2 ms·
> When I want OOP, I play with Smalltalk. Or Self. I'm reasonably sure there was an implicit "and be productive" in there. Smalltalk and Self are neat, but the
by eropple 14y ago
> When I want OOP, I play with Smalltalk. Or Self.
I'm reasonably sure there was an implicit "and be productive" in there. Smalltalk and Self are neat, but they don't do well on the get shit done test.
(Yes, I know it is possible to get shit done in those. Compare the difficulty of getting-shit-done in them to an environment like Java or C#, and an unbiased source is going to have to admit they fail pretty hard if only because of stuff like Maven or, to a lesser extent, NuGet.)
- masklinn 14y ago> I'm reasonably sure there was an implicit "and be productive" in there. Right, let's move the goalposts and reduce the target, was there also the implicit assumption that the language should have a C-style syntax, be statically typed, run on a JITted runtime and be maintained by a big company?
- eropple 14y ago...or we can assume that the guy isn't an idiot and has selected C# as an object-oriented language for getting shit done. The only one who said "play" was you, and it makes sense because there's not really a lot of getting-shit-done using Smalltalk on modern systems. But he didn't say "play", he said "use", and a reasonable person might think that he said "use" because he has shit to get done. If hopping up and down and yelling about your pet likes when they don't really fit the topic is your bag, more power to you, but...
- masklinn 14y ago> ...or we can assume that the guy isn't an idiot No, I think we can exclude that one with no issue at all.