3 ms·
There is a popular Russian saying, “A laughter without a reason is a sign of stupidity” I'd read this, and spent a couple weeks in Russia last fall, and notice
by mgkimsal 14y ago
There is a popular Russian saying, “A laughter without a reason is a sign of stupidity”
I'd read this, and spent a couple weeks in Russia last fall, and noticed the lack of smiling a lot when I was there. The thing that struck me about that mindset, and particularly that phrase (and others like it) is that it presumes the person looking at me knows if I have a reason to smile/laugh or not.
There's no doubt a lot of layers in the thinking that produced that (and similar) phrases which I can't unravel or fathom, but it's still strange all the same. To presume someone is stupid if you see them laughing is certain a cultural thing. Here (US) we'd probably just assume they were happy.
- jarek 14y ago> To presume someone is stupid if you see them laughing is certain a cultural thing. Here (US) we'd probably just assume they were happy. But on the flip side, a lot of people in the U.S. would assume someone is sad or angry if they are not smiling. There are examples in comments here.
- mlvljr 14y agoThe phrase ("смех без причины -- признак дурачины") makes a statement on a cause-less laughter only, and knowing if there's a cause for it hence out of its scope. Speaking culturally, in a country with a "historic code" built around Mongol enslavement, Napoleon struggle (200 years to Borodino was just yestreday, btw) and crushing Hitler (losing around 25 million people, both civil and military), only a slightly off-his-mind person would laugh w/o obvious reasons :) [in spite of a smiley, I'm dead serious] Many (if not most, actually) not-that-cheerful old men and ladies in the streets of StPetersburg remember Leningrad blockade, for example (like my grandma), and memories like that never make one too eager to smile w/o feeling a real cause for it. We (Russians) just usually lack a "polite" smile a western-world person is used to; being perceived as honest to others is graded much higher when being formally polite, correct, or tolerant. So do not panic next time ;)