3 ms·
We, in the tech industry, go all starry-eyed when we imagine utopian futures filled with robots that will do all your tedious chores. But a dark side of this th
by groos 1y ago
We, in the tech industry, go all starry-eyed when we imagine utopian
futures filled with robots that will do all your tedious chores. But a
dark side of this that goes unnoticed is that such automation is often
just a way for money to be transferred from the poorest sections of
society to the richest.
This fact was driven home to me recently when dropping my mother off
at the airport. For various reasons, my mother us to use wheelchair
assistance when flying, and I usually get a "gate pass" to accompany
her to the gate. An airline provided wheelchair is pushed by an
airline employee whom I usually tip a decent amount every time. The
last time she flew, the employee insisted that we had to make a
detour, otherwise they would "write him up". Not wishing to make his
life hard, we agreed and he brought us to an area where they were
trialing robotic wheelchairs. They insisted my mother use the robotic
wheelchair and since I was with her an a little curious, we agreed. In
the process of tranferring her, I forgot to tip the wheelchair pusher.
The robotic wheelchair was an unconditional disaster. In a busy
airport, it stopped every time it detected anyone within 5 feet of it
and took 20 min to get where it would have taken less than 5 with the
cherry on top being that it stopped and told my mother to get off 3
gates away. Had I not been with her, I'm not sure what she would have
done, being too weak to lift her carry-on and walking to the gate.
But thinking about it a bit, I realized that sooner or later, the
robotic wheelchair would be improved to the point that it did just as
good a job as the human pusher at which point, all the income earned
by the humans, all of whom are from the poorer sections of society,
would be transferred to the robotic wheelchair company and its
shareholders, all of whom are probably in the top 2% wealth-wise.
This transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich seems to be a
recurrent theme in tech. Sure new wealth eventually is made, but it
seems it's mostly for the top strata, with us techies being paid well
enough to prevent us from feeling too many scruples.