2 ms·
Writing about autism science? 10 things
- lutusp 14y agoFor some reason, the author of the linked article didn't include a link to the op-ed piece under discussion: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/26/opinion/sunday/immune-disorders-and-autism.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/26/opinion/sunday/immune-diso... I emphasize I'm not drawing or suggesting a conclusion about the merits of the argument presented there. For readers who don't read much science journalism, the op-ed piece needs to be taken with a grain of salt, and I agree with the author of the linked article that the present state of our understanding of autism is a great deal less certain than the statement "An Immune Disorder at the Root of Autism", as though a consensus has been reached. No such consensus exists or is imminent. An example of the kind of argument in the article is this: "One large Danish study, which included nearly 700,000 births over a decade, found that a mother’s rheumatoid arthritis, a degenerative disease of the joints, elevated a child’s risk of autism by 80 percent." (Emphasis added.) The word "elevated" sugggests a cause-effect relationship that hasn't been established. It is more accurate to say that there is a correlation between the mother's rheumatoid arthritis and the child's autism. There's no reliable basis for saying that one caused the other. It will be a supreme irony if the present true autism rate is traced to our clean modern world, the world so often praised as self-evidently better than the dirty environment our ancestors lived in. It seems there's a circumstantial association between modern cleanliness and asthma (the so-called "hygiene hypothesis"). I emphasize that these are conjectures with no solid scientific backing, just like the op-ed piece.
- tokenadult 14y agoA couple days earlier, the biologist-parent author of the submitted blog piece on how to write about autism wrote a specific reply to the New York Times opinion piece (which I submitted to HN for discussion http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4435190 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4435190 the day it was published). Her reply post http://www.emilywillinghamphd.com/2012/08/autism-immunity-inflammation-and-new.html http://www.emilywillinghamphd.com/2012/08/autism-immunity-in... was drawn to my attention in an email from a local behavior genetics researcher this evening, and that prompted me to read several of her posts. Seeing that the first reply here is by a fellow participant on HN who reads good sources on these issues, I look forward to some good discussion here.
- lutusp 14y ago> Seeing that the first reply here is by a fellow participant on HN who reads good sources on these issues, I look forward to some good discussion here. That would be nice, but given the topic and its emotional undertones, if this comes to pass it will be quite a balancing act. This topic suffers from the burden common to all scientific topics that bear on the lives of parents and children, and in that connection it reminds me to some extent of the vaccine controversy (indeed, linked in the minds of some), in which a single individual with a vested interest in a specific outcome created something that appeared at first glance to be a legitimate connection, but by the time he was unmasked as a fraud, the damage had been done. My point is that, had the topic been anything other than autism, the episode could not have unfolded as it did. In Ms. Willingham's reply, I particularly liked "I’m sure the party has just begun. Accurate science, however, likely won't be one of the attendees." In most circumstances the science journalist's tendency to use words like "linked" as a synonym for a cause-effect relationship that hasn't been demonstrated to exist, and for those associations to ride unchecked into the the public's mind, is deplorable but not tragic. In this case, the outcome may be tragic. The author of the NYT op-ed piece segues through conjectures and "links" at length and ends up discussing drug (and parasitic worm) remedies with respect to a condition that no scientist is in a position to either identify or associate with autism. The fact of the piece's existence, and its wide readership, testifies to the desperation felt by the public, given the diagnosis rate of 1/88 among American kids (1/54 among boys). I emphasize that this is a diagnosis rate, not an occurrence rate, and it's now widely recognized that diagnosis greatly outstrips occurrence, to the degree that the diagnostic criteria are being reworked to produce a more realistic connection between diagnosis and incidence: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/health/research/new-autism-definition-would-exclude-many-study-suggests.html?_r=2 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/20/health/research/new-autism... And Asperger's is being abandoned as a diagnostic category: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/health/03asperger.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/health/03asperger.html?pag... My point is that people are proposing cures for a disease that not only has no known cause, but isn't even accurately diagnosed. As much as people would like to see the rabbit come out of the hat, it's far too soon for sleight of hand, and just about time for serious, dispassionate science.
- lutusp 14y ago