5 ms·
Your comment made me realize why my comment was wrong: the issue isn't listening in, the issue is recording. Recording someone else's conversation without the
by aidenn0 14y ago
Your comment made me realize why my comment was wrong: the issue isn't listening in, the issue is recording. Recording someone else's conversation without the permission of a participant is illegal in most states.
- dmishe 14y agoWhat if you memorise it and then put on paper?
- rosser 14y agoExactly. Even in the "one-party" consent states (which is most of them), where a conversation, phone or otherwise, can be recorded if only one of the participants is aware of the recording, it's illegal almost everywhere to record a conversation you're not a party to.
- tedunangst 14y agoWhat about recording the police beating somebody on the sidewalk?
- rosser 14y agoI wasn't aware that the intersection of truncheons and skulls was a "conversation".
- tedunangst 14y agoThe policeman is likely to be saying something. And his focus is on the victim, and therefore unaware of the recording. So do we still think that should be illegal to record?
- dllthomas 14y agoA policeman operating in the course of his duties has a modified set of permissions, rights, and restrictions.
- tedunangst 14y agoThe policeman having more restrictions does not automatically mean you have fewer restrictions. Your recording is also likely to pick up the conversation of the people nearby saying "hey look at that".
- rosser 14y agoWhat the people nearby are saying is incidental to the thing you're actually recording, though. It's the same thing as, or very similar to taking a video while you're on vacation: the police aren't going to bust down your door and haul you away because your camcorder's mic happened to pick up a conversation between the people standing three feet away from you. When you break out a parabolic mic and start recording conversations from 30 meters away — without the knowledge or consent of the people having that conversation — however, you're doing something that's at best creepy, and probably also illegal. EDIT: It would also probably be illegal to, in the course of taking your vacation video of whales breaching or whatever, instead start specifically recording a conversation happening nearby. IANAL, but I think the distinction has more to do with what you intend to record than what you happen to record. You don't have a "reasonable expectation of privacy" in public, but you do have a "reasonable expectation" of not being deliberately and specifically recorded by some random creeper while out in public. EDIT 2: Further, with as often as it happens, and pursuant to the DoJ's own statements on the subject, the police don't have a "reasonable expectation" of not being recorded when they're going about their jobs — particularly when, in the course of executing said job, they end up beating someone into unconsciousness...
- tedunangst 14y agoPersonally, I feel such matters are resolved by the simple rule that things happening in public spaces are public, and things happening in private spaces are private. One can argue about public vs private spaces, but it removes intent and expectations from the equation. Are you outside your house? If yes, expect to have all your actions recorded and available to be streamed on the internet.
- hack_edu 14y agoIt is legal, though I can only speak to US law. Its just that the police can take it as evidence, and that makes the task of making it 'disappear' pretty simple. Some jurisdictions also require the officer to be made aware of the recording as it goes on.
- joshAg 14y agoI think that it is legal to record someone else's conversation without permission if it is in public, since there is no expectation of privacy in a public place.
- mattmanser 14y agoBut there is in this case, you have to take extraordinary steps and specifically ask your network card to enter a special mode to start recording these conversations. They aren't public at all as there is an expectation at the protocol level that you ignore the message that aren't intended for you. And they're explicitly flagged that they're not for you. You're opening mail addressed to someone else and you know you're doing it. It's not legal to start opening other people's mail because it's lying in the same hallway as yours. This is exactly the same thing. This judge just doesn't understand that. The legal expert is right, the judge will end up with egg on his face. Why they don't just do a bit of street theatre like 'Here is a letter addressed to the judge. Because of the way the postal system works I got it as well. I am now opening it and reading it. Is this ok? No. Of course not. It's not for me. This is exactly what they deliberately did but it's just digital.'
- anigbrowl 14y agoYou're opening mail addressed to someone else and you know you're doing it. It's not legal to start opening other people's mail because it's lying in the same hallway as yours. This is exactly the same thing. No it isn't, because the mail is in a closed envelope whereas unencrypted activity over wifi is equivalent to a public conversation that can easily be overheard. The steps required to sniff open traffic are hardly extraordinary. Why they don't just do a bit of street theatre like 'Here is a letter addressed to the judge. Because of the way the postal system works I got it as well. I am now opening it and reading it. Is this ok? No. Of course not. It's not for me. This is exactly what they deliberately did but it's just digital.' Well, no. If traffic is not encrypted then it is public in the same manner as a postcard. It's illegal to open people's mail, but you can't practically prevent people reading what's written on a postcard.
- 14y ago