4 ms·
Can anyone explain in general what is the point in WhatsApp which isn't compatible with anything except itself, vs normative XMPP/Jingle client through which on
by shmerl 14y ago
Can anyone explain in general what is the point in WhatsApp which isn't compatible with anything except itself, vs normative XMPP/Jingle client through which one can communicate with any user from federated XMPP servers? I have hard time understanding why new closed (walled garden) IM networks appear in these day and age.
- adthrelfall 14y agoIt got traction because it worked simply with no config and was very cost effective in certain use cases. I know it was used as a precursor to iMessage type eaperince to send 'texts' and images using only data, so was perfect for communicating across countries with no carrier charges.
- shmerl 14y agoSo the only point was in avoiding one time step like adding an account to the client (like users do with e-mail too) / or registering on some XMPP server? Still it hardly justifies creating more walled networks (unless they allow federation and regular XMPP communication with their servers).
- evertonfuller 14y agoDo you think consumers care about walled networks? No.
- shmerl 14y agoTo a degree they do, since users of one walled network can't communicate with users of other walled ones, and if they want they need to create an account in each of them. While federated XMPP is like e-mail, i.e you can use one ID to communicate with users from many servers. So there is an obvious comfort even for the end user.
- marquis 14y agoIt's quite popular in countries where buying SMS credits is not always an afforded cost, but public wifi is everywhere. Basic Android phones are fairly popular and inexpensive given that they double as a web browser and communication device for many.
- shmerl 14y agoThat's understandable, but my question was about creating WhatsApp vs making a regular conformant XMPP/Jingle client which also simply works through TCP and UDP. The later gives free choice of what XMPP server to use and allows communicating with users of other federated servers. WhatsApp allows communicating only with WhatsApp if I understand correctly.
- njs12345 14y agoI would imagine this is a plus for them, sadly. It's probably easier to extract revenue from a walled garden than an equally user-friendly XMPP client.
- cageface 14y agoHere in Vietnam you can get unlimited 3g access for $2/month and once you've paid for that using something like WhatsApp is much cheaper than paying the SMS fee for every message.
- kbronson 14y ago> It's quite popular in countries where buying SMS credits is not always an afforded cost, but public wifi is everywhere. What countries are that?
- njs12345 14y agoI use it to talk to my friends back home because: - it's free (or inexpensive compared to international SMS) - it doesn't require any technical expertise whatsoever - it's cross platform - it already has traction I can't think of any alternative which has this combination of properties..
- captaintacos 14y agoI hate to be the devil's advocate but I swear by Facebook's messenger app. It does exactly the same things: international, FREE-as-in-beer, really cross platform (can whatsapp do web?), push notifications on iPhone thereby effectively replacing SMS, etc. As long as the other person is on facebook of course! It has come to the point that my wife and I barely use SMS anymore and are actually saving some play money on SMS thanks to that thing. And that is bad news for carriers worldwide yes, but not that anyone really feels pity for them anyway.
- shmerl 14y agoYou see, so what stops them all from implementing their clients and servers using conformant XMPP with enabled federation? Can your Facebook messenger connect you to users of WhatsApp and vice versa? No. With Federated XMPP it'd just work. Is it just their greed, or lack of thinking? Actually Facebook does use XMPP, and I think even WhatsApp in some way internally does, but Facebook server lacks federation, and WhatsApp isn't even conformant to standard XMPP. In the end - you have no way to connect the two. This situation resembles the early period of the Internet, when users of Compuserve couldn't send e-mails to users of AOL (and other way around). It sounds completely weird today, but how is this situation with IM networks different? Understandably there are historic isolated networks (AOL, MSN etc.) which predate any serious federation efforts, and even they are slowly enabling XMPP in some ways. But creating new closed ones in the present time is just weird and only serves to make the situation worse.
- elemeno 14y agoUsing Facebook's messenger app requires you to know someone in way which just having their phone number doesn't. For example, if I'm going to go on a date with someone and we've swapped numbers that's enough for us to talk by SMS/iMessage/WhatsApp, whilst we probably[1] don't know each other well enough yet to expose our digital lives to each other on Facebook. [1] - This entirely depends on things like age, social norms, how much personal information is on your Facebook page etc. Also, depending on are you going on a date with someone you already know vs. someone new. Mostly the point being that anything that just needs a phone number has a low barrier to communication while also not leaking any personal information (other than your phone number).
- vdm 14y agoUbiquity; works on every mobile platform. (Including Nokia/Symbian, Windows Phone) So you can talk to any of your friends if they install the app. Phone numbers are logins. Everybody with a phone already has one, so they don't have to do the whole 'create/verify an ID/password' dance. If you have friends in other countries, this avoids roaming SMS charges. And if you are from Ireland, or Greece, lots of your friends are in other countries.
- shmerl 14y ago> you can talk to any of your friends if they install the app Yes, that's exactly the catch. Why should you require them to install anoter app if they might already use some other IM network? Approach of WhatsApp may be simplifies the initial registration step, but it adds to the global mess of the non interoperable IM networks. Negative impact way outweighs any potential comfort benefits, and authors who promote such things are to be blamed for it. > Everybody with a phone already has one, so they don't have to do the whole 'create/verify an ID/password' dance Actually you might want to do it, since numbers change, while IDs don't. Plus you want to authenticate the other party if for example you need a secure conversation (such as with OTR).
- janerik 14y agoFor most people it's far easier to just install an app instead of going through a whole setup and registration process and remembering a login handle and a password. I have a lot non-geek friends who are happy with how WhatsApp works. They mostly ignore all privacy issues with this.
- shmerl 14y agoI'm not really directing this critique to WhatsApp users, rather to WhatsApp authors, who exploit users' comfort of no configuration vs one time configuration / registration, while causing with that a proliferation of walled networks. They are not doing a good service to users at large. One time configuration / registration is not really a burden. All users are familial with that process. And they don't do it each time they read their e-mail for example. As I said, the negative impact of non interoperability proliferation is way more significant.