4 ms·
4 geeky laws that rule our world
- smoyer 14y agoCan we rename "the trough of disillusionment" to "the pit of despair"? That's how I've felt when I had products trapped there and it's also a great movie reference.
- bshep 14y agoLoved the youtube clip
- MojoJolo 14y agoWhen I read about geeky law, the first thing come to my mind is "Moore's Law".
- noamsml 14y agoMoore's law as commonly understood (single-threaded computing power doubles every X amount of time) is already false. Moore's law as originally stated (number of transistors per chip doubles every X amount of time) is probably only true for a short while longer.
- eru 14y ago> (number of transistors per chip doubles every X amount of time) That's closer, but still not there. Moore was more specific: He talked about the chip that currently has the lowest price per transistor. What really amazes me, is that Moore's law works backwards, too, for much longer periods than Moore had fitted the data to. You need to relax the definition of transistor somewhat, though. But punch-card looms still fit the pattern. On a tangent: I wonder how long exponential progress in falling prices will last in the fields of genome sequencing and synthesis. (I've also read that rechargeable batteries currently improve by around 8% a year. I don't remember by which metric exactly, though.)
- dmckeon 14y agoA reference to Moore's law in the lead paragraphs of an article in popular media is a useful diagnostic. If the law is mentioned at all, usually in ~200 words, I expect the writer to handwave with low signal/noise about some supposedly latest-and-greatest tech and I can decide whether to read the rest of the article. If the writer butchers an explanation of Moore's law, I can simply skip the rest of the article, confident that there will be enough other errors to drown out any surviving signal.
- eru 14y agoI'd guess, if they know (and mention) Moore's second law, you are almost guaranteed a good article.
- btilly 14y ago3 of the 4 are good. The last is not. Reed's law is a extremely optimistic version of Metcalfe's law which gives clearly nonsensical results. And Metcalfe's law in turn seems to be overly optimistic. See http://spectrum.ieee.org/computing/networks/metcalfes-law-is-wrong http://spectrum.ieee.org/computing/networks/metcalfes-law-is... for evidence that the real scaling law tends to be more like n log(n). (See http://www.dtc.umn.edu/~odlyzko/doc/metcalfe.pdf http://www.dtc.umn.edu/~odlyzko/doc/metcalfe.pdf for several other lines of argument leading to the same result.) Note that when I say "tends to be" I mean that, depending on the details of a social network, the scaling law can differ. In particular a network that relies on relative strangers having interactions with other relative strangers, as happens with eBay and Airbnb, is going to scale much closer to Metcalfe's Law. By contrast one that depends on developing a circle of friends, such as happens with Facebook, the scaling law will be closer to n log(n). Disclaimer, I have a bias here since I'm one of the co-authors of the n log(n) law. (Andrew Odlyzko did all of the work. And then we found out that Bob Briscoe had independently arrived at the same conclusion based on data that he had access to at British Telecom.)
- jcr 14y agoThe trouble I have with Metcalfe's Law and similar is that all of them are far too optimistic. Most English speakers have heard the phrase, "Point of diminishing returns," and such points do exist. Worse yet, there's also the phrase "Collapse under its own weight," describing the point where something got so big or widespread to retain its integrity, so its groth essentially harmed itself and failed. If you look around, you'll see this kind of diminishing returns and self destruction in a lot of different places, from "social" environments like this forum, to your over-flowing email box, to the constant interruption of your cell phone.
- btilly 14y agoIt is definitely true that a vocal minority of users are destructive to any network they find themselves in. Examples of negative users include things like trolls and spammers. Another problem is that the natural desire of the people running the network to monetize it creates incentives to weaken the experience. Both of these can lead to sub-linear growth in overall value as a network grows. But measuring value is already hard. Modeling all of the ways to screw up a network is even harder, and I doubt that there is any simple approximate general law that describes it.
- lsc 14y agoI am consistently amazed by the durability of this "cloud" hype. I mean, it's been at the peak of the hype cycle now for what, six years? I have been expecting a backlash for most of that time, and even now, when I make comments that are not glowing about "cloud" I get funny looks. Part of this is that 'the cloud' is now how we refer to perfectly ordinary services that have been around as long as the web, like FTP space. I mean, I walked in on a group of guys discussing their 'time machine' backup scheme for their mac. Now, being a service provider with a whole lot of disk, my first thought, of course, was "can I sell some kind of standards-based something that will let people time-machine to my hard drives in a datacenter?" I got about half way through asking if such a thing existed, and they said, "Oh, you mean backup to the cloud?" at which an involuntary scoffing noise escaped my throat. (the upshot is that apparently you can backup the time machine data to 'the cloud' but the people I talked to did not know what mechanism was used to upload/store the data.)
- 001sky 14y agoThis is an interesting observation. I wonder, too, how much of this is due to changing definitions of [cloud], over time.
- bpatrianakos 14y agoChanging definitions of the cloud? As far as I can tell the only definitions of the cloud that ever existed were basically: 1. On the Internet in a general sense. Somehow "cloud" became synonymous with Internet for many people and I can't figure out why. The weird part is that people who use "cloud" to mean Internet also use the term Internet to describe the same services the "cloud" offers. To me this makes me think marketing made this so. Somehow Dropbox is a cloud service but gmail (or hotmail or whatever email provider) is on the Internet according to many. How is that? 2. Definition 2 is basically the same as 1 but more specific. People use "cloud" to refer to anything connected to a server except you access the server through a service and all the specifics like hostnames and such are abstracted away. Like iCloud for Mac. I just don't get all the fuss about the Cloud and I'm glad there's someone else out there that scoffs when they hear the term. How is Amazon EC2 "in the cloud"? As far as I can tell its a VPS with some neat scaling features. How is Heroku and other app hosting services "in the cloud"? Again, what I see is VPS hosting with even more abstraction on top of Amazon's abstraction. Whenever I did freelance development work for people they'd ask if the hosting I offered was in the cloud. First off, why does that matter (well the people who ask for it claim it's better but can't explain why)? Second, what does that even mean? If it means will your site be hosted on a server connected to the Internet then yeah I suppose you can cal it the cloud. About a year ago I noticed some copy on MediaTemple's page for either their (ve) or (dve) hosting offerings that say something to the effect of "some people call it the cloud but we prefer to think of it as... (some very same logical explanation here)". I was happy to see it because in the end, as far as I can tell there's no difference between the cloud and one or more servers accessible via the Internet. Maybe to non-technical people having their information and data available across all devices by syncing with a remote server is novel and can only be understood by using the cloud metaphor. To them, the "cloud" is this vague thing on the internets that's all knowing and always available that's the next revolution in computing. To me it's just a client and server connecting and exchanging data. It's been there since I was a kid. The only difference is that now my phone, my car, and even my fridge can connect to it (for some strange reason) but its still just a damn server like we've had since before 56k modems.
- monochromatic 14y agoThat first graph could be a lot clearer.
- TimPC 14y agoReed's Law is arguing that the number of cliques I can participate in on a social network is more important than the number of "friends". The number of cliques tends to grow exponentially in the number of users except: (i) Social networks are extremely sparse.. the most well connected nodes have 5000 out of hundreds of millions of users. This greatly reduces then number of available cliques (although does still leave it exponential). (ii) Many of the connections are quite weak.. my interest in a random clique of a social graph in which I'm a member is almost always zero. (iii) Most cliques that provide value can be extended into other cliques by inviting members, so I may only be interested in maximal cliques, a further significant winnowing. (iv) Cliques aren't even the greatest representation of this because most groups I participate in on a social network don't have all-to-all friending. On the whole though I expect the effect of disinterest in most cliques, and improving the interested one's to optimality by extension reduces the cliques I'm actually interested to something far slower than exponential.
- bootload 14y ago'Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic' Arthur C. Clarke You could add more. I particularly like this Clarke observation. cf http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke%27s_three_laws http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke%27s_three_laws