6 ms·
You put your information on a public website for free, and are surprised that people use it as they see fit?
by SoftTalker 1y ago
You put your information on a public website for free, and are surprised that people use it as they see fit?
- AlienRobot 1y agoDon't be surprised if there is no more free information in the next 10 years.
- skeledrew 1y agoThere will always be people putting information out there with 0 expectation of any kind of return. What will happen is there will be far fewer websites enforcing return, as they'll be automatically deranked for that enforcement.
- integralid 1y agoI am tech blogging for free, and my expected return is people reading my content, recognition, attribution, social media attention and people discussing my content. I have zero interest in providing free labor for LLM companies with no human actually reading my words. I don't think I'm alone in that stance. Similarly, I used to help people on forums for free. My reward was getting respect of my peers, the feeling of helping another human being and sometimes them being grateful, rare side job opportunities thanks to people finding my specialist posts. That was fun, being anonymous question-answering bot for AI to scrape is not.
- skeledrew 1y ago> recognition, attribution, social media attention Expectation of these in particular makes your blogging a product. > with no human actually reading my words But it - or at least the idea - is being ultimately read by humans, as long as some article is in the top results for relevance to some LLM prompts. It just may be summarized, or particular parts extracted first, or reworded for clarity (like I may ask for an "eli5" if I encounter something that's interesting but I find concepts going over my head), or otherwise preprocessed in order to fulfill the prompt parameters. All actions which the very human users may have to do manually anyway in order to efficiently consume your content (or give up and move on if they can't be bothered), is now automatically done by LLM agents.
- AlienRobot 1y agoThe number of people who have the privilege to publish content for free for others (or spend their free time contributing to open source) is minimal. And now they will feel like they're being disrespected and exploited by LLM's and its users who think of the authors not as people but as just as the source of content. You can be sure most of the content will be gone because nobody wants to be just a content cow for LLM's.
- skeledrew 1y agoWhy do you think they'll feel disrespected? They literally have no expectations; they're just putting content out there for others to do as they wish with. Several here have weighed in to say they don't care about LLMs accessing and morphing their content. Of course they won't be nearly as many as those who publish with expectations, but also history has shown that whenever there's a gap, someone tends to fill it just because. I'm not worried about content gaps at all. What I see is an overall increase in quality as no-expectation sources float to the top of search results.
- nicbou 1y agoWell I'm one such person so you can hear it from me instead of guessing. I feel disrespected. I can also confirm that I will do a lot less of it since it's threatening the parts of my business that supported me and gave me so much free time to release things for free. It almost halved my audience, so I have to do the same amount of work for nearly half the pay, half the community, and half the credit.
- murukesh_s 1y agoNot always creators puts the content for free free, they expect views, gratitude, and/or ad revenue..
- skeledrew 1y agoIt's not free if there's any kind of expected return.
- juliangmp 1y agoAttribution would be one thing. See ooen-source and free software licenses.
- skeledrew 1y agoThere are specific constraints on "free" in that context. For example *GPL also generally forbids providing functionality without making the source available.
- rightbyte 1y agoIf the return is also free, yes. A smile or a thank you is free to give.
- nicbou 1y agoIf I gave my surplus eggs for free, I'd be annoyed if they ended up at the Best Western's buffet. These eggs were meant for my neighbours. There is a difference between working for free for your community and working for free for a trillion dollar company's investors. Doubly so when you strip consent or attribution from the equation.
- SoftTalker 1y agoThen you should make sure you are giving the eggs to your neighbors and not to Best Western.
- nicbou 1y agoI can't help if the Best Western plunders the honesty box in front of my house. There is no way to stop them. I hope that you understand that this is a metaphor for free labour intended for a community being exploited by big corporations with no way of stopping them.
- kcartlidge 1y agoJust because something is on a public website accessible for free doesn't mean it is then public domain. Sharing is not necessarily giving. (Though unfortunately in the Wild West Web of today it seems it does, practically speaking.)