4 ms·
Skeumorphism is no more an "easy way out" than black Helvetica on a white background is an "easy way out". They can both be used appropriately, or used badly an
by crazygringo 14y ago
Skeumorphism is no more an "easy way out" than black Helvetica on a white background is an "easy way out". They can both be used appropriately, or used badly and in excess.
The address book in OSX is an example of bad skeumorphism -- it's a fake book with pages that don't actually turn, trying to shoehorn "advanced" computer technology into a visual representation that doesn't work. It's a bad metaphor, a bad analogy. It confuses more than it helps.
The "Notes" application on OSX is a fantastic use of skeumorphism. The legal-pad look shows us at a glance that it's for taking notes, which a plain white background wouldn't do. The analogy between individual note documents and pages is perfect. Anyone can use it instantly, without worrying where documents are saved or anything like that.
The fundamental question is, are design choices helping or hindering understandability and usability? Apps and the web have evolved conventions like share icons and tabs and underlined/colored links, etc. which people understand. Skeumorphism just adds vocabulary from the physical world to the toolbox.
And in the opposite direction of skeumorphism, I think the SVBTLE blog platform itself goes too far to the minimalist. I can't tell people's blogs apart, because they all look virtually identical -- that's bad design. And what the heck is the "kudos nipple"? Why do you hover instead of clicking? A simple thumbs-up icon would be understandable by everyone, which is almost skeumorphic in its own way, since it refers to a physical thumbs-up... Reference to the physical world can be a very useful thing.
- comex 14y agoAnd what the heck is the "kudos nipple"? Why do you hover instead of clicking? ...I never even knew that was interactive. I guess I might have tried to click it if I wanted to give a kudo, but not before looking at the bottom of the page or something. Too far indeed.
- simonrobb 14y agoI'd agree that the address book skeumorphism is a pretty terrible option - seems to be more about design bling than addressing usabiblity. OTOH the "head-shaking" of the OSX login window when you enter a bad password is some of the best skeumorphism I've seen, and yet there are no visual design elements (like putting ears on the window or something.)
- vacri 14y agoWow, that 'kudos nipple' is terrible. It's not even clear what's happened after the rather unclear "don't move" instruction.
- barrkel 14y agoThe first few times it happened to me, I felt that I had been manipulated into "approving" of the article, when I felt no such approval. It was abusive. Now, whenever I visit a new Svbtle blog, I block that whole element so I never accidentally vote again.
- hairyballs22 14y agoYou can click on it to undo the kudos.
- 001sky 14y agoA simple thumbs-up icon would be understandable by everyone, which is almost skeumorphic in its own way, since it refers to a physical thumbs-up... Reference to the physical world can be a very useful thing. "OK" is one of the worlds best understood words, in any language. Simple, elegant, and a powerful. This is an important point. Very information efficient. All of this is synoymous with good design. Skeumorphic, or not.
- wisty 14y ago> The "Notes" application on OSX is a fantastic use of skeumorphism. I think good skeumorphics are called "affordances", while skeumorphism is being used as a prerogative term ("indiscriminate affordances"). There's no reason for a new word. Affordances are ancient. Bad affordances (especially crappy media players) are ancient. "Apple" and "media needs a new trend to carp on about" are the only reason to start using a new term for them.