4 ms·
Comparing baseball greats across eras, who comes out on top?
- jleyank 1y agoThese kinds of analyses were done back in the 70's and 80's as I recall (Linear Weights, other SABR-published decade corrections, ...). But I guess if you wait long enough you can republish?
- PaulHoule 1y agoPeople can do more complex analysis now that we have more computational power, for one thing.
- monster_truck 1y agoNothing done in this paper requires more than a simple calculator
- mitchbob 1y agoGood to see Barry Bonds on top. An eye-opening Chart Party episode showed how ridiculously great he was: https://youtu.be/JwMfT2cZGHg?si=ETq2PbMVglFP5LFb https://youtu.be/JwMfT2cZGHg?si=ETq2PbMVglFP5LFb
- LargeWu 1y agoHe was also a cheater, taking bespoke steroid cocktails, so there's that.
- jghn 1y agoI mean, as long as we're going to pretend that players weren't chemically enhanced as far back as the 60s (if not further), then sure? From steroids to amphetamines, it was far from uncommon.
- jgalt212 1y agoAmphetamines aren't even in the same league as steroids.
- jghn 1y agoNot necessarily true. This was discussed ad nauseum in the early aughts.2 bits that are less obvious: 1) the most challenging aspect is maintaining energy throughout a long season. Drugs that help with that are useful. 2) pitchers were believed to benefit more from steroids than batters but batters drew the most attention.
- jgalt212 1y agoStatistical outlier analysis of different time periods would help settle this matter. My theory is that amphetamines raise all boats by roughly similar and less dramatic amounts, and thus are less detrimental to the game.
- jghn 1y agoThere is also the assumption that players weren't taking steroids until much later than it likely started to occur. We know that athletes were experimenting with steroids going way back, at least the 40s & 50s. Further, having the discussion of "steroids" being centered around *steroids* is a bit of an oversimplification as by and large the state of the art had moved on by the heyday of Bonds/McGuire/Sosa. Nevertheless, the focus was always on the chemicals that made players big & strong, meanwhile the ones that helped to *preserve* muscle and/or enhance recovery speed were more impactful. And even then, simply looking at things like power outliers over time isn't useful. State of the art in terms of play style changed over time. For instance there have been eras where players were intentionally hitting for contact and eras where players were intentionally hitting for power. Or, one can just relax in the knowledge that players have been cheating, chemically or otherwise, from time immemorial, and that it's impossible to retroactively sort out. So if we compare players relative to their peers and then use that to compare across eras we can get a better sense. But it's folly to read too much into all of this.
- NaOH 1y agoFor those interested in details, there's more information at one of the author's sites than this article which links a paywalled paper. https://eckeraadjustment.web.illinois.edu https://eckeraadjustment.web.illinois.edu
- lapcat 1y agoI love Bert Blyleven, but #23??? This was a guy who took 14 ballots to get in the Hall of Fame.
- vondur 1y agoHa. I remember him being called Bert “be home” Blyleven.
- streptomycin 1y agoEven just with normal WAR https://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/WAR_career.shtml https://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/WAR_career.shtml he comes out at #38 all time. I'm not sure summing up career WAR is the best way to rank players, though. It favors guys who played a long time, like Blyleven who played 22 seasons. Sandy Koufax played half as long but was undoubtedly better at his peak. Who was really "better" overall? You probably want some metric that combines career totals and peak production, but ultimately there is no universal way to come up with one definitive ranking, so we will debate it forever.
- NaOH 1y ago>You probably want some metric that combines career totals and peak production. How does WAR miss this goal? It credits year-to-year player contributions and gives more credit for better seasonal performances. Longevity alone doesn't ensure a higher WAR total since a negative WAR valuation is possible (and common).
- streptomycin 1y agoWell there's infinite ways to combine peak and career totals, and "10 years of 1 WAR is equal to 1 year of 10 WAR" is certainly one of them.
- lardbgard 1y agoNobody
- snapetom 1y agoBonds and Clemens should be excluded.
- loloquwowndueo 1y agoExplain why for those who don’t know. Thanks :)
- jayemar 1y agoI'm assuming it's because both are presumed to have used steroids, which is the reason that neither are in the hall of fame.
- rubidium 1y agoThe overlap of statisticians and baseball fans is high (anecdotal). Hypothesis 1: statisticians love good data sources, and with its many games, innings, and types of hits / pitches it’s a great source. Hypothesis 2: makes you seem more interesting at dinner parties hypothesis 3: a natural overlap of preferences
- deeg 1y agoI am surprised at how low Nolan Ryan is, given how good he was and how long he played (27 years!). I guess he wasn't as good as I thought.
- MrMember 1y agoRandy Johnson had an absolutely insane career. He basically had two hall of fame careers, one before age 35 and one 35 and after. Any one of those alone would have been enough to get him into the hall of fame, taken together makes him one of the best pitchers of all time.