70% for something like “Richard Stallman is dead” I have another model that predicts If the comment/score ratio > 0.5 which is about the average for the site. This is a much better model, close to the first recommender models I made. Trained on articles with score > 10 the input is less noisy for one thing. It’s how a learned y’all like to talk about cars. [1] what attention folks call the “head”
- cantor_S_drug 1y ago[flagged]
- hdvr 1y agoIt seems predicting the score directly (regression) is almost impossible without considering the associated domain. E.g. headlines with the letters GPT in it from openai.com, get an order of magnitude more votes than similar headlines from other sites.
- PaulHoule 1y agoTo go into more detail. My best model was developed about two years ago and hasn't been updated. It uses bag-of-word features as an input into logistic regression. I tried a lot of things, like BERT+pooling, and they didn't help. A model that only considers the domain is not as good as the bag-of-words. This kind of model reaches a plateau when it has seen about 10,000-20,000 samples so for any domain (e.g. nytimes.com, phys.org) that has more than a few thousand submissions it would make sense to train a model just for that domain. YOShiNoN and I have also submitted so many articles in the last two years that it would be worth it for me personally to make a model based on our own submissions because ultimately I'm drawing them from a different probability distribution. (I have no idea to what extent submissions behave different depending on whether or not I submit them, I know I have both fans and haters.) I see recommendation problems as involving both: "is the topic relevant" and "is the article good quality?" The title is good for the first but very limited for the second. The domain is probably more indicative of the second but my own concept of quality is nuanced and has a bit of "dose makes the poison" kind of thinking. For instance I think phys.org articles draw out a conclusion in a scientific paper that you might not get from a superficial read (good) but they also have obnoxious ads (bad). So I feel like I only want to post a certain fraction of those. So far as regression goes, this is what bothers me. An article that has the potential to get 800 votes might get submitted 10 times and get 1,50,4,800,1,200,1,35,105,8 votes or something like that. The ultimate predictor would show me the probability distribution, but maybe that's asking too much, and all I can really expect is the mean which is about 120 in that case. That's not a bad estimate on some level, but if was using the L2 norm I'd get a very high loss except in that case where it was 105. The loss is going to be high no matter what prediction I make so it's not like I can make a better model can cut my loss in half, but rather I can make a better model and reduce my loss by 0.1% which doesn't seem like too great of a victory -- though on some level it is an honest account of the fact that it's a crap shoot and the real uncertainty of the problem which will never go away. On the other hand, the logistic regression model gives a probability which is a very direct expression of that uncertainty.
- datadrivenangel 1y agomy vibecharts [0] site got 35k views a few weeks back. Made it feel worth spending $22 on a domain for a joke. 0 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44830684 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44830684 What was really interesting is seeing how many people are scraping the front page of hackernews and storing their data in public github repos. Dozens of them.
- keepamovin 1y agoMy business was built by repeated Show HN and posting on HN front page. The spikes led to interest, emails and GitHub stars which eventually led to thousands of stars, constant Google search traffic, and a stream of inbound leads. Even now around 10% of converting leads come from old HN content related to remote browser isolation and BrowserBox. A seeming paradox was that often a high quality comment in another thread led to higher quality leads than a direct post with its spikes. It is probably not how you’re supposed to do it but it worked for me, and I don’t know another way.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- yieldcrv 1y ago> Engage and ask questions that show you have thought about their comment. The best time to do this is right after they make a comment, but even a day later you’ll get some replies. And then get rate limited for arbitrary reasons, from arbitrary user behavior, for arbitrary amounts of time (2 hours), preventing involvement in this culture
- jurking_hoff 1y ago[dead]
- yieldcrv 1y agoDownvotes and flags can come from arbitrary reasons and preferences, arbitrary user behavior alluded to above. The platform shouldn't then work against someone trying to address a curious user base, but it does. The reasoning is unsubstantiated, not A/B tested, and not the only way to keep a higher signal community.
- zywoo 1y ago[dead]
- m463 1y agogah. just what we need, articles about engagement and monetizing hn do we have to go there?
- pinter69 1y agoThanks Dan, as usual, deep and insightful