5 ms·
China Is Run by Engineers, and the US by Too Many Lawyers
- Grace2025Rachel 1y agoFrom my experience, Chinese engineers listened to CCP - they are engineering tools for their ruler. For example, the Three-Gorge dam project was opposed by many geologists and scientists. But the party wanted so the engineers helped the party. There are many such examples. The impact assessments are mostly fake so nobody really take these serious like we do in the West.
- bigyabai 1y agoBut if you deregulate America, then you inherently create a market where lawyers rule. I'm fine with the status-quo.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> But if you deregulate America ...how does building more and putting more engineers in positions of power mean deregulation? To the extent the article has a position on this, it's for deproceduralisation. Not deregulation per se.
- yetihehe 1y agoImplementing rules made by lawyers|engineers makes good environment for lawyers|engineers. Deregulation implemented by lawyers|engineers makes good environment for lawyers|engineers. Deregulation implemented by politicians or laypersons doesn't make good environment for engineers or lawyers. So yes, not all deregulation and not all regulation will be good for engineers. Putting engineers in positions of power will mean that engineers will make and remove laws that are good for engineers. When engineers are happy with rules, they can FINALLY go do what they want which typically results in engineering products, which most people like after lawyers say things like "no, a steel sword is not a good educational toy for children". Reality is not simple.
- aspenmayer 1y agoI can’t really put my finger on it, but I think there’s a kind of sandbagging going on on vote-weighted social media sites, where folks in favor of the status quo make really incongruous or non sequitur statements as a kind of red herring bullet sponge for corrections, because they may suspect that the good corrections will get downranked by proxy when their own comment gets downvoted. I see similar things in sports, where leading competitors intentionally lower their performance in qualifying rounds so that they get a better seed advantage and easier competition going forward in the bracket. Have you seen this before on HN or online generally? I’m seeing it more online lately.
- ronsor 1y agoIt's awfully bold to claim that the US is obsessed with making rules, and China isn't. China is similarly full of rules (in fact, likely moreso), but they have less rule of law, so they aren't enforced consistently. The US has more rule of law (for now), so enforcement is (was) more consistent. And of course, if anyone's too good at making rules, it's the EU.
- hilbert42 1y ago"It's awfully bold to claim that the US is obsessed with making rules, and China isn't." Of course China is obsessed with rules just like many countries are, and it's pretty clear it firmly polices its laws. The difference is that after the death of Mao in 1976 Deng Xiaoping consciously and openly embarked on a task to pull China into the modern technological era, and to do that he deliberately set out to populate China's Politburo with highly educated engineers and like. (I gave references to this in a HN post a short while ago.) Thus, for nearly 50 years China has been run by the best brains available rather than those who've the gift of the gab and promise the electorate whatever it takes to get them elected. Sure that's not democracy and many of us in the West find it irksome. However, like it or not, over the last 50 years China's rulers have run a command economy and worked an economic miracle. Deng Xiaoping's insight of getting the best and brightest to run the country was brilliant, unlike most dictators he chose a course of action that actually benefited China. There's no question about that, the evidence is there for all the world to see.
- kelseyfrog 1y agoWhich poses an interesting consequence. It's not exactly controversial to generalize HN's sentiment that the US would be better off with more engineers and experts in elected office, which all other things being equal, implies that the US should be more like China.
- insane_dreamer 1y agoThe problem is that it’s more of a dictatorship now with Xi than it was after Deng. It’s not longer the best and brightest but those loyal to Xi. That’s how you got highly capable people like Li Keqiang sidelined and many others purged altogether on “corruption “ charges. A benevolent dictator can be beneficial for a country in crisis (the original Roman idea of a dictator which was a temporary position), like you could argue Deng was, but it’s not a good model for long-term governance.
- aurizon 1y agoThe USA is run by too many dummies, China has a far higher number of graduates in tech, although China also has many 'purchased' degrees - the hiring of a winger to pass exams
- laughing_man 1y agoWell, okay. But China also has a lot of environmental and governance disasters. One thing lawyers help do is protect normal people from large companies and government officials who exceed their mandate. Would you be okay with companies near you just dumping toxic waste into the local rivers?
- tstrimple 1y agoI don't know what you're talking about. That is the current reality in the US. We have no recourse. https://www.yahoo.com/news/disastrous-figures-show-poverty-iowas-112015430.html https://www.yahoo.com/news/disastrous-figures-show-poverty-i... > Runoff and soil erosion continually pour dangerous chemicals into bodies of water statewide. The pollution starves fish of oxygen. It causes organic material to grow that threatens to sicken humans unless drinking water providers spend huge sums on decontamination. It similarly makes water unsafe for recreation. This spring’s heavy rainfall ended years of drought — and it also, as predicted, led to levels of nitrates in rivers above or near the highest on record.
- laughing_man 1y agoI don't know what you're talking about either. Farm runoff is a whole different beast than mercury compounds or cyanide.
- gnerd00 1y ago> We have no recourse. This is just misinformation. This is an international board. Many readers will take this as fact. There are courts and there are laws on the books, and yes many cases are enforced. Not "enough" for some, "too much" for others.. it is a "Goldilocks Problem" .. comparing the situation across the USA does not make a lot of sense either, since State's Rights historically have played a big role.
- tstrimple 1y agoWhat a crock of shit. Yeah, it's an international board but we're talking about the ability of countries to support AI development. And outside of the US and China there is basically nothing going on. Maybe your country doesn't allow rampant pollution to be dumped into water streams. That's great! But then your country matters fuck all to the state of AI development. But it's absolute bullshit to pretend that China allows rampant ecological destruction in their pursuit of goals and then pretend that the US is constrained by some pollution restrictions. It has zero basis in reality and contributes nothing to the discussion. You are the one supporting misinformation.
- vunderba 1y agoOnly tangentially related, but during the height of the Covid crisis I remember Taiwan's response was particularly efficient. The vice president of Taiwan from 2016-2020 was Chen Chien-jen (陳建仁) - a man with a DOCTORATE in epidemiology. The last time the United States had a presidential figure with any kind of STEM background was probably Jimmy Carter (bachelors of science and served as a navy nuclear engineer) - nearly 50 years ago.
- DiogenesKynikos 1y agoThe mainland Chinese response to Covid was very similar to the Taiwanese response, but the media perception of the two was completely different.
- Barrin92 1y ago>Only tangentially related, but during the height of the Covid crisis I remember Taiwan's response was particularly efficient I think it's pretty related on the cultural side. If you look at how Taiwan succeeded, it's basically two fold. On the population's side it was willingness to follow orders, wear masks, get tracked using a smartphone app if you were sick and they were pretty damn strict about this. In particular mask wearing is a common courtesy in much of East Asia long before covid. On the tech/politics side they were lucky to have people like Audrey Tang. But let's put it that way the chances that the US put a trans hacker who writes Perl implementations in Haskell for fun in a top cabinet position and for Americans to accept East Asian levels of collective discipline is well, not looking to good to put it mildly
- vunderba 1y agoGreat points. Another reason masking wasn't all that unusual was the prevalence of two-stroke engines in scooters (at least back when I lived there) which tend to put out a bit more pollution.
- tamimio 1y ago[flagged]
- vdupras 1y agoCommon accepted knowledge around here is that greed is good and that capitalism works because of it. Fine, let's accept it. But here's my pet theory and here why I think we see cracks forming up in this "greed is good" mantra (which, frankly, hurts common sense of anyone living in a judeo-christian culture, because, well, isn't greed a sin?): this only works in a world of expanding EROEI (Energy Return On Energy Investment). This cheap energy is basically a giganormous pool of energy slaves. As long as there are slaves to capture, greed is good because it's good for everyone to capture and distribute as many slaves as possible. When that pool dwindles, greed stops working as well as it did for the advancement of public good and it begins cannibalizing on it (the public good). It still gets accepted as a truism today, but it will soon go back to sin territory.
- linotype 1y agoThe anti-US sentiment is exhausting. If you don’t like the US, stop using our technology and our markets.
- saubeidl 1y agoThose two are directly related. The common thread is US imperialism.
- linotype 1y agoAs if China isn’t also building towards that same position.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> anti-US sentiment is exhausting How is saying America should have more engineers in positions of power anti-American?
- linotype 1y agoIt’s a well known issue that’s been beaten to death.
- VerminOctopus1 1y agoOkay, that’s still not anti-American in any way.
- dumah 1y agoWhat a fallacy to equate the status quo of lawyers running the country with the United States itself.
- os2warpman 1y ago> stop using our technology and our markets That's exactly what's happening. Like, it's happening before our very eyes. Right now. Hubris, arrogance, and entitlement led us here and the world is taking your suggestion to heart.
- raincom 1y agohttps://archive.is/tdtMy https://archive.is/tdtMy
- Gibbon1 1y agoIf you know your history the US has always been run by lawyers until about 50 years ago when it started being run by MBA's and Finance Capitalists.
- rorylawless 1y agoWho went on to train the lawyers and judges in the MBA/Friedman orthodoxy.
- saubeidl 1y ago*ideology.
- powerapple 1y agoPeople in the US thinks it is a bad thing that US is run by lawyers? I would argue differently. The real difference is that China is a developing country, and US is a developed country. China should focus more on growing the pie and US should focus more on sharing the pie, hence lawyers to set up rules and regulations.