11 ms·
How Dangerous Is Your Couch?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zafirk 14y agobetween this and the article about brain parasites in california, HN is scaring the crap out of me
- publicfig 14y agoI don't know which article you're referencing, but we also had brain parasites found in a man who died about 50 miles from me in Indiana. We've basically been told to avoid freshwater lakes and rivers for now.
- 001sky 14y agoThose freshwater incidents sound like protozoa (amoeba) infections with an high mortality rate ("Brain-eating amoeba suspected in Indiana death"). GP is referring to another hazard, also seems to be from nasty water. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4492244 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4492244. Don't say you weren't warned though !
- noahc 14y agoMinnesota also had a confirmed case about a month and half ago as well.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThis is a fundamental problem with our always-on, 24 hour news, headline-based world. Unfortunately, it tends to breed fear, hopelessness and apathy as people feel overwhelmed about too many problems they can't control. Not sure what to do about it, though. Get outside and disconnected more, I suppose. :)
- rcthompson 14y agoBonus: getting outside gets you away from your carcinogenic couch.
- tsotha 14y agoNot me. For one thing, keep in mind these people are selling page views. If the headline was "Odds of being diagnosed with brain parasite at .00061%", would you even bother reading the story? Dividing things out is a big anxiety stopper. And think about it when you see something like "...100% increase in your risk of brain cancer," since it represents the doubling of a very small number. Taking percentages of percentages is a sneaky way to make things look more important than they really are.
- 001sky 14y agoOf the 84,000 industrial chemicals registered for use in the United States, only about 200 have been evaluated for human safety by the Environmental Protection Agency --Wait, what? What is the EPA doing, then for 42 years? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Pro...
- pmorici 14y agoProtecting the interests of the chemical manufacturing industry?
- simonsarris 14y agoI think this kind of cynicism without citation is a very unhealthy thing for any (online) community. large edit: I should have said "cynicism without citation and qualification." Even if there's a citation I don't like how people reject people/places/institutions out of hand because they might do bad things or have bad qualities because it's often represented as a dichotomy. For instance here, even if we grant that the EPA is susceptible to corporate influence, even if we as a society decide to go so far as to find them guilty of all the good they didn't do, it doesn't diminish the good that they did do and can still do, and too often these kinds of rejections/scoffs/cynicisms don't serve to add anything to the conversation of a community (such as HN) other than shut down more concrete or nuanced criticisms or discussions. Sorry for being way off topic here.
- 001sky 14y agoThere is a citation of the data. The question is a fair one. I don't think we should self-censor people for answering, per se.[1] [1] Also see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#Environmental_Protection_Agency_.28EPA.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#Environmenta...
- srl 14y agoThe next sentence: That’s because industrial chemicals are presumed safe unless proved otherwise, under the 1976 federal Toxic Substances Control Act. In other words, the EPA isn't _allowed_ to investigate products unless evidence that they are unsafe is brought before it. Makers get the benefit of the doubt.
- afterburner 14y agoMemory-foam mattresses have the same problem apparently. I have one, and am looking into a dust mite bed casing (~$100) to prevent the chemicals from getting into the air... http://lesstoxicstuff.com/2011/09/how-to-reduce-your-familys-toxic-flame-retardant-exposure/ http://lesstoxicstuff.com/2011/09/how-to-reduce-your-familys...
- lignuist 14y agoWe spend a lot of time in our beds (at least we should), so we should take everything about it very serious! We recently switched to a bed that strictly consists of natural materials like wood, latex, cotton and natural rubber. Absolutely no metal and no toxic additives. Costs as much as our car, but is worth every cent. Sleeping feels like holiday now. I also can smell the difference.
- walkon 14y agoDo you have a link to info on such beds?
- lignuist 14y agoIt is called "Relax" and is manufactured by an austrian company. http://www.relax-bettsysteme.at/en http://www.relax-bettsysteme.at/en
- rfzabick 14y agoAre you in the states? How did you order it? I could only find a link for finding dealers in Europe.
- lignuist 14y agoNo, I'm in the EU and bought it from a local dealer. However, I wouldn't order such a bed without having tested it. There are some parameters like the thickness and the softness of the mattress that should be adjusted to your needs, but maybe the Manufacturer ships also to the US when they get an order.
- hastur 14y agoVote for Mitt Romney, he'll scale back the EPA and you'll be able to wallow in carcinogenic substances all day long.
- newbie12 14y agoWhat is the EPA doing about it right now? You'd be surprised to learn that many U.S. environmental laws were passed by Republican presidents. There's a "Nixon-goes-to-China" aspect to it. Indeed, Nixon created the EPA...
- hinathan 14y agoArlene Blum is kind of amazing. I met her maybe 20 years ago in the context of mountain climbing. Can't imagine climbing with a baby strapped to myself.
- Tichy 14y agoSo basically she is completely crazy? However I hope she wins the fight against toxic chemicals...
- WildUtah 14y agoI climbed mountain passes that size with my infants carried in a pack. It was good clean fun and the babies loved it. They play in the pine needles and the sand and get sap all over themselves and then snuggle up with you in the cold alpine nights. Everybody has a good time. And I'm nowhere near as tough as Ms. Blum. (Annapurna I! Holy. Cow.)
- Tichy 14y agoNot sure about the definition of climbing. Seems to me falling might not be healthy for babies? As for hiking in the mountains, sure, why not.
- WildUtah 14y agoClimb is an English word which simply means to rise. "The sun came out and the temperature was climbing." Of course, there are various activities we describe as climbing that need more precise descriptions. Some of them are more perilous than others. The most I did in the mountains with baby in tow was class 3 scrambling with a spotter.[0] Hacker News types like it specific. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grade_(climbing) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grade_(climbing)
- NoPiece 14y agoI feel like the article is missing a basic analysis of whether there would be more deaths by an increased number of fires caused by removing the fire retardant, or by cancer cancer caused by fire retardant. Just give me some numbers, and let me decide what kind of furniture I want.
- Tichy 14y agoHow does a couch catch fire, though? I suspect falling asleep on a couch with a cigarette is the main cause. Smokers want to die anyway, so I'd give priority to safety of children.
- anonymouz 14y agoBut what about the people living next door to your hypothetical smoker? It's a good idea to have fire safety regulations, for the reason that a fire usually will not just burn the person who caused it in the first place. (Whether this fire retardent helps prevent fires or not is of course a more difficult question...)
- Tichy 14y agoYou have a point, we are back to needing more data. Living next door to a smoker, we have at least installed a smoke detector. But I suspect if it goes off it would already be too late.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThe article specifically mentioned this case. The chemicals they put in the foam would have absolutely no benefit if your apartment was burning because the neighbor's started. Furthermore, there is little evidence that the chemicals will prevent your sleeping smoker from burning the place down. Droithomme's comment[1] very much applies. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4493813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4493813
- Tichy 14y ago
- huhtenberg 14y agoReminds me of the situation around one of theories that tries to explain SIDS - Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. If you had a kid, you know what it is - a newborn dying in his sleep for no apparent reason. You put a healthy baby to sleep in his bed only to find him dead in the morning. Fun stuff. There are no exact explanation for the syndrome, but there are preventive measures (such as always let newborn fall asleep on his back) that statistically lessen the risk of it occurring. One of the theories was that a typical crib mattress creates a fertile ground for some fungal growth. Coupled with chemicals found in the mattress, this creates weak poisonous gas emission, which ultimately kills the child. It's an older theory that was verified and formally considered invalid. However in one country, New Zealand, there's a doctor who has been a vigorously arguing in favor of this theory and now has a statistic to show that proper mattress wrapping nullifies the risk of SIDS. From what I've read, he had very hard time getting the authorities to even listen to his findings, leave alone to act on them. I wish this lady the best of luck, she's got NYT on her side, I hope she takes a full advantage of this exposure. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudden_infant_death_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudden_infant_death_syndrome
- philwelch 14y agoSIDS is another word for "looks like asphyxiation but we can't figure out how". There's no single cause. Babies sleeping on their tummies was one, since they just breathe back in their CO2. Other proposed causes include fungus, as you mentioned, and even infanticide.
- newbie12 14y agoSIDs, while still too common, has dropped 70% in the U.S. since the "back-to-sleep" effort and the general awareness of the situation. Children under 6 months don't have a reflex to carbon dioxide poisoning, and their respiratory systems aren't fully developed, so it is easier for them to suffocate on their own breath pooling in too-soft mattresses or cribs with polyester blankets or bumpers. Risk factors for SIDs death include: winter, cigarette smoke exposure, respiratory illness, not breast-feeding, and not sleeping in the same room as an adult.
- 14y ago
- greenyoda 14y agoThe irony of the whole thing is that the flame retardants don't even make furniture any less flammable: "The problem, [the fire expert] argues, is that the standard is based on applying a small flame to a bare piece of foam - a situation unlikely to happen in real life. ... In real life, before the flame gets to the foam, it has to ignite the fabric. Once the fabric catches fire, it becomes a sheet of flame that can easily overwhelm the fire-suppression properties of treated foam. In tests, TB 117 compliant chairs catch fire just as easily as ones that aren't compliant - and they burn just as hot." So the entire country is now exposed to the dangers of these chemicals because in 1975 some bureaucrats at an obscure government agency in California came up with an arbitrary standard that was not based in reality.
- droithomme 14y agoThanks for digging that up, I was wondering about that. The article cites a retardant advocate as saying "Deaths caused by furniture fires dropped from 1,400 in 1980 to 600 in 2004; a 57 percent reduction." We know that almost all of these couch fires are caused by people falling asleep while smoking cigarettes. According to the CDC, in the same period, cigarette consumption in the US adult population has fallen from 33.2% in 1980 to 20.9% in 2004. (http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0762370.html http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0762370.html) So a certain portion of the decline is due to the reduction in cigarette use. Also, 43 out of 50 states now mandate "fire safe" cigarettes which contain substances such as ethylene vinyl acetate which increase the chance an unsmoked but lit cigarette will stop burning. The presence of these cigarettes has also certainly led to fewer couch fires. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_safe_cigarette http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_safe_cigarette It is unlikely that the entire 57 percent reduction in couch fires over 24 years is entirely due to the use of carcinogenic flame retardants.
- Alex3917 14y ago"According to the CDC, in the same period, cigarette consumption in the US adult population has fallen from 33.2% in 1980 to 20.9% in 2004." Those who smoke cigarettes also smoke a lot less than they used to, so total cigarette consumption is maybe only half as much or less compared to what it once was.
- nostromo 14y agoLooking at mattresses without flame-retardent led me to this provider: http://www.whitelotus.net/green-cotton-rx/ http://www.whitelotus.net/green-cotton-rx/ Turns out you'll need a doctor's prescription to even order a plain cotton mattress. Yet another perfectly reasonable regulation from our friends in the California Legislature! :) My least-favorite CA regulation has to do with eye-glasses. I lost my only pair and went in to get a replacement on a Saturday, but I couldn't because my (perfectly fine) prescription had expired. I had to make an appointment to get an exam in order to get new glasses, but they were closed for the weekend and booked for a few days. So I spent about a week with headaches because some CA legislator decided it was in my best interest to pay some practitioner to get the same prescription for glasses every year.
- tocomment 14y agoYou should have ordered online.
- guelo 14y ago"So I spent about a week with headaches because some ophthalmology trade group lobbied (bribed) the legislature to get profit-enhancing regulations in place." FTFY
- _delirium 14y agoAre there any states that don't have a requirement of a current prescription to purchase glasses? I've had the same issue in Texas [1], which usually considers itself small-government. [1] cf. http://www.tob.state.tx.us/tobrx.htm http://www.tob.state.tx.us/tobrx.htm
- tokenadult 14y agoAnother top-level comment wrote: between this and the article about brain parasites in california, HN is scaring the crap out of me And I guess that's why my all-time favorite external link to share here on Hacker News is "Warning Signs in Experimental Design and Interpretation" http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html by Peter Norvig, Google's director of research. To resolve the issue of the safety trade-offs of not treating furniture with flame-retardant chemicals (the status quo when I was a child) and treating it (the status quo for quite a while now in the United States) will take careful examination of the actual risk ratios of any disease said to be correlated with the chemicals, the risk ratios of injuries and deaths from fires, the cost of other preventive measures for each kind of harm, and so on. Public policy is not easy. The best public policies have to be carefully examined in light of verifiable facts. I see from user danso's profile http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=danso http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=danso that he has a professional role in investigative journalism, and indeed I have enjoyed reading (and of course have upvoted) many of his comments here on HN over the past year. The piece submitted here mentions about its author that "Dashka Slater is the author of six books for children and adults. Her latest children’s book, 'Dangerously Ever After,' is out this month," which prompted me to look up other information about the author. Her personal website http://www.dashkaslater.com/index.php/journalist http://www.dashkaslater.com/index.php/journalist declares that she has written pieces for a variety of publications, many in the "alternative" market for periodical articles, and her LinkedIn profile https://www.linkedin.com/in/dashkaslater https://www.linkedin.com/in/dashkaslater declares her educational background. There is some interesting reporting here, but as a regular reader of Mother Jones (one of the publications that most often publishes her work) and of other "alternative" publications, I would like to see more follow-up on this issue before writing to my elected representatives, as I sometimes do, asking for a change in current law. I do remember when newspaper and magazine articles in my childhood were all about the fearsome dangers of fires killing little children. A recent submission to HN based on very reliable statistics pointed out that life expectancy in the United States at birth, at age 40, at age 60, at age 65, and even at age 80 has been steadily RISING http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=longevity-why-we-die-global-life-expectancy http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=longevity-w... since 1960, so new regulations introduced since then so far don't seem to have net harm for the population in balance with all other social and environmental changes since then. Perhaps the purported flame-retardant chemicals don't prevent as many fires as people suppose. But perhaps they also don't cause any serious human illness in actual use. Let's not rush to judgment on this issue, but let's do actual, verifiable science that with sound economic and policy analysis can help guide lawmakers to the best currently available trade-off in regulation.
- abdelmaalik 14y agojust in case your couch is dangerous: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JcJkhSUSnek https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JcJkhSUSnek 10 seconds that can mushroom into a lot of wasted time, you've been warned.
- hollerith 14y agoAfter the foam in cushions described in the OP, the biggest source of human exposure to flame retardants is probably consumer electronics. Particularly, most televisions and computer monitors are encased in a plastic housing which by law must be resistant to catching fire, and the universal way that is achieved is by mixing flame retardants with the plastic while the plastic is still "liquid". I read once that flame retardants make up up to 20% of the volume of the material of the housings. When you remove this toxic plastic housing, there is another housing underneath made of steel, which holds the monitor or TV together just fine on its own. The exception is the buttons for adjusting brightness, etc. Last year, I removed all the urethane foam from my home and the plastic housing from my monitor. There is a row of buttons for brightness, etc, that now hangs by wires, and there is a button near the top of the monitor for power which now hangs down the back of the monitor by wires. Now that the buttons are no longer held in place by the plastic housing, it is much harder to press them, but that is OK because I never adjust the brightness (preferring to use OS X to "switch black and white" at night). And I never use the power button. (The monitor draws one watt when it is on but not receiving video input). Except for the small and not particularly noticeable row of buttons hanging by wires from the bottom of the monitor, the monitor has a tidy, trim appearance and does not prevent me from feeling proud of how my computer looks. I recommend these home modifications to almost everybody. The way the flame retardants get into the human body, by the way, is by attaching to dust, which gets ingested in small amounts. Consequently, after removal and disposal of the housing, I recommend cleaning the area under and around the device. Or get a recent Apple monitor, which has an aluminum housing.
- WalterBright 14y agoThe single best way to protect your home against fire, by far, is to have a fire sprinkler system installed. Unfortunately, this can only be done when the house is built. So if you are planning on building a house, specify a sprinkler system. It'll be the best money you ever spent.
- rdl 14y agoWhy can't you retrofit fire suppressing foam in the kitchen, like one does in a commercial kitchen range hood? I've seen this done on kitchen remodels. There are residential range hoods (Viking, Wolf, ...) which have a wall-mounted button or a pull which 1) kills the fuel source and 2) smothers the range area with fire suppression (class BC or K) to put out the fire and prevent re-ignition. Totally ruins your food AND needs to be cleaned off promptly since it's corrosive. Kitchens are by far the most likely source of domestic fires.
- _delirium 14y ago> Kitchens are by far the most likely source of domestic fires. Interesting; I would've guessed it'd be in closer running with other causes, but it looks like they constitute around 55% of total residential fires. According to some U.S. statistics from 2010 [1], the leading causes of residential fires are cooking, with 166k fires, followed by heating at 47k fires, electrical and "other unintentional" at ~25k each, and open flame and "intentional" at just under 20k each. [1] http://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/statistics/res_bldg_fire_causes.pdf http://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/statistics/res_bldg_f...
- ericdykstra 14y agoAnother example of government creating arbitrary policies that just waste time and money, and probably kill us. Since 1975, an obscure California agency called the Bureau of Home Furnishings and Thermal Insulation has mandated that the foam inside upholstered furniture be able to withstand exposure to a small flame, like a candle or cigarette lighter, for 12 seconds without igniting. Who decided on 12 seconds? Why the inside of furniture rather than the outside? Who does this benefit? Why is there even a Bureau of Home Furnishings and Thermal Insulation? Why do government agencies like the EPA exist when they can't say anything about the safety of chemicals that are in couches in probably in upwards of 95% of homes in America? It wouldn't surprise me if a flame retardant manufacturer was behind the law to begin with, which is even more disgusting.
- brendn 14y agoIt was totally a lobbying effort to get the legislation passed. First by the tobacco industry because of fires started by smokers falling asleep with lit cigarettes, then by the chemical industry (by courting state fire marshals) to boost sales of their flame retardants. The Chicago Tribune has a multi-part series on it here: http://media.apps.chicagotribune.com/flames/index.html http://media.apps.chicagotribune.com/flames/index.html
- tptacek 14y agoChemtura Firemaster 550 is "just starting to be analyzed"? It was introduced in '05-'06, and here's its 2006 MSDS: http://www.busbrp.org/cireeh/uploads/Main/FM550msds.pdf http://www.busbrp.org/cireeh/uploads/Main/FM550msds.pdf
- gregPC 14y agoTo protect someone, we must endanger everyone.
- thejefflarson 14y agoThe Chicago Tribune has a good series about how Big Tobacco and chemical companies have pushed for more flame retardants in everything despite health concerns: http://media.apps.chicagotribune.com/flames/index.html http://media.apps.chicagotribune.com/flames/index.html
- gojomo 14y agoIt's sad that premature regulation moved this into the sphere of politics and mandated-purchases (from companies with an incentive to lobby). That means any attempt to learn what's really going on, or make any incremental changes, is gummed up by the fog of adversarial, zero-sum politics. Without the inflexible mandate, the rule could simply be: label whether your product has flame-retardants or not, and have evidence for your claims. Then the industry could diversify, some brands emphasizing flame-resistance and others lack of chemical additives. And, this diversity would mean we would gather more real-world experience about whether the flame-retardant units are really correlated with fewer/slower fires and fewer fatalities, or with more health/IQ/behavior problems in children and pets, or both, or neither. But because of the uniform monoculture imposed by the premature politicization, we face a data white-out and policy is flying half-blind... with only indirect data on costs and benefits. Maybe a way out would be to compel a bisection of the industry output: you must make half your units with, and half without, these additives, and clearly mark the units in each category. Five to ten years later, we'd likely have much better data about real effects.
- reirob 14y agoWhen reading the title I thought the article will be about how dangerous the couch is for our generation, because we are spending more and more time on it and so do not exercise enough our body, etc. You know, related to Tablet devices and Internet which allow more and more entertainment from the couch. Was quite surprised it is about another type of danger. I guess I am too much on portable devices and on the couch ;)
- dromidas 14y ago>The baby’s mother had placed a candle in her crib, he said, and the candle fell over, igniting a pillow. I'm pretty sure the baby's mother didn't deserve to be the mother of anyone. Either that or she spent too much time sniffing her own couch and it lowered her IQ enough to put a CANDLE IN A FREAKING CRIB WITH A BABY.