3 ms·
The article doesn't appear to be paywalled and I'm reading it just fine without JavaScript enabled. Is an archive really necessary?
by zahlman 1y ago
The article doesn't appear to be paywalled and I'm reading it just fine without JavaScript enabled. Is an archive really necessary?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- voidnap 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y agoPlease edit out swipes from your comments. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- tetromino_ 1y agoPaywalled here - can only read 2 paragraphs. Possibly paywall is triggered conditionally, for example if you read multiple articles in some time period?
- Jtsummers 1y agoIt used to be 5 free a month when they first introduced it years ago. Not sure the current mechanism and policy.
- john01dav 1y agoMany paywalls rely on client side JavaScript to work. My guess is that this has something to do with search engine indexing.
- zahlman 1y agoAs a test, I whitelisted JavaScript in NoScript for theatlantic.com and the paywall appeared. I revoked it and it disappeared again. It appears to be purely client-side, not reliant on cookies or anything. So my conclusion is that an archive indeed shouldn't be necessary; people can just disable JavaScript. It doesn't cause issues with the page formatting or anything.
- cnst 1y agoMost browsers do NOT offer per-site JS disable buttons. It should not be necessary to change the browser to view a website; people can just use archive.today, which works fine in all browsers with JavaScript, and doesn't require a captcha, either, in browsers that don't block stuff. (It only requires captchas in those browsers that do block stuff.)
- zdragnar 1y agoI got a "sign in or start a free trial" wall that blocked most of the article. I suspect these sites don't put up that block until articles reach a certain popularity. That encourages early readers to enjoy and share the article, and everyone else gets to think that the person that shared it with them has an account, so maybe they should too.
- bookofjoe 1y agoThe block is built-in from the get-go.
- cnst 1y ago> The block is built-in from the get-go. That's only because the JavaScript is fast. If you're using the Brave browser, you can click on the Brave logo when on the required site, and toggle the disable scripts button when on the www.theatlantic.com website, then JavaScript would be disabled for the site, and it'd stop requiring the paywall. Please don't take these complaints personally; personally, not all of my devices / browsers have JS disable buttons, so, some of us do appreciate others posting the archive.today links, even for sites where paywall can be skipped through the script disable trick in some browsers.
- foresto 1y agoNot everyone can be bothered to disable JavaScript by default. It's a pity that archive.today walls off their saved pages behind a Google CAPTCHA, which requires JavaScript. I would think avoiding that kind of fingerprinting/tracking would be a common use case for an archive site, but the Google-wall renders archive.today useless for that purpose.
- bookofjoe 1y agoThere are those of us here who haven't a clue what it means "to disable JavaScript by default" — much less what JavaScript is.
- boston_clone 1y agoThis makes me super curious - could you share how you came to find this site and decide to sign up? It's called "hacker news" with the implication that content posted here is intellectually stimulating for hackers - or, those who hack together computer programs. If you do already program, have you never been exposed to JavaScript at all? If not, I think you should use that curiosity to find out what JavaScript is and what effects disabling it may have. Even more odd when I see that the majority of your comments are really just posting archive links to bypass a paywall. Not an issue with me per se, but even more surprising to be ignorant of JS at that point.
- bookofjoe 1y ago1. I happened on HN accidentally in 2016 and enjoy posts both in areas completely foreign to me — like things computer-related — and others more familiar. 2. I never considered that because it's called "hacker news" it's intended only for hackers. 3. I have never written a line of code, much less programmed. 4. I have zero curiosity about JavaScript. 5. "Even more odd when I see that the majority of your comments are really just posting archive links to bypass a paywall." In fact, 99% of those archive links are to primary articles I post which in fact ARE paywalled. Since by being a paying subscriber to a number of publications I am able to provide "Gift Links" as well, as a courtesy to HN readers I go to the time and trouble of posting them as well as archive links. There is some distaste on your part for this practice — "Not an issue with me per se" implies the opposite. In your opinion "even more surprising to be ignorant of JS at that point" — I fail to see any connection between being ignorant of JS to posting archive links — I will going forward cease and desist from posting both "Gift Links" and archive links and instead let you do it, since you clearly have knowledge of JavaScript and believe it important for providing such links.
- cnst 1y ago> The article doesn't appear to be paywalled and I'm reading it just fine without JavaScript enabled. Is an archive really necessary? Not every browser has the option to disable JavaScript for a webpage. Yes, of course archive is necessary, as it helps everyone read the article easily, see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html, which points out that complaining about paywalls is not.