5 ms·
> Am I an exception? Years ago I was following development of an indie game. The developers wanted to provide a DRM-free experience. The game had some online
by Aurornis 1y ago
> Am I an exception?
Years ago I was following development of an indie game. The developers wanted to provide a DRM-free experience.
The game had some online functionality (leaderboard or something). They were surprised when the number of accounts accessing the online functionality exceeded their sales by a dramatic number. The developer updates grew more and more sad as they switched from discussing new features to pleading with people to actually buy the game instead of copying it. Eventually they called it quits and gave up because the game, while very popular, was so widely pirated that few people actually paid.
Whenever the piracy topic comes up I hear people do mental gymnastics to justify it, like claiming they spend more than average and therefore their piracy is a net win. Yet when we get small peeks into numbers and statistics like with video game piracy, it’s not hard to see that the majority of people who pirate things are just doing it because they get what they want and don’t have to pay for it.
- kemayo 1y agoThe difficult bit is working out what percentage of pirated copies are actually replacing a sale that would have happened if the content wasn't available to pirate. The more dramatic industry numbers like to claim it's 100%, which is ridiculous. It's certainly more than 0%, though. I'd assume that for your indie game, there were a lot of people who wound up thinking "I would play this if it's free, but I wouldn't spend $X" on it. Adding successful DRM wouldn't have done anything to them but drive them away, and reduce the amount of buzz the game received. But then, particularly in the indie game space, maybe trading away a lot of buzz for a couple hundred more full-price game sales would have been completely worth it... This is where the concept of services like Xbox Game Pass seem to be landing. Once someone has paid their fairly-small-amount each month, every game is now "free". Much like fairly-cheap streaming music basically stopped music piracy from being mainstream, cheap game-services might have the same impact on the game industry. Though, much like streaming music, whether it turns out to be economically viable for the average game studio is certainly a question. (For the sake of completeness: I don't pirate anything, so I have nothing to justify here.)
- charcircuit 1y agoSales or economics is not the only thing a developer may care about. Some people want control over their work and will be upset from people pirating their game even if it doesn't mean they lose a sale. Similarly many artists do not want you to repost their art or use their art as your profile picture.
- kemayo 1y agoSure, but the specific thing the person I was replying to said the developer was complaining about was not getting paid.
- account42 1y agoOk, but should we care if those developers/artists get what they want? Some companies would also really like to take games they have sold you away from you so they can sell you the next installment. Some developers don't want certain groups of people they dislike to enjoy their game. Not all things that developers want are reasonable.
- brookst 1y agoLimiting sales to the “right” people is a totally different proposition than revoking sales after the fact. Both are dumb, but one is within a copyright owner’s rights, and the other is not.
- dns_snek 1y agoWhat does "control over their work" mean if it's not about losing a sale? Developers exerting control over a copy that's already in someone's hands has never been a good thing. Too many games have had content ripped out years later because the developer had a change of heart, or was contractually obligated to remove it due to some licensing agreement (unbeknownst to their customers, of course). Both of these scenarios are immoral (arguably illegal) and don't deserve support.
- charcircuit 1y ago
- boomboomsubban 1y agoYour story sounds like "World of Goo," which reported a 90% piracy rate from comparing unique IP addresses to number sold. Despite that, they didn't quit and recently released "World of Goo 2" still DRM free.
- usef- 1y agoYes, hit games are still popular enough for sequels (world of goo 2 came out 16 years after the first one, according to wikipedia, which is an unusually long time). I remember World of Goo being one of the few choices of games for iPad when it was young. But the vast majority of developers aren't lucky enough to have massive hits, and so money differences can still matter.
- mrguyorama 1y ago>comparing unique IP addresses to number sold Wouldn't that be beyond a flawed system? I would count as a "new unique" player every few weeks.
- boomboomsubban 1y agoI think it was a daily scoreboard so that wouldn't be an issue, but they themselves said the number was flawed, just not that wrong.
- wiredpancake 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tonyhart7 1y agoYeah people pretending that "piracy" is good because they can try product first before buying which is true but lets be real out of 100 people doing that how many actually buy product in the end???? if net gain is positive then developer would not pay millions to license DRM
- FranzFerdiNaN 1y ago> out of 100 people doing that how many actually buy product in the end???? if net gain is positive then developer would not pay millions to license DRM Lets not pretend that markets and companies are actually rational.
- AngryData 1y agoI think part of the question though is also, would they have been as popular as they were without piracy, which does provide some advertising benefits through audience exposure. It is easy to say a really popular game would still be popular without piracy, but some lesser known games might never have gained any attention at all if there weren't enough people spreading word about it. Of course trying to quantify the sales and word-of-mouth benefits from that sort of thing is extremely difficult.
- brookst 1y agoIt’s difficult enough that perhaps we should leave it in the academic / ideological argument space and focus on whether copyright owners should be able choose whether or not to give away for free in the hopes of a net win.
- account42 1y ago> The game had some online functionality (leaderboard or something). They were surprised when the number of accounts accessing the online functionality exceeded their sales by a dramatic number. The developer updates grew more and more sad as they switched from discussing new features to pleading with people to actually buy the game instead of copying it. Eventually they called it quits and gave up because the game, while very popular, was so widely pirated that few people actually paid. Ok, but why? Whas the game actually unprofitable or did they just feel bad about some people getting it for free. You need to remember that a pirated copy does not equal a lost sale - in fact, sales may even be higher than they would be without piracy as popularity gained from pirated copies also translates to more legitimate buyers.
- sersi 1y agoWhich indie game was that?
- Krasnol 1y agoMaybe the game wasn't worth it. Check out RimWorld. Small game, no online functionality, never had DRM. It wasn't even big. It was shared all over the place because it was so expensive. It's still there and it's thriving. Still expensive.