4 ms·
Eh... Suppose A solves a problem and writes the solution down. B reads the answer and repeats it. Is B reasoning, when asked the same question? What about one
by mattkrause 1y ago
Eh...
Suppose A solves a problem and writes the solution down. B reads the answer and repeats it. Is B reasoning, when asked the same question? What about one that sounds similar?
- briangriffinfan 1y agoCould it be said that reasoning requires intent?
- DennisP 1y agoIf a human does A, that required reasoning. Same for AI. If a human does B, that didn't require reasoning. Same for AI. Believe it or not, people do make an effort to test their AIs on problems that they could not have seen in their training data.
- briangriffinfan 1y agoThe crux of the problem is "what is reasoning?" Of course it's easy enough to call the outputs "equivalent enough" and then use that to say the processes are therefore also "equivalent enough."
- DennisP 1y agoI'm not saying it's enough for the outputs to be "equivalent enough." I am saying that if the outputs and inputs are equivalent, then that's enough to call it the same thing. It might be different internally, but that doesn't really matter for practical purposes.
- briangriffinfan 1y agoI think one of the great lessons of our age will be that things being apparently equivalent, or in more applied terms "good enough," are not equal to equality.