5 ms·
I understand how this type of color photography works, as does anyone who read the article, since the article explained it. It's basically the same as Technicol
by 001sky 14y ago
I understand how this type of color photography works, as does anyone who read the article, since the article explained it. It's basically the same as Technicolor
That sentence says, no you don't understand.
The images are monochromes, set with chemistry. 100yrs ago.
Then they are scanned into a computer.
Imported into photoshop.
The color is from photoshop.
The working color space is from photoshop.
The output color space is from photoshop.
Ergo, they look like photoshop.
PJ's use photshop all the time, there is nothing nefarious.
But the "look" is a function of the post-processing.
Provided a somewhat reasonable monochrome scan quality.
In fact, images are shot on overcast days to maximize the post-processing range of the output images.
Thats how you max tonal seperability and ability to punch the color without blowing the dynamic range.
Its counterintuitive, but true.
A modern look is a dull image input + aggressive tonal controls.
This is exactly what NASA does from the digital files from Mars.
Or what the NY times does on its news stories, etc.
Its "cool". Its just different than what you think it is.
- nessus42 14y agoI understand all of that, and none of that contradicts anything I've said. Technicolor starts with three monochrome images on black and white silver negative film, just as these images started. So once we have the negatives, Technicolor uses a chemical process to do dye transfer, while these images were creating using scanning and computers to achieve the same goal. So what? We already knew this, of course. Or are you asserting that Technicolor and/or modern SLR produce images that are vastly more accurate in their color rendering than these images are? And do you think that people here would be any less impressed if they'd been rendered using a "filmic" or classic Technicolor look, rather than a "Photoshop look"? I've done a fair amount of photography, so I know first hand that the colors and contrast you get on your final print are often vastly different from what you saw in reality while taking the photo, and yet we still typically think that results are "good enough". And no, the process you've described is not particular different from what occurs with any photography. It's still precisely reality --> series of dubious technological steps --> not-terribly-accurate but good enough representation of reality
- 001sky 14y agoAt the risk of being pedantic, I'll explain it too you in another level of detail. First, lets backup though. shawnc 19 hours ago | link | parent | flag These are so amazing. The world wasn't sepia toned a hundred years ago! As silly as that statement is, my brain is actually having a hard time really believing these photos are from 100 years ago. I'm in awe. OK. This was the original statement. The somewhat minor but technical point I was making is as follows. There is a simple explanation. The world then looked like it does today. And the image itself is modern, so it looks modern. Thats it. The Awe of this? Its called the "uncanney valley". Its kinda-almost-sorta-perfect-but-off-a-bit. How did they do this then? Easy, the colorwork is done in photoshop, using contemporary techniques. PS allows them to exploit the latent image data, and map it onto one of many "style" outputs. [1] You can debate this or not. But its cited in the footnotes above. If you havent read them, take a look. I understand all of that you say? Ok. You so, you are now in "awe of photoshop". The technical reasons for this are not hard. I'll stop here, because I think any more technical is not going to help you. I've done a fair amount of photography... Again, I would encourage you to do research on colour theory. If you do your own work, it will help you immensely, to make the most of your images. And if you really are an expert in this already, you know how trivial it is to produce "contemporary" style images from these formats, given the datasets you have to play with. ____________ Edit: For the general reader [1] Style. In the sense i'm using it here is a mix of overall color, texture, tone, sharpness, saturation, hue, tint, noise, and other basic image editing techniques. Without getting into a discussion about "color" (ie, not "accuracy" but more correctly temp, tint, gamut, etc), its important to understand that the "look" has a lot of potential. Think about instagram. All of those filters are just "style" presets. But they don't look alike. Some are contemporary, some are retro, etc. It only requires a certain base image quaity to "take" the style (ie, good enough to not be ruined at the pixel level). So you might have an image which out of iphone looks "OK" and then in instagram is "Cool" or whatever. But the look of the "instagram" is independent of the landscape (which always looks the same, sepia toned on your phone or not). Now, the question is, what limits the "style"? And thats where the color technicals come in. If your input is messed up, your gamut and balance and tint will not let your image "take" a style. Because the transitions (ie, curves, etc) will destroy your pixel base. The size of your gamut, will determin the range you can execute. Now, with film, the color-setting step is a one-shot deal. There are no 12 instagram settings - you get just one - film/chemistry setting. You gett a little bit of flex at the print (color mix, etc) but not much. If you scan the film, then you are opening up to 12 syles (or whatever). So, now we get to the point. None of the film emulsions (prior to NC portra) really give you a contemporary look. To get that, you have to bring the image into digital. The temp/tint/contrast levels are just not there. Thats why its "odd" seing an old image looking like NC portra film or like a 2000+ PJ photoshop. And you can double check by looking at the details, if your an expert. The monochrome seperations have good tonal information, which is a credit to the guys back 100 years ago. But the modernists of that era were some of the best photogs ever, and among the most technically brilliant in monochrom image capture.
- michrassena 14y agoThese images do not look like Photoshop. The color gamut of the original negatives would probably be outside of the gamut of RGB. What has happened in post-processing is that the contrast and saturation have been exaggerated (is it too much, is that all you're really saying?). I've pulled some of these very same images into Photoshop and reconstituted them into color images. What you've described in so many words is quite simple. These are three color channels, overlaid on each other (Photoshop makes auto-aligned layers very easy). That's it. And basically that's what the three lens lantern projector that Prokudin-Gorsky used to present his images did. The original source images, due to their being recorded on plates or film, probably have a wider gamut, due to the greater latitude of the analog medium, that most of the digital cameras produced today. While we can't say for certain that this post-production has yielded an image of reality that corresponds exactly to the colors and lighting of those scenes 100+ years ago, grass is only so green, some historic dress survives, and there are archivists who study the deterioration of dyes, and while I don't know if the aspect of clothing has been studied in the production of these images, how can you say that these images are not an impressive reconstruction? Basically, your argument boils down to this point. It's as if there were an ancient sculpture in three pieces. Researchers glued those three pieces together. You're bitching about the fact they used modern tools to put them together. If you were to take these lantern slides and project them in the very same projector used by Prokudin-Gorsky onto a wall, I think you complain when a digital photograph was taken of them and displayed on the Internet. You are looking for things to nit-pick about. What you haven't demonstrated an understanding of is how color film has always worked, since the very beginnings in experiments by Maxwell. There are layers of monochrome film, because that's what a sensitized silver emulsion is, is monochrome, there is none other. Above each of these layers of monochrome emulsion are dyes acting as filters, generally three, which filter all but 1/3 of the spectrum, giving us a red layer, a green layer and a blue layer. The film when processed removes the dyes which didn't get exposed (or did, depending on whether it's print or reversal film). Digital cameras are the same, there is a light sensitive layer, which again, is entirely monochrome, sensitive to all frequencies of light. Above this layer is a layer of filters, called an Bayer array, which is two parts green, 1 part red, 1 part blue. Each light sensitive site has a filter of some color sitting over it. When the sensor is exposed and read out, the camera software processes it into a true color image by interpolating the color information onto adjacent pixels (demosaicing). Finally, what you fail to demonstrate is why we should care where the color space and tonal separation come from. These images weren't shot on an overcast day, there's plenty of contrast present in most of these images, as they were shot on sunny days. Film emulsions in 1900 weren't very fast, the equivalent of ISO 25 or slower. You can get an idea of the duration of the exposure by looking at the silkiness of the water in the photos that were shot near water. What I keep coming back to in my mind, is why you think that being produced in Photoshop diminishes or alters the reality of these scenes. I too am sick of seeing candified images with off-the-charts color saturation, produced that way just because it can be, because colorfulness is compelling. I don't think the images fit the definition of over-colorful. It would surprise me that the Library of Congress, whose mission is the archival of material, would make no allowance for the accuracy of the colors presented, however I see no allusion to the research, so perhaps these bear no resemblance to reality. These images come close enough that a contemporary viewer would be awed by them, and a modern viewer can better appreciate and understand the world which bore them. It takes true artistry to convey emotion with a monochrome image, so I'm glad we have these color images to convey more of the feeling of life in that era.