7 ms·
Germany's identity crisis: The trains no longer run on time
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/9kInY https://archive.ph/9kInY
- ktallett 1y agoIs this an old article? They haven't consistently run on time for around a decade. The service is no better than supposedly worse trains in say the UK and is nowhere near say Korea's train system.
- cdrini 1y agoNo it's from August 5th. It includes some nice graphs, apparently the punctuality really plummeted around 2020.
- bot403 1y agoI wish the author would dive into that even a little bit. It looks like COVID killed the performance. Why? And what about post COVID?
- bookofjoe 1y agoMaybe train personnel out sick?
- cdrini 1y agoThe odd thing is it never recovered; it's stayed low since 2020.
- DemocracyFTW2 1y agoThe way neoliberalism dealt with the public sector including rail service and infrastructure and then come up with "COVID killed Deutsche Bahn" is like saying that poor old sucker who was pushed down the staircase succumbed to his running nose. The problems run much deeper and were already visible in the 70s and 80s, but because it's only the public sector and rail traffic, not about more highways and more cars and then even more cars it never got fixed. Because who needs rails and trains, right.
- ars 1y agoCOVID harmed most industries that rely on manual labor. Suggested reasons vary, one is that people discovered they could do mental-work, and preferred it (and apparently it never occurred to them before). Another reason is many retirements and a gap in knowledge transfer to the next generation. Another is a huge increase in demand for non-physical work during COVID that never went away, leaving other industries short handed (and it's not a pay thing, there's not enough people for all demand in all industries, someone must run short).
- petre 1y agoMaybe the DB staff went soft during the lockdowns. Maybe some employees left and institutional knowledge suffered. The same thing happened with the truck driver shortage.
- illiac786 1y agoThe data is misleading at best, probably manipulated. Let’s not forget the data is from DB itself. As an example, in 2018, the then boss of infra at DB, Ronald Pofalla introduced the “Pofalla Wende”, whereby a commuting train between two cities will simply turn around and not serve the rest of the line if it has a certain delay. In itself, one could argue it can make sense under certain circumstances. But all remaining stations on the line are not counted as delays, even if there is not replacement train. Same with cancellations, these don’t show up as delays. The situation is significantly more dire than what this data shows.
- soneil 1y agoIronically, DB owned many lines in the UK up until recently (via their ownership of Arriva)
- TaboZ 1y agoJeff Bezos might be interested in that market.
- thinkindie 1y agoI moved to Germany 10 years ago and while regional and suburban train service has been great, the long distance service has been terrible, with high prices, almost no high speed service and no competition. I'm Italian and therefore I had very low expectations, but at least high speed trains in Italy run better than Germany (at least until recently, when lack of regular maintenance work ultimately made its dent into the service quality). But for many software engineer this is not a big surprise: everyone knows that accumulating tech debt and neglecting maintence will eventually bite back sooner or later.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago> regional and suburban train service has been great In which city?
- bilbo0s 1y agoI don't know what others think, but Munich seemed reliable to me. YMMV
- schroeding 1y agoThe problem in Munich is that everything must go through a single two-track part underneath the city center, which is at absolute capacity. If anything breaks down there (and it does, often, very often), even a small delay in a single train, all trains get delayed or skip stops. In my experience, you have to take at least one train early if you do not want to come late regularly. Even e.g. the main airport train line, used by tourists, often turns around before the actual airport due to delays. If you live in the city itself, it's fine, you also have other options. If you live further away, it's barely acceptable to very bad, IMO. It is reliable-ish, but more "Amtrak Capital Corridor"-reliable than "JR Yamanote Line"-reliable.
- illiac786 1y agoVery nice comment, thanks. One remark only: TGV does not have to use the high speed rails only. It will just have to go slower on the other rails.
- fabian2k 1y agoThe punctuality of the trains has been more of a joke for quite a bit, I don't think it's a big part of German identity. The part that is really terrible are the long-distance trains. Not that the regional trains are always punctual, their reliability varies a lot per route. But they're not as bad as the long-distance trains. One big recent improvement is the Germany ticket, for 58 EUR per month you can take any regional train or bus.
- firefax 1y agoI got the impression they have a different cultural definition of "late" -- they'd get as mad about a 15 minute delay as folks in the states would get about an hour plus delay.
- MrJohz 1y agoMaybe twenty years ago, but these days it's pretty common to have hour-long delays, or to have trains be cancelled at short notice, or rearranged such that you won't get a connection. When traveling East/West, I'd pretty much always recommend planning a buffer of at least an hour, more if your journey involves connections.
- patrickmcnamara 1y ago6 minutes is late for DB. But trains are often much later (or cancelled).
- firefax 1y ago>6 minutes is late for DB This is what I was getting at... they equated a ten minute delay in the same category as an hour plus... it was atomic, binary -- that's what I meant to get at in my post, that the level of "umph" was the same. It's my understanding the delays that prompted the OP are longer, 30+ is a big deal even in the states.
- flobosg 1y ago> But they're not as bad as the long-distance trains. In my recent experience the most punctual trains I’ve taken have been long-distance ones, namely IC (as opposed to ICE). Not sure why, though.
- jeffbee 1y agoGermany, like America, is operated by and for the benefit of car companies. Their infrastructure difficulties share root causes with America's.
- general1726 1y agoOr there is a sane explanation - People drive cars -> People push their politicians to improve road infrastructure -> less money for other infrastructure -> trains are underfunded -> trains and tracks are having maintenance issues a reliability starts to fall apart -> people drive cars even more.
- jeffbee 1y agoWhile I agree that fundamentally the issue is that Germans spend more on cars than any other European population (but nowhere near as much as Americans), there is also the detail that a large share of VWAG is owned by a German state.
- DemocracyFTW2 1y agoif you judge driving cars as 'sane', sure; I don't
- general1726 1y agoI am just opposed to "big auto" idea being responsible for lack of investments in train network.
- DemocracyFTW2 1y agoit's exactly this
- firefax 1y agoNo longer? They were bitching and moaning when I visited fifteen years ago in my hostel. They got horrified when I told them they're coddled to be annoyed about 15 minute delays and spoke on how things are in the states... anyways this is troubling I guess... but it's not new. Edit: also, I found the English UI to be the best in the EU (yes, better than UK's) and traveled the continent on DB, so while I sympathize with wanting things better... as an American it was a pretty good system.
- heraldgeezer 1y ago>they're coddled >bitching and moaning Why is this always the American answer when anything good about EU gets brought up that maybe turned worse? Vacation, workdays, sickdays, parental leave, free schooling and healthcare? and public transport as here. It is a question of money, investment and what society you want. You chose the Ford F-150. For me in Sweden, we also have worse rail now, also due to the same issue. Maintenance is never "sexy" weather its fibre or rail. Parking, roads and cars nets points here too sadly.
- libraryatnight 1y agoAmerican here, very tired of the response you note. It's self defeating and depressing. Feels like any expectations for a good experience, for things to work, to be treated like a person, is mocked as childish naivete.
- gddgb 1y ago[dead]
- consumer451 1y ago[flagged]
- opan 1y agoAre you implying it's a WW2 reference? Did not occur to me before I saw your comment.
- consumer451 1y agoIt was the first thing that came to my mind, even though that referenced Mussolini. But I think about WWII probably too often. Maybe the editor wasn't thinking that at all.
- krapp 1y agoIt would be an odd reference to make since it's usually applied to Mussolini, falsely (it's propaganda, he did not actually make the trains run on time[0].) I suspect in this case it just generally refers to some archetype of efficient modern German infrastructure and engineering. [0]https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-15/stop-saying-mussolini-made-the-trains-run-on-time https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-15/stop-sayi...
- renewiltord 1y ago> Guy who has only seen The Boss Baby, watching his second movie: Getting a lot of 'Boss Baby' vibes from this...
- WalterBright 1y agoWhen I toured Germany in the 1980s with a train pass, there were clocks all over the train stations. If the train was scheduled to start at 11:07, when the big hand clicked to 7, the train started to move. It was wonderful. BTW, the D community is all over the world. We schedule a zoom meeting each month. When we began the meetings, and the meeting started at, say, 8, the meeting organizer would say "we need to wait a bit for the rest to join us". I put my foot down and said when the meeting is scheduled for 8, it starts at exactly 8. And everyone shows up on time! It's amazing how that works.
- WalterBright 1y agoWhen I worked at Boeing, we'd have a meeting now and then in a meeting room. The engineers showed up on time. The lead engineers showed up 10m late. The supervisor showed up 30m late. Anyone higher up, even later. This was never discussed, but the pattern was the same every meeting. I seriously disliked that nonsense.
- c-linkage 1y agoThat is why I do not like the American traffic signaling system. When the light turns red cross traffic has a two to three second delay. My feeling is that if people knew the cross traffic would go immediately when the light turned red they would certainly stop. But right now they know there's a buffer so they just run the red light.
- WalterBright 1y agoAround here the power goes out to the lights now and then. Interestingly, the traffic flows smoother and faster without the lights! Even the arterials! It's amazing! Drivers simply politely cooperate with each other. (The same thing happens when a traffic cop handles the intersection.) I'm always assured that the city traffic light engineers know what they're doing and design the lights for maximum flow. They do no such thing. They are either incompetent or deliberately set things up to impede the flow of traffic. Most of the lights now have cameras on them. Would it be so hard to connect them up to AI with the goal of "maximize throughput"? Imagine how much gas would be saved. It would be tremendous!
- junto 1y agoLast year 38C3: https://media.ccc.de/v/38c3-wann-klappt-der-anschluss-wann-nicht-und-wie-sagt-man-chaos-vorher https://media.ccc.de/v/38c3-wann-klappt-der-anschluss-wann-n...
- bamboozled 1y agoWhen have they ran on time sorry ? The last time I caught a train in Germany I remember having to wait on a freezing platform for ~ 3 hours until they gave up on the train and got us a coach and drove us to Hamburg...that was ~ 9 years ago. I don't remember having the same issue in Netherlands though. On the other hand I've been in Japan for a long time, I honestly don't remember a single train being late in all that time.
- 1718627440 1y agoIt's compared to before the train reform. 9 years is only 2016.
- nudgeOrnurture 1y agodude, Germany's identy crisis is that Germans still don't get the potential they have. They are still, after decades of American ( I love America but I think they had it waaaaaay too easy in the past decades ) easy mode, not realizing they are playing the game of others. Two bad examples: there's a PhD level genius just a few villages away and he still didn't even try to get the funding to build a proper mechatronics Hogwarts in our area ( it's 2025 ... ) and a nuclear Physics PhD, who's now a banker ( crying laughing joker emoji, a fucking banker, like one of those modern Kazakhs, crying laughing Joker emoji ) just a little further away .... who's daddy is also a Physics PhD and has been in IT for 30 years or so ... Iean, sure, money, but is that all "agency" or just the result of priming/nudging towards the lower levels? Good little Germans, just do as I do, keep your lips ( and minds ) sealed .... walk away it's 4 to 8 hours of work per day anyway and you got the brains for it, ma dudes and dudettes, what the fuuuuuuuck
- cooper_ganglia 1y ago[flagged]
- nicbou 1y agoThese problems predate the immigration waves
- TacticalCoder 1y ago[dead]
- flobosg 1y agoIn the last few weeks I’ve had friends lose/almost lose their flights in Germany because their trains were several hours late.
- account42 1y agoTrains here are bad and the ones to/from Frankfurt are almost always delayed IME but surely you have other options to fall back on for getting there (or to whatever airport) that take less than "several hours".
- flobosg 1y agoGood luck with those fallback plans when your train stops in the middle of nowhere for an extended period of time. Or getting a full refund for that taxi you had to take to reach your intended destination.
- bdisl 1y agoI don’t understand why someone would take the train instead of his car unless he wanted to take the risk of losing the flight.
- hearsathought 1y agoFor starters, you don't have to worry about getting stuck in traffic, getting in an accident or the car breaking down. You also don't have to worry about parking the car at the airport. I guess one's viewpoint on the matter depends on the public infrastructure in one's region.
- cadamsdotcom 1y ago> “The reliability of the railway must be significantly improved,” Patrick Schnieder, Germany’s new transportation minister said .. calling the punctuality numbers “unsatisfactory.” Passengers often make the same point — but using expletives. Thanks for the chuckle!
- karim79 1y agoI found this article a couple of hours ago, it's fun to see it here as a thread. I live in Germany and I sent the article to my former manager. His response, verbatim, was this: "This pisses me off so deeply". I went on to muse about the "academic quarter hour" and that now "six minutes is now German standard lateness". All in good faith, and hell of a lot of fun.
- eviks 1y agoThe old data chart shows that they never did run on time, so it was always just a myth. Well, don't build your identity on lies and you won't have a crisis :)
- netsharc 1y agoI remember last decade seeing an ad on a Deutsche Bahn "ticket envelope" (remember those things?) promoting their new mobile app, proudly telling everyone "now with delays notification!"...
- illiac786 1y agoThe diagram is confusing because DB has started “massaging” the data. As an example, if a train which travels back and forth between two cities has a certain amount of delay, it will just turn around and not serve the remaining stations on the line. And that’s as many stations not counted as delays. This trick is named the “pofalla turnaround”, after the DB infrastructure boss Ronald Pofalla who introduced it in 2018. And I think that’s just one trick, meaning the downfall starts earlier and is more significant I suspect.
- justlikereddit 1y agoWhy would a de-industrialized third world country amalgamation have trains running on time? Germany took some choices about where it's going as a nation and now complaining about how the destination terrain is shaping up. I'd hope they discover causality one day but I'm afraid that ship already sailed.
- pjmlp 1y agoSadly true, always plan your trip with at least half an hour exchange, with as minimal train exchanges as possible. Also pick train stations for the exchange where there are more options for follow up connection trains, in case that half an hour is not enough. Additionally good luck with luggage, the new trains hardly have any space for luggage, I don't understand how they are supposed to be an alternative to cars, if the only luggage I can fit on the upper compartment is a slim backpack, under the seat, or if I am lucky fighting for a slot on the single luggage compartment in the middle of the wagon.
- twobitshifter 1y agoI always thought Swiss trains were the ones with the reputation for being on time.