4 ms·
Banks already do ask for financials and corporate track record. You're required to stake your own credit when your financials are inadequate. As far as I can s
by Silhouette 14y ago
Banks already do ask for financials and corporate track record. You're required to stake your own credit when your financials are inadequate.
As far as I can see, those providers who require personal guarantees usually do so as a standard condition for almost any new business. Effectively, they consider everyone's financials to be inadequate.
You want that to be illegal? It's better than those companies not be able to obtain merchant accounts?
Someone would still offer the merchant account services to businesses who could demonstrate a reasonable business plan, because on balance they would make money from doing so. Most new businesses are not, in fact, going to experience a 30% chargeback rate four months after the original sale.
The banks obviously know that, they just want (as usual) to privatise the profits but externalise the risks/losses. I have no problem with prohibiting that kind of predatory behaviour. It's a potentially significant barrier to starting a new business, and with the global economy in its current state, allowing absurdly risk-averse banks to inhibit new businesses is exactly what we shouldn't be doing.
If the banking industry had a track record of assessing its clients responsibly and lending (or not lending) based on the results of those assessments and reasonable assumptions, I would be happy to cut them some slack. But we all know damn well that they aren't doing that. And if governments are going to pressure them just to lend to small businesses, they should certainly pressure them to provide basic services to businesses that are viable without relying on loans as well.
- tptacek 14y agoIf someone could make money by offering merchant services to businesses with no credit history, they'd already be doing it. No law requires banks to require personal credit checks for merchant accounts.
- Silhouette 14y agoIf someone could make money by offering merchant services to businesses with no credit history, they'd already be doing it. They are already doing it, every time a new business opens an account with them. No law requires banks to require personal credit checks for merchant accounts. I'm not talking about credit checks, I'm talking about a personal guarantee, of the "taking your house" variety.
- tptacek 14y agoIf it's possible to build a viable business offering merchant account services backed by absolutely nothing other than the creditworthiness of a brand-new corporation, why is nobody doing that already?
- Silhouette 14y agoBecause they don't have to. The negotiating positions are entirely one-sided, and since they command all the power, they can essentially impose arbitrarily harsh terms to any extent the law permits.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm not sure you're following what I'm saying. That's probably my fault, for being terse. Even if the negotiating positions are "entirely one-sided" right now, that position leaves the door open for a competitor to capture market share by offering accounts without personal credit attachments. And yet nobody does that. That suggests one of two things: either (i) you can't capture much market share by offering easy terms for a merchant account (unlikely, to my mind) or (ii) you can't stay in business offering those terms.
- Silhouette 14y agoEven if the negotiating positions are "entirely one-sided" right now, that position leaves the door open for a competitor to capture market share by offering accounts without personal credit attachments. And yet nobody does that. Are you sure about that? That suggests one of two things: No, there are other possibilities. One is that the merchants assume that you're right and everyone is going to screw them the same way. Another is that they simply don't understand the profound legal implications of a couple of lines of small print and one more signature because, like most start-ups, they're trying to build a company and not paying lawyers thousands to review dozens of pages of terms sent by every financial service provider they've contacted.
- Spooky23 14y ago
- joe_littlebiz 14y ago"SQUARE" (square.com) does.