3 ms·
Apple censoring apps in its own proprietary app-store isn't really a big deal to society as a whole. Apple censoring what other devices are allowed to exist ou
by josteink 14y ago
Apple censoring apps in its own proprietary app-store isn't really a big deal to society as a whole.
Apple censoring what other devices are allowed to exist outside their production-lines and what competing products customers are allowed to choose is.
- onetimeuse001 14y agoIt could be if they reach a certain size, especially as the web moves to mobile.
- bookwormAT 14y agoI disagree: Apple convinced developers that censorship is cool, and that is at least as dangerous as the broken patent system. Upcoming versions of both OS X and Windows take large steps in the same direction already. We all enjoyed a free software market for most of our lives. Now Android seems to be the only "personal computing" platform with a future. And who knows when Samsung or Google are going to shut down that door on Android as well? It wouldn't hurt them, since neither consumers nor developers seem to care about independent software distribution anymore.
- zevyoura 14y agoApple did not convince developers that censorship was 'cool,' they convinced developers that they could make more money in a marketplace with censorship. As soon as that stops being true, or the frustrations mount, developers will change their mind. The patent system is enshrined in law, and a far bigger problem.
- epo 14y agoBlocking flagrant copying by a commercial competitor is not censorship.
- pook1e 14y agoPlease, explain to me how the Galaxy Nexus is the result of "flagrant copying".
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- gwright 14y agoI know that this is a hopeless request but can we stop using the word "censor" when we are really talking about curation, or editorial policy, or private business decisions, etc? Government imposed restrictions on speech and/or commerce is something entirely different from plain old business decisions and it would be nice if we didn't conflate the two things by overloading the meaning of "censorship".
- bookwormAT 14y agoIMHO, restrictions on speech and/or commerce do not need to be imposed by a government in order to count as censorship. Any controlling body will do. If you control software distribution on a plaform, you directly or indirectly control every information that customers of that platform receive. I think this covers censorship. Of course iOS does not have a dominant position in the market yet, so censorship is limited by the customers choice to switch to another device. But as I explained above, the moment to speak against the control is now, as long as there are still alternatives left. I think this "plain old business decision" is a political issue of great importance.
- gwright 14y agoOk so now 'business' is the same as 'politics'? The problem with tossing all these things into the same etymological barrel is that you lose the ability to communicate effectively about their differences. Government restrictions imposed by force are not the same thing as market realities created by private decisions. Business decisions are not the same thing as public policy crafted via the political process. It is true that business decisions can have public policy implications and vice versa. That doesn't make them the same thing though.
- eschulte 14y ago"Mr. Tower's [your] distinction [...] is spurious. The essence of censorship is the suppression of a particular point of view [...] over the channels of the mass media, and the question of who does the censoring is one of form only." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_censorship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_censorship
- eschulte 14y agoLet's say roughly 1/3 Americans own an iphone [1]. So yes, wether you like them or not and weather it is legal or not, Apple's politics (and I think keeping information from US citizens about their militaries actions is bad politics) are important. [1] probably not the best link, but probably close enough to the right answer http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_percentage_of_Americans_own_an_iPhone http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_percentage_of_Americans_own_a...
- Artistry121 14y agoI think a lot of the App Store rules will have to change eventually. It is anti-competitive for them to not allow apps that duplicate their functionality and Apple has "market-power". I'm not a lawyer but it seems to me that someone with strong market power and restrictions in place to slow competitors or ban them entirely is good grounds for an anti-trust suit.