4 ms·
Police seizure of text messages violated 4th Amendment, judge rules
- stephengillie 14y agoYet police can legally impersonate you if they have your cell. Police in WA state confiscated a cell from a dealer, read past messages, then set up new deals to arrest the users. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4266538 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4266538
- imgabe 14y agoPolice lie to suspects all the time to trick them into confessions. I don't see how that's any different.
- Karunamon 14y agoI'd really like to see this process banned. Just because it's legal doesn't mean it's proper or just.
- dmishe 14y agoWait, it is unjust to trick a criminal into revealing himself?
- Karunamon 14y agoThat's not what I said. I said that police should be able to do their work without resorting to lies and deception. Also, notice that GP said "suspect", you said "criminal". Huge difference.
- vacri 14y agoDoes this mean you're also against undercover agents and informants? What about things like bait cars?
- Karunamon 14y agoBait cars, drug stings, and the like always seemed way too close to entrapment for my liking.
- tptacek 14y agoThey manifestly cannot do their work without resorting to deception. Virtually all policework above the level of street patrols turns in one way or another on some flavor of deception.
- qbit 14y agoThe counter example that comes to mind is a detective who gathers physical evidence in order to convict a criminal. Where is the deception there?
- dmishe 14y agoAgreed on second argument.
- veemjeem 14y agoHow is that not considered entrapment?
- baddox 14y agoBecause that's not at all what entrapment is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entrapment
- vacri 14y agoA salient difference in that example was that the owner was arrested and the device confiscated in the process - the activity happened on a device already in police custody. In the example in this article, there was no arrest until the phone was examined.
- tptacek 14y agoThe police do not need a warrant to search suspects incident to their arrest. Contrary to message board expectations, it is for that reason among many others that the police will not arbitrarily place you under arrest; arrest is a big deal. If the police arrest you unlawfully and discover key evidence of a major crime, your showing in court that the arrest was unlawful can undo their case.
- cma 14y agoSeems like you could get one cop on the inside and get a get out of jail free card--murder someone, have him search your house without a warrant, find tainted evidence, suddenly you are immune from prosecution.
- koenigdavidmj 14y agoUsually you're not immune from prosecution; they just suppress the evidence collected in that search so that it cannot be used against you (this is a simplification; there are a number of reasons why this evidence can be used against you anyway, generally amounting to `they would have another legal way of discovering the same fact about the crime').
- stusmall 14y agoWhat I am confused on, and maybe there is something missing from the story, but it sounds like the office stumbled upon those text messages in his normal activities. I don't know much about the law but I assumed what he did was okay. Was he over stepping his bounds in answer someone else phone or was it that the court didn't believe he was doing it only to get to touch with the birth father?
- tptacek 14y agoAbsent a warrant or an arrest, the police cannot use your phone to "get in touch" with one of your contacts and then derive evidence against you from that action. That seems sensible to me.
- jerrya 14y agoSavage reasoned that cell phone contents are deserving of Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable searches and seizures because people generally keep them on their person at all times. "Text messages are often raw, unvarnished, and immediate; revealing the most intimate of thoughts and emotions to those who are expected to guard them from publication," she wrote, further stating that the court "does not find that the remote possibility that an unintended party will receive a text message due to his or her possession of another person‘s cell phone is sufficient to destroy an objective expectation of privacy in such a message This seems like one of these decisions that defy reality. In this case the phone was not being kept on the person, and yet the judge writes that phones are expected to be kept on the person contra reality. If people expect text messages to be delivered immediately, they are wrong. Their expectation doesn't change reality. If some people expect text messages to be kept private, they are wrong. Their expectation doesn't change reality. If the cop found the cell phone, beeping, with a new message and that message was incriminating, I have no problem with it being used against them. If the cop picked up the phone, beeping, with a new message, and then pressed buttons to get to the messaging functions where he then read the incriminating message, that is much more problematical. If people think their text messages are private, they are just wrong.
- superuser2 14y ago>If some people expect text messages to be kept private, they are wrong. Their expectation doesn't change reality. Let's try it this way: If some people expect phone calls to be kept private, they are wrong. Their expectation doesn't change reality. The presence of surveillance doesn't negate the expectation of privacy. >In this case the phone was not being kept on the person, and yet the judge writes that phones are expected to be kept on the person contra reality. So when you put your phone in the bin to go through a metal detector, your phone records, text messages, email accounts, Dropbox account, social media accounts, and anything else accessible from your smartphone is fair game for the state? No.
- jerrya 14y agoIf some people expect phone calls to be kept private, they are wrong. Their expectation doesn't change reality. The phone call itself is private. GSM Cell phone calls are encrypted (is that still unbroken for most people??) Recording is governed by laws that specify for each state how private it is. The police need to get warrants to record. So when you put your phone in the bin to go through a metal detector, your phone records, text messages, email accounts, Dropbox account, social media accounts, and anything else accessible from your smartphone is fair game for the state? I am looking at the bin, and I will not let anyone pick up the phone. A cop seeing a phone on a coffee table blinking away with a message on the face of it seems very different to me than what you have described. (I am speculating about several aspects of that vis a vis the actual case.)
- hannibalhorn 14y agoI'm curious as to why this didn't fall under inevitable discovery? I imagine that a dead 6 year old, having received blows to the stomach, would warrant an actual investigation and (most likely) the phone records of everyone at the scene could have been subpoenaed.
- vacri 14y agoWhat would be the link between suspecting a child died of abuse and applying for a warrant to read text messages?
- hannibalhorn 14y ago1) Generally speaking, a dead kid gives the police a LOT of leeway. 2) If they suspected somebody at the scene of having knowledge as to the culprit, I think most judges would have allowed them access to phone records for everyone at the scene during the time period in question. Basically, this wasn't a stoner crossing the border that might have had photos of himself smoking something illegal, this is a dead kid, and I'm pretty sure the cops would have asked for those records in due course. And I'm pretty sure a judge would have said yes.
- tptacek 14y agoThe kid wasn't dead when the phone was searched, and there was, as the court itself noted, no evidence of wrongdoing apparent the the officer who conducted the illegal search. But that's besides the point. "Inevitable discovery" does not simply mean what it sounds like on a message board thread. It is not an invitation for the police to sieze everything they can and then come up with a compelling story for how they would have found it anyways. In particular: when the evidence in question is the direct result of an illegal search, its inevitability probably doesn't matter. If the officer had a grave suspicion of wrongdoing, he had available to him a mechanism to search the phone: he could have arrested its owner or any other occupant of the house. What he can't do, at least without a warrant, is walk around someone's private home without permission and search their belongings. Had the message been flashing on the front of the phone, it would have been in plain sight and probably have been allowed. The message was not in plain sight.
- 001sky 14y ago"In addition, this Court finds that the Defendant made a preliminary showing that numerous sworn statements made by police officers in a dozen warrant affidavits were either deliberately false or made in reckless disregard of the truth..." A pattern of abuse, seems to be part of the issue here.
- grecy 14y agoAnd what punished do the Police Officers get for lying in sworn statements.. ?
- philip1209 14y agoIf the phone were face-up on the counter, the text message appeared, and the officer photographed, but did not disturb, the phone, how would the case be different?