3 ms·
Red states and the Federal Government don’t believe in climate change. Let them cover their own climate costs. California alone sends $86B to the Federal govern
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
Red states and the Federal Government don’t believe in climate change. Let them cover their own climate costs. California alone sends $86B to the Federal government. The moral hazard is covering the cost of bad faith actors acting in bad faith. Bootstraps and all that.
- giantg2 1y agoCA can't even get their own house in order. If they were serious, they would apply the wildlands fire code to all the new construction in LA after the recent fires, but they won't. The real moral hazard is thinking the risks, costs, and benefits are as clear cut as you're making them... plus the non-starter about implying not paying taxes.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoThey’re the world’s fourth largest economy (behind the US, China, and Germany), they’ll be fine economically. Red states actively choose to ignore climate change, with Texas going so far as to attempting to disadvantage renewables while supporting fossil fuels [1]. Florida’s insurance market is functionality insolvent [2]; they extend and pretend. Why would we financially help folks who don't believe in the active climate crisis? Vote for folks who dismantle FEMA? Vote for folks who rollback the inflation reduction act and climate mitigation spending [3]? Vote for folks who rollback vehicle emissions standards? Enjoy your vote. Better luck next time. [1] https://prospect.org/environment/2025-06-05-texas-legislature-beats-back-assault-on-clean-energy/ https://prospect.org/environment/2025-06-05-texas-legislatur... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2024-04-24/home-insurance-with-lax-oversight-hides-florida-climate-risk https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2024-04-24/home-insu... | https://archive.today/g8Ic5 https://archive.today/g8Ic5 [3] https://www.lw.com/en/insights/one-big-beautiful-bill-new-law-disrupts-clean-energy-investment https://www.lw.com/en/insights/one-big-beautiful-bill-new-la...
- giantg2 1y agoI'm not sure what you're even going off on at this point. You completely ignored my comment about how CA is handling things like fire code and fire insurance. It seems like youre just trying to start a political flame war.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI'm unsure how this isn't political. Some states are economic engines of the US, some states are net takers of resources. States that have resources by way of being economic engines should protect themselves from the coming impact of climate change (if one doesn't believe in climate change, or the impending risk it presents, don't bother replying, there is no common ground to be had). That's it, that's the thesis. How California is handling fire code and mitigation currently is somewhat immaterial; more importantly, they have the resources by way of their economy to fix the problem if and when they choose to (to spend to de-risk against fire risk). They have the economy of a developed nation state. They can spend whatever is required when they decide to appropriately spend. If you don't have the resources to defend against climate risk, or don't believe in the risk, you have little recourse against it. This could've been a collective action problem at the nation state level; it no longer is due to political choices by people who believe a global climate phenomenon is a hoax. So those who can afford it must go it alone for the foreseeable future.
- giantg2 1y agoSo according to you CA has the resources to rebuild themselves and should protect themselves, but you consider it immaterial that they are choosing not to protect themselves with fire code and insurance changes? This sounds classist - we can do whatever we want because we have money, but we don't want to pay taxes because that might help other states that are also making suboptimal choices. But both Florida and Texas (your examples) are also donor states. It's hard to find what the basis is for your thesis when it seems to be applied irrespective of the facts.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoYes, I am saying if you have the economic resources as a state, you should not help other states economically that do not believe in climate change (within the context of climate mitigation spending and transfers). Why would you help people working against you or who don't believe in what you're defending against?
- caligirla 1y agoSo, you believe that people with higher incomes and greater social standing should be permitted to make suboptimal choices with regard to climate sustainability? Is it really just a class thing more than the scientific implications of changing climate?