3 ms·
Land Value Tax (one of the main theories pushed by Georgism proponents) is a favorite of online discussion forums, but becomes progressively less popular as the
by Aurornis 1y ago
Land Value Tax (one of the main theories pushed by Georgism proponents) is a favorite of online discussion forums, but becomes progressively less popular as the conversation turns from broad strokes to details.
Every time it comes up it seems many people are also unaware that taxing land value is already common practice. It’s common to have one tax for the assessed value of the land and another tax for the assessed value of the improvements. Policies might include exemptions for the first so many dollars of a person’s primary residence structure.
With a pure Land Value Tax you cover your eyes and pretend the value of the structures and improvements doesn’t count. If one wealthy neighbor builds a $2,000,000 house next to a retired grandma living out her final years in her small, old forever home, the LVT people don’t care. If their lots are the same then they must pay the same taxes because the land value is what matters.
This makes it a very regressive tax structure as the people or businesses with the least valuable structures now subdivide their neighbors with the most valuable structures. This can all be avoided by simply using our existing system of having a tax on land and a tax on structures each at their assessed value.
- owenversteeg 1y ago>This makes it a very regressive tax structure That's objectively false. Georgism is one of the few reliably progressive tax structures, ask any economist. The "little old grandma in her forever home surrounded by incredibly valuable real estate" trope is a) fairly uncommon + a very small percentage of total real estate and b) very common in conservative billboards advocating for highly regressive cuts to property tax. At the end of the day, if your little old grandma owns $5M in prime real estate, she is very wealthy and can certainly afford the property taxes, and pretending otherwise is how we get policy disasters like San Francisco. But of course, the overwhelming majority of unimproved property is not owned by little old grandmas, it is owned by real estate corporations. The half acre of Grandma's house pales in comparison to the literal _billions_ (!) of parking spaces in the US, or empty lots, or empty buildings. Drive around NYC and tell me the ratio of acreage owned by little old ladies to that of underutilized land owned by real estate corporations.
- Aurornis 1y ago> That's objectively false. Georgism is one of the few reliably progressive tax structures, ask any economist. It’s not false at all. Georgism via a LVT purposefully ignores all forms of wealth except land. Let me simplify it for you: Two neighbors live next door to each other on identical lots. One has $10m in stocks and earns $500k/year. The other is early career and earns $100k/year while trying to build their retirement savings. Under Georgist LVT, you ignore all of this and make them pay the same taxes. The person who earns less pays a higher percent of their income. This is the definition of regressive. Where does the average person have most of their wealth stored by retirement? Their house and the land it’s on. Georgist LVT argues that we should tax them out of that land and give it to a business, who should be able to profit from it without paying any taxes on the profits. This is regressive. The LVT argument holds that we should ignore everything else: Their business ownership, their 401k, their stocks, bonds, cash, and even the house itself. Ignore all of that, tax people based on land. The 10 story apartment complex and the single family house both might occupy the same land, so they’re taxed the same. Georgists love this in theory because they want those people priced out of their houses and the developers to come in and build those apartment complexes, which those displaced people can come rent. Efficiency! Sorry typical homeowner, we need to price you out of affording the home you bought and lived in. Our policy needs to force you to sell to this developer who will construct apartment complexes, reap the profits (tax-free now, because it’s not land!) but they’d be happy to rent an apartment to you for a monthly fee. > Drive around NYC and tell me the ratio of acreage owned by little old ladies to that of underutilized land owned by real estate corporations. NYC is an outlier. If you’re basing your understanding on economic theories from one of the single most dense and developed cities in the US you’re missing a lot. Do you think the average person is closer to an NYC parking lot operator? Or closer to the typical homeowner? Why would we pick an entire taxation structure to punish some NYC parking lot owners instead of looking at the typical person? The entire premise is an example of out of touch academic thinking that forgets to even look at what the real world looks like. Finally, your “ask any economist” appeal to authority does not hold any water. Much has been written about the severe flaws with a Georgist style 100% LVT. Even the lay discussions on LVT are starting to admit it’s not a panacea. Previously you’d find rationalists championing as the perfect economic format, but even they are waking up to the fact that it’s not so simple. A recently shared HN link: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/CCuJotfcaoXf8FYcy/some-arguments-against-a-land-value-tax https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/CCuJotfcaoXf8FYcy/some-argum...