5 ms·
Ask HN: What is the consensus on Hacker News?
A thread currently at the top of the Hacker News main page includes comments mentioning issues on which most Hacker News users agreed a few years ago, and other issues on which most users agree these days. Users are speculating about HN's "broader sentiments" and others are mentioning "fanboys" or "echo-chamberism."
As far as I know, no one reads Hacker News exhaustively. I certainly don't. I miss hundreds of threads each week now, not even having time to lurk in them. So I'm not sure if Hacker News today has any consensus points of view. What do you think? Within the scope of the site's guidelines (which were recently revised) what are the issues on which most users here agree, and what are the issues on which there are vigorous debate?
- Piskvorrr 14y agoI think you have just spawned a recursive argument, which Segmentation fault
- hiddenstage 14y agoAfter lurking for a few months, here are a few "consensus" issues that come to mind (again, this is just the majority of users - certainly not all): - Macbooks are the best laptops - iOS is preferred over Android (both in use and development) - PHP is terrible - Facebook is the devil A few common debates here are: - Ruby vs. Python - Rails vs. Django - Google (whether they are evil or helpful) - Whether or not we are in a startup bubble
- S4M 14y agoOther "consensus" you forgot: - lisp is good, java is bad - working in a big co sucks - rms is awesome - pg is awesome
- brudgers 14y agolisp is good, java is bad And this makes Clojure...?? There is plenty of dislike for Lisp and acceptance of Java.
- dylanpyle 14y agoI think you'll find the common theme being Java hate, but a general love-hate relationship with the JVM (clojure, scala both have their fanboys and critics).
- DanBC 14y agoThere is a vocal group (maybe also sizable?) who think that rms is not awesome.
- tokenadult 14y agoThank you for your substantive reply. Sure enough, your reply illustrates that each reader of HN sees a different nonexhaustive subset of all threads here, and perhaps perceives a different consensus. - Macbooks are the best laptops It's interesting to me that you mention this, because it has been several years since I have owned a current laptop computer, and I have utterly no opinion about which brand of laptop is the best. I guess I almost never read threads on HN that even bring up the issue. - iOS is preferred over Android (both in use and development) I sure don't read these threads exhaustively either. I own an Android phone, since a bit more than a year ago, and I try to figure out the user experience in the Android ecosystem, which I have found annoying with my mobile service provider's default installation. - PHP is terrible My perception is that the consensus here is "PHP is a kludge language, but very useful for applications all the same," but I could be mistaken. - Facebook is the devil The consensus I perceive on that issue (I could be wrong) is "Facebook is a company that has overreached often in its attempts to monetize, but it offers great opportunities for some advertisers who use its platform." I have no experience with Facebook except as a daily user. I have predicted "Facebook will go the way of AOL, still being a factor in the industry years from now, but also serving as an example of a company that could never monetize up to the level of the hype surrounding it." I could be wrong, but that's my sense of where Facebook is in the market. A few common debates here are: - Ruby vs. Python It's interesting to someone who started posting webpages as long ago as I did that Perl isn't mentioned in this context anymore. - Rails vs. Django That one does seem to be balanced pretty well between the two sides, with no clear HN consensus. - Google (whether they are evil or helpful) My impression, by contrast, is that most HN users think Google is helpful in many of its business activities. - Whether or not we are in a startup bubble Yes, this general issue is debated, as is the valuation of particular companies.
- 27182818284 14y agoI"m not the oldest user, but I'm older and I whole-heartily agree with your observations. For MacBooks, just search for threads with "best laptop." For iOS, I mean this pg post immediately came to mind http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4332278 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4332278. And so on.
- polyfractal 14y agoAlso: -vi(m) vs. emacs -Taxes (and governments) are abominations -Talking about funding -SEO is evil -Marketing is evil -Conversely, "Growth Hacking" is cool And the general sentiment that, despite being a board about entrepreneurship and startups, taking money from people in a business transaction is evil. There is a lot of double-think on HN about money, particularly if it is paired with marketing and advertising.
- brudgers 14y agoThere is an historical bias in favor of Google and Apple. Somewhat contradictorily, there are biases in favor of privacy and open source. Other large companies tend not to be seen as positively. On the hardware side, ARM is favored over Intel. Politically and culturally, HN tends to US centric with an Anglo shell.
- viraptor 14y agoI'm not sure if Google part contradicted the other ideas until a few years ago. Easily available software, open-access quality services, clients available for linux (even if not open-source, it's still something), they contributed to many projects like the linux kernel, published go, worked on Android which is... corporate-flavoured open-source, etc. They were very much about geeky stuff and easily available information. Google groups were also popular with open-source projects. Also in all cases at some point in the past favouring those companies was about rooting for the underdog... and then just continued even when they became large and abusive in some cases.
- brudgers 14y agoApple v Open Source (particularly since the iPhone). Google v Privacy (always).
- andremendes 14y agoMy 2 cents on what I think is consensus here: Javascript frameworks are cool Public API's are good VIM is awesome
- jcr 14y agotokenadult, from all of the things I've read from you over the years, I believe you are too kind and well intentioned to notice the reality of the situation. Then again, maybe I'm too harsh and jaded. If you're as jaded as I am, you've already realized that the ancient days when people put great stuff on the Internet because they enjoyed working on it are long gone. The commercial interest of the web combined with human vanity have transformed the Internet into a for-profit popularity contest. The vast bulk of submissions to HN support this, both the stuff on the front page, and all of the countless things that have slid off of the 'newest' page into oblivion. A large part of the supposed "sentiments" show in comments, submissions, and voting/flagging are really just playing to the crowd. Though it might be offensive to some, the typical phrase is "karma whoring." It's really just human nature at work; if you buy or buy into some expensive widget, you promote your choice publicly to gather the esteem of your peers. Similarly, if you abandon something, you disparage it publicly to promote your choice and gather the esteem of your peers. Using gmail/google? Bought an Apple? Programming in javascript? Love/Hate copyrights? All of the "consensus" issues boil down to pimping for profit and praise, or resisting the resentments of others. A prime example is, when was the last time you saw someone really speak out against javascript? It does happen on occasion, but voicing a negative opinion of javascript is always severely punished -- negative comments threatens the capacity of js coders to make a living, so they respond harshly. As noted by others, positive opinions of javascript are promoted endlessly, and for the opposite reason -- positive comments increase the value/income of js coders, so they respond beneficially. There are plenty of people on HN that work for the big companies (Apple, Google, Twitter, Facebook, Amazon, and gasp, Microsoft), so the pimping and punishing is rampant on every mention of any of them. As harsh as it might sound, the people employed by these companies have vested interest in promoting and protecting them. If someone disparaged the value of the skill you use to make a living, how would you react? On the flip side, if someone praised the value of the skill you use to make a living, how would you react? (For the record, I'm a typical human language monoglot, so I absolutely envy your skill with the Chinese language!) ... ... ... ... ... Did my admission of envy for your skills make you feel good or proud of your abilities? ... ... ... ... ... Maybe that was just what I wanted you to feel... If you have far too much free time and spend it watching the /newest queue, you'll see the attempted manipulation of HN by both vested parties and professional marketers. Their efforts are continuous, and their goal is manufacturing "consensus" by any means possible. The self-reinforcing echo chambers seen on HN and elsewhere are entirely intentional, completely dubious in nature, and created specifically for the sake of profit. When you hear an echo, the only rational question is, "Who profits from this?" With all of the above said, we still see people asking tough questions and others responding in an honest attempt to contribute help. It's the very best part of HN. Unfortunately, the bright sparks of HN have been slowly fading in the face of contentious discussions, ever falling average technical acumen, and of course, the self-centered motivations behind promoting and punishing. I honestly don't know if the trend of decline is inevitable or reversible, but surprisingly, I like to believe the latter.
- csense 14y agoConsensuses I've noticed on HN: - Paypal screws merchants over. - Startups are cool. - PG is God. - The US should be more liberal, like SF or Europe.
- _delirium 14y agoAs an American who believes the last one (and moved to Denmark), I haven't felt that HN posters generally agree with me, unless you mean purely on social issues (e.g. discomfort with religious conservatism and support of gay rights). On economic issues there seem to be a lot of libertarians around, tempered mainly by a vocal group who're unhappy with the healthcare situation for freelancers and startups.
- DanBC 14y agoIf you mention some companies a few people will rabidly upvote your comment, and a few people will rabidly downvote your comment. It doesn't matter what your comment actually is. Online communities are used to this kind of religious war. It's sort of surprising to see it so blatantly here. TSA are always stupid, all the time. Patents are evil. (But no-one knows what to replace them with. And maybe they're only evil for software.) Facebook is evil and will destroy the Internet, but most certainly are violating all kinds of privacy laws.