4 ms·
If this has been known for years and nobody's trying to implement it, surely there's a catch?
by zahlman 1y ago
If this has been known for years and nobody's trying to implement it, surely there's a catch?
- wetpaws 1y ago[dead]
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoAgreed. Farming is incredibly data driven/cost conscious. For the entire industry to not make this an overnight priority says something about the analysis is missing.
- littlexsparkee 1y agoAdoption is growing in Brazil but it takes a while for a practice to become mainstream.
- danielheath 1y ago“Worked once in a specific tropical pasture”. AFAIK, most beef production is not in the tropics.
- Izikiel43 1y agoSouth of Brazil is in the tropic of capricorn and it's a beef producing region
- Loughla 1y ago100% accurate. Livestock feed is (like most agriculture) hyper optimized. If they could increase production by 60% with any additive at all, it would immediately see widespread use. People still have this weird view of farming that it's like Johnny Goodguy and his family taking care of a small herd. While that exists still, Johnny is also tracking every input and outcome and optimizing daily. The data collection and use in Ag would astound people.
- anon84873628 1y agoThis article is not about a livestock feed, it's about creating a pasture polyculture that reduces the need for nitrogen fertilizer application. The 60% claim is "in comparison with pastures without the use of nitrogen fertilization." And of course only applies to the region and cattle breed they studied, not to mention only cattle raised on pasture in the first place. It's not claiming to be a magic growth tonic for all cattle. Though I agree the title is a bit exaggerated and invites misinterpretation.
- morpheos137 1y agoCows graze.
- tocs3 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feedlot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feedlot
- chasil 1y agoI'm curious if the nitrogen fixation is done by symbiotic bacteria. If so, can both organisms survive in all the climates where cattle is raised?
- anon84873628 1y agoYes, legumes are fairly unique in that their root nodes host symbiotic bacteria capable of fixing nitrogen for the atmosphere. That's why they are so important in crop rotation or polyculture. Every region could have different species that work best. The finding of this study, as I understand it, is identifying this foreign species that happens to work well for the location and agricultural needs.
- zdragnar 1y agoEven tractors with RTK satellite guidance have 1 inch precision. Commercial fields with modern tractors are guided to the point that the tractors drive perfectly between crops without damaging them automatically. Spraying applications and other jobs are likewise informed, driven and executed automatically in tandem between computers and overhead imagery.
- weaksauce 1y agothe other people are right that there is crazy data collection and optimization from them... however blind spots can exist and outliers could be possible in that kind of environment.
- oguz-ismail 1y agothere's no blind spot where even a 5% increase in beef production can hide...
- littlexsparkee 1y agoin the book We Are Eating the Earth it bemoans that money is going to soil carbon schemes that don't do much whereas money to distribute this plant's seeds (what is needed) is scarce
- strken 1y agoI'm really curious to see a comparison with all the other common self-regenerating legumes, like clover. Maybe it's better adapted to Brazil?
- tengbretson 1y ago> According to him, if the leguminous plants whose reproduction is stolon-based are adequately managed in the pasture, they will persist there. "In desmodium's case, the solution is to have the cattle graze it when the plant height reaches 30 cm and remove the animals when the average height is 15 cm", he recommends. The risks associated with over-grazing something like this makes me think it would be ill-suited for anything but management intensive rotational grazing type operations. And even then it seems a bit risky.