4 ms·

Born and raised, and still living in an area that you likely wouldn't. You have no idea. To be clear, not advocating for the military on the streets. However,

Born and raised, and still living in an area that you likely wouldn't. You have no idea. To be clear, not advocating for the military on the streets. However, the people who do sympathize with that will forever increase as ineffectiveness in policing crime does. If the military is on the streets, and there is broad support for it, then objectively speaking it's because we're at a tipping point of imbalance in policing crime. The question then becomes, even with the military outside of their windows, would the people who start stuttering the word "fascist" in response have hindsight regret in not better enabling civilian policing to inhibit crime? Or will they continue to deny the tipping point? At what point is undermining of civilian police the same thing as advancing us toward military streets? No one can have everything. If a balance isn't kept, then aberrations in norms will begin to occur. Going either way.

Arainach 1y ago
There is no undermining, as everyone living in the cities realizes. In Seattle I'm sick of people who think the whole city burned down in 2020 or that you can't go downtown without a homeless person stabbing you with a needle. People who don't live here and watch Fox News are afraid. People in the suburbs who never go into the city are afraid. Anyone who spends any time in the city knows otherwise. For more than a decade I've walked the streets in every neighborhood here weekly, often after dark, carrying thousands of dollars in camera gear, not bothering to hide my watch, phone, or whatever, and never been harassed.
- mrangle 1y ago
  >There is no undermining, as everyone living in the cities realizes. I remember that "Defund the Police" is the general mantra of one side of the isle. You aren't paying attention. I stated that I was born and raised in a (major) city, and I still live in an area that many on HN and virtually all bourgeoise urban-bubble people would not live. And so who are you trying to gaslight, exactly? I don't assert that Seattle is perfect, but Seattle is a cakewalk. One of the nicest and per-capita wealthiest cities in the country. But with a sizeable population of bored grown toddlers. A subgroup of whom are professional terrorists, while living in a priveleged city on the World scale. Spare me your faux "urbanite on a walk" homily. The nine months of rioting in 2020 were nine months of partisan terrorism purposefully leading exactly up to an election. Funny that, in the context of those so concerned with democracy. We were terrorized, absolutely. It caused me to think twice about voting at all, out of fear. During one weekend in which police were hamstrung by the mayor in favor of rioters, we had two large bombs go off in my neighborhood. While the power happened to be off for 72 hours. Have you ever felt the deep vibration from a close domestic terrorist bomb in the dark? Twice? How about during election season? Would you like to go into my personal experiences with urban crime? How many gun barrels have you stared down? How many times have you been punched in public by a stranger, while just standing there? How many times did that lead to a full blown street fight, out of self-defense? How many times have you been robbed on the sidewalk? How many friends of yours have been targeted and murdered on the sidewalk? How about while in grade school? Yes, I'm Caucasian. I'm overeducated, including graduating on a full-ride from a school that existed a long time before the United States did. That makes no difference. You deserve a string of derogatory names, but decorum prevents.
  - Arainach 1y ago
    >I remember that "Defund the Police" is the general mantra of one side of the isle. And I remember that that was about focusing police on policing and spending more on having specialists provide social support and the kind of things that prevent crime, which cops aren't trained to do or any good at.
    - mrangle 1y ago
      [flagged]
      - saulpw 1y ago
        Not OP, but yes, "defund" meaning to reverse the excessive budgetary increases of the past 5-10 years, which increased militarization of police, alongside increasing qualified immunity precedent. Some people took "Defund The Police" to mean "No Police" (there will always be extremists, sincere or planted), and it turned out to be a terrible slogan for this reason. There's a healthy middle ground in which the police force is reduced to a reasonable level, and other services are funded, so the police with their guns and military training aren't the first responders when e.g. someone is suicidal or spraypainting graffiti. And even if the suicidal person is holding a knife, or it's my house being spraypainted, I don't want the person shot!
        mrangle 1y ago
        Ok, so still undermining. Got it. Irrelevant babble aside that was already read and refuted with wikipedia information.
  - nobody9999 1y ago
    >Would you like to go into my personal experiences with urban crime? How many gun barrels have you stared down? More than one. >How many times have you been punched in public by a stranger, while just standing there? More than once. >How many times have you been robbed on the sidewalk? Once, as a child because I wasn't paying attention. As a teen? Several attempts on the subway, on the street and other places. As an adult? On the Brooklyn Bridge. So. Where exactly did all this stuff happen to you, eh? I call bullshit on your "horror stories."
- dh2022 1y ago
  Hmm, to your anecdotes I will add mine. I have been harassed in the International District at around 10:00 pm by drug dealers - was offered drugs, told them to go away so I was yelled “Get off my block”. A hobo spilled his beer on my wife while riding the bus. A female coworker was offered oral sex by a hobo and asked to take her glasses off to “see her pretty eyes”. At a bus school stop on Fairview (right next to Amazon Campus) a hobo with his pants down to his knees was exposing himself in front of some kids (their mothers were trying to make some shield around the kids) All of these around 2021-2022-2023. We moved out of Seattle in 2023. Maybe these snecdotes are not a big deal for you. For me they are scary.
ryandrake 1y ago
> If the military is on the streets, and there is broad support for it, then objectively speaking it's because we're at a tipping point of imbalance in policing crime. Where is this "broad support" coming from? The actual people living in Washington DC, or rural outsiders who have conjured up some picture in their minds of "crime infested cities?" If you did a poll of everyone in DC, would the majority be in favor of increased policing? It always seems like the people who are most vocal about crime in big cities are always the people who don't live in or visit those big cities.
- mrangle 1y ago
  I live in a high crime area of a major city.
  - nobody9999 1y ago
    Which city? Which "high crime area?" Crime is down all across the US and way down in most major cities. Let's see some statistics, friend. I live in NYC[0] and I'm old. It's never been safer in the many decades I've been alive. And the police have little to do with that. They're just the biggest and best-armed gang. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_New_York_City[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_New_York_City[1] [1] In fact, NYC saw fewer murders in 2024 than any year since 1958 -- long before my parents ever met.
    - mrangle 1y ago
      I'm not your friend, palooka. You questioning my experience and where I live isn't an argument. In liberal circles, we "believe" people. Remember? Especially those with bad experiences. You questioning me just means that you can't tolerate people with differing experiences having opinions and perspectives that are counter to your own. What I said is factual. You're a sheltered person with a false entitlement to an opinion on this specific matter. I live in a major city between Boston and DC. I've implied enough of my experience to warrant telling you to shove your rude scare quotes up your a*. I've also lived in NYC. I have family that still lives in NYC. Who was just punched in the face for the second time in a couple of years, walking home at night. And that's in "safe" lower Manhattan. What does where you live have to do where I live? Just like the "person who walks with cameras", the only thing that you are communicating is that you are privileged and awful on a couple of levels. One of which is having zero perspective and real experience living in an urban area that is outside of wealthier zones and, especially in poorer cities, is only barely managed by police. Bourgeoise bubble living does not entitle you to having a policy opinion on how the poorer areas of cities should be managed, what it's like living in them let alone growing up in them, and on how they are doing on the street level. "Relativity" aside.

Arainach 1y ago

There is no undermining, as everyone living in the cities realizes. In Seattle I'm sick of people who think the whole city burned down in 2020 or that you can't go downtown without a homeless person stabbing you with a needle. People who don't live here and watch Fox News are afraid. People in the suburbs who never go into the city are afraid. Anyone who spends any time in the city knows otherwise. For more than a decade I've walked the streets in every neighborhood here weekly, often after dark, carrying thousands of dollars in camera gear, not bothering to hide my watch, phone, or whatever, and never been harassed.

mrangle 1y ago
>There is no undermining, as everyone living in the cities realizes. I remember that "Defund the Police" is the general mantra of one side of the isle. You aren't paying attention. I stated that I was born and raised in a (major) city, and I still live in an area that many on HN and virtually all bourgeoise urban-bubble people would not live. And so who are you trying to gaslight, exactly? I don't assert that Seattle is perfect, but Seattle is a cakewalk. One of the nicest and per-capita wealthiest cities in the country. But with a sizeable population of bored grown toddlers. A subgroup of whom are professional terrorists, while living in a priveleged city on the World scale. Spare me your faux "urbanite on a walk" homily. The nine months of rioting in 2020 were nine months of partisan terrorism purposefully leading exactly up to an election. Funny that, in the context of those so concerned with democracy. We were terrorized, absolutely. It caused me to think twice about voting at all, out of fear. During one weekend in which police were hamstrung by the mayor in favor of rioters, we had two large bombs go off in my neighborhood. While the power happened to be off for 72 hours. Have you ever felt the deep vibration from a close domestic terrorist bomb in the dark? Twice? How about during election season? Would you like to go into my personal experiences with urban crime? How many gun barrels have you stared down? How many times have you been punched in public by a stranger, while just standing there? How many times did that lead to a full blown street fight, out of self-defense? How many times have you been robbed on the sidewalk? How many friends of yours have been targeted and murdered on the sidewalk? How about while in grade school? Yes, I'm Caucasian. I'm overeducated, including graduating on a full-ride from a school that existed a long time before the United States did. That makes no difference. You deserve a string of derogatory names, but decorum prevents.
- Arainach 1y ago
  >I remember that "Defund the Police" is the general mantra of one side of the isle. And I remember that that was about focusing police on policing and spending more on having specialists provide social support and the kind of things that prevent crime, which cops aren't trained to do or any good at.
  - mrangle 1y ago
    [flagged]
    - saulpw 1y ago
      Not OP, but yes, "defund" meaning to reverse the excessive budgetary increases of the past 5-10 years, which increased militarization of police, alongside increasing qualified immunity precedent. Some people took "Defund The Police" to mean "No Police" (there will always be extremists, sincere or planted), and it turned out to be a terrible slogan for this reason. There's a healthy middle ground in which the police force is reduced to a reasonable level, and other services are funded, so the police with their guns and military training aren't the first responders when e.g. someone is suicidal or spraypainting graffiti. And even if the suicidal person is holding a knife, or it's my house being spraypainted, I don't want the person shot!
      - mrangle 1y ago
        Ok, so still undermining. Got it. Irrelevant babble aside that was already read and refuted with wikipedia information.
- nobody9999 1y ago
  >Would you like to go into my personal experiences with urban crime? How many gun barrels have you stared down? More than one. >How many times have you been punched in public by a stranger, while just standing there? More than once. >How many times have you been robbed on the sidewalk? Once, as a child because I wasn't paying attention. As a teen? Several attempts on the subway, on the street and other places. As an adult? On the Brooklyn Bridge. So. Where exactly did all this stuff happen to you, eh? I call bullshit on your "horror stories."
dh2022 1y ago
Hmm, to your anecdotes I will add mine. I have been harassed in the International District at around 10:00 pm by drug dealers - was offered drugs, told them to go away so I was yelled “Get off my block”. A hobo spilled his beer on my wife while riding the bus. A female coworker was offered oral sex by a hobo and asked to take her glasses off to “see her pretty eyes”. At a bus school stop on Fairview (right next to Amazon Campus) a hobo with his pants down to his knees was exposing himself in front of some kids (their mothers were trying to make some shield around the kids) All of these around 2021-2022-2023. We moved out of Seattle in 2023. Maybe these snecdotes are not a big deal for you. For me they are scary.

ryandrake 1y ago

> If the military is on the streets, and there is broad support for it, then objectively speaking it's because we're at a tipping point of imbalance in policing crime. Where is this "broad support" coming from? The actual people living in Washington DC, or rural outsiders who have conjured up some picture in their minds of "crime infested cities?" If you did a poll of everyone in DC, would the majority be in favor of increased policing? It always seems like the people who are most vocal about crime in big cities are always the people who don't live in or visit those big cities.

mrangle 1y ago
I live in a high crime area of a major city.
- nobody9999 1y ago
  Which city? Which "high crime area?" Crime is down all across the US and way down in most major cities. Let's see some statistics, friend. I live in NYC[0] and I'm old. It's never been safer in the many decades I've been alive. And the police have little to do with that. They're just the biggest and best-armed gang. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_New_York_City[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_New_York_City[1] [1] In fact, NYC saw fewer murders in 2024 than any year since 1958 -- long before my parents ever met.
  - mrangle 1y ago
    I'm not your friend, palooka. You questioning my experience and where I live isn't an argument. In liberal circles, we "believe" people. Remember? Especially those with bad experiences. You questioning me just means that you can't tolerate people with differing experiences having opinions and perspectives that are counter to your own. What I said is factual. You're a sheltered person with a false entitlement to an opinion on this specific matter. I live in a major city between Boston and DC. I've implied enough of my experience to warrant telling you to shove your rude scare quotes up your a*. I've also lived in NYC. I have family that still lives in NYC. Who was just punched in the face for the second time in a couple of years, walking home at night. And that's in "safe" lower Manhattan. What does where you live have to do where I live? Just like the "person who walks with cameras", the only thing that you are communicating is that you are privileged and awful on a couple of levels. One of which is having zero perspective and real experience living in an urban area that is outside of wealthier zones and, especially in poorer cities, is only barely managed by police. Bourgeoise bubble living does not entitle you to having a policy opinion on how the poorer areas of cities should be managed, what it's like living in them let alone growing up in them, and on how they are doing on the street level. "Relativity" aside.