4 ms·
For me it doesn't really raise any interesting questions at all: things are statistically not 'bad' per se, besides, you could trade your democracy for an autoc
by jacquesm 1y ago
For me it doesn't really raise any interesting questions at all: things are statistically not 'bad' per se, besides, you could trade your democracy for an autocracy or a dictatorship and end up 'safe' from small crime but meanwhile have your whole country looted.
Maybe some people prefer that but I would rather have garden variety criminals and a trustworthy government fighting them than some kind of re-invention of the USSR, which didn't really bother with collecting crime statistics, and where crime was - so they claimed - very low (this really wasn't the case, especially not if you consider the behavior of lots of highly placed individuals, who could get away with just about anything, except of course stealing from their bosses).
- skajzbxbbj 1y ago[flagged]
- ethbr1 1y agoAs with the parent, I prefer civil liberties and small amounts of crime to any alternative. Which is why the playbook for authoritarianism traditionally starts with lying about how much crime there actually is, thus justifying a crackdown. If Trump wants to cite excessive crime as his reasoning, then he should provide statistics, not the unsubstantiated off-the-cuff insults he has thus far.
- throwawayqqq11 1y ago[flagged]
- energy123 1y ago[flagged]
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoThis is a particularly uneducated take. Violent crime is down massively from a few decades ago.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- energy123 1y agoYou refute that violent crime is a large factor that caused authoritarianism in El Salvador? The post I was responding to made it seem like democracy and violent crime can somehow coexist or that they aren't in strong tension with one another. When it's pretty clear that they are. I was not saying it's the only cause of authoritarianism, or the most relevant cause in the current US moment.
- onetimeusename 1y ago> I would rather have garden variety criminals and a trustworthy government fighting them What do you count as garden variety here and what makes you say the government is trustworthy? I think law enforcement has become extremely bureaucratic and that generally lawyers, but especially DC lawyers, view the criminal justice system as racist so they made it much less punitive and much more bureaucratic. The end result is more crime. Trump saw an opportunity and he is exploiting it even though it's stupid to fight crime this way. I would bet the worst that comes from this is we run an expensive experiment in seeing if NG patrols reduce crime. In a few months, this will be forgotten about. If I am wrong and this turns into a coup d'état or autocratic takeover, you can collect $100 from me.
- jacquesm 1y agoTrump is not fighting crime. He's fighting anything that doesn't kowtow to Trump.
- rayiner 1y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 1y agoTrump is systematically engaging in performative actions to distract from the simple fact that the USA has elected a conman, criminal and serial abuser of women to the highest office. And you are cheering him on.
- ben_w 1y agoThe only change I would make there is the "to" in "to distract". On the basis of his behaviour in courts, I recon there's a common cause for performative behaviour and him being a convicted criminal, rather than it being an instrumental behaviour intended to distract. He doesn't behave as if he has a mental model for the difference between "I did a bad thing and should be ashamed" vs. "I am having power struggle and must fight dirty", nor any concept of a lie beyond observing that "liar" is an insult. This isn't really an improvement, and other people may be playing him in this way for their own power games.
- rayiner 1y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 1y ago> Dude, no it’s not. Everyone is parroting the “crime dropped from 2023” line, but nobody mentions that the 2023 spike pushed DC’s murder rate to as high as Haiti. Not Haiti normally, but the recent events in Haiti where gangs took over the country, causing the homicide rate go spike from about 10 per 100k normally (safer than DC has ever been) to about as bad as DC in 2023. Why use 2023, rather than say 1991 as your baseline? And 2024 as the year to use for reference (it is the last year for which complete data is available, after all). And as for NYC, that wasn't dealt with on the Federal level but on the state and city level. And it left a power vacuum in the crime world that was soon taken up by others, which should have been dealt with rather than ignored. Who knew that policing cities of millions of individuals over decades is hard? Especially in countries where there are lots of weapons afloat. As for the comparison with Haiti you make (and not to mention Iraq, as you did elsewhere in this thread): countries, especially countries at war and places like Haiti do not excel in record keeping. As such you probably should take the numbers reported from those countries as somewhat polished before being presented.
- rayiner 1y ago> Why use 2023, rather than say 1991 as your baseline? Because numerous people in this thread have been parroting the line that homicides dropped since 2023. I'm pointing out that this is cherry picking, since homicides spiked to record highs in 2023. 1991 isn't a good baseline because policing trends started reversing in the 2000s. We did mass incarceration from 1980 until the early 2000s, and homicides dropped dramatically. El Salvador recently proved that you can more or less solve homicides by just putting a small fraction of the population in prison. > Especially in countries where there are lots of weapons afloat. That's just untrue. Puerto Rico has very few guns, and is an island so it's hard to get guns, but has a very high homicide rate. Meanwhile, half the people in Idaho have a gun, and Boise is has a homicide rate comparable to Toronto.
- 1y ago
- potato3732842 1y agoDemocracy gets traded for dictatorship because someone shows up and says "I might not be perfect but I'm a hell of a lot better than these schmucks who've been ruining things". And when that person saying that stuff shows up at a point in time when the people who have been in charge of things have run the country into the ground with wars, debts and policies that give people no hope that things will get better, it's a pretty compelling message.
- jacquesm 1y agoIt would be, if it were true. But the premise isn't true and the solution isn't true either. It just sounds good and people tend to respond from fear and other emotions rather than rationality.
- HumblyTossed 1y agoExcept that person is also the person who add 1/6 of the debt just himself and is doing it again just to make the wealthy wealthier.