4 ms·
Proxmox Virtual Environment 9.0 with Debian 13 released
- Takennickname 1y ago"It’s also possible to install Proxmox VE 9.0 on top of Debian." Has that always been the case? I have a faint memory of trying once and not being able to with Proxmox 7.x
- oakwhiz 1y agoI do it this way every time.
- robeastham 1y agoI'm pretty sure it's been the case since at least 7.0, as I've done it a few times on hosts such as Scaleway that only offered a Debian base image for my machine.
- ChocolateGod 1y agoYeh. It's useful when trying to install onto partition setups the built in installer doesn't support OOTB. But, things like proxmox-boot-tool may not work.
- rcarmo 1y agoI've done it a few times--8.x for sure, maybe earlier, but I've now been using it for too long to remember accurately.
- SirMaster 1y agoYes it's always been the case. I installed Proxmox 3.4 (based on Debian 7) this way originally, and have been upgrading ever since with no issues.
- lillecarl 1y agoYou can even install Proxmox on NixOS now (no official support ofc) though https://github.com/SaumonNet/proxmox-nixos https://github.com/SaumonNet/proxmox-nixos Which I think is really cool since it means their stuff is "truly open-source" :)
- zozbot234 1y agoSomewhat annoyingly, Proxmox relies on a non-Debian kernel for at least some of its features. This definitely made a difference w/ Bookworm (which was on the 6.1 kernel release series), not sure about Trixie (which will be on 6.12).
- throw0101c 1y ago> Has that always been the case? I have a faint memory of trying once and not being able to with Proxmox 7.x We did it for 7.x [1] and it worked fine (since upgraded things in-place to 8.x). [1] https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Install_Proxmox_VE_on_Debian_11_Bullseye https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Install_Proxmox_VE_on_Debian_11...
- m463 1y agoI wonder about things like this. It seems to me people who try things like this might also be ok with spaces in filenames, or replacing bash with csh... It should work, but you might want to cross your fingers.
- rcarmo 1y agoI just installed 9.0 atop Trixie. Works fine, just follow https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Install_Proxmox_VE_on_Debian_12_Bookworm https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Install_Proxmox_VE_on_Debian_12... and replace the distro name.
- sschueller 1y agoThe official release of Debian Trixie is not until the 9th...
- piperswe 1y agoTrixie is under a heavy freeze right now; just about all that's changing between now and the 9th are critical bug fixes. Yeah it's not ideal for Proxmox to release an OS based on Trixie this early, but nothing's really going to change in the next few days on the Debian side except for final release ISOs being uploaded
- zozbot234 1y agoThey might drop packages between now and the stable release. An official Debian release won't generally drop packages unless they've become totally unusable to begin with.
- piperswe 1y agoGiven that Proxmox operates their own repos for their custom packages and users don't typically install their own packages on top of Proxmox, if a package they need gets dropped due to RC bugs (etc) they can upload it to their own repo
- tlamponi 1y agoWe manage anything, including package builds, ourselves if the need should arise; we also monitor Debian and release critical bugs closely, we see no realistic potential for any Proxmox relevant package to disappear, at least nothing higer compared to that happening after the 9th. FWIW, we got staff members that are also directly involved with Debian which makes things a bit easier.
- znpy 1y agoDebian repositories gets frozen months in advance before a release, and pretty much only security patches are imported after that. Maybe some package gets rebuilt, or stuff like that. No breaking changes. I wouldn't expect much changes, if any a all, between today (Aug 5th) and the expected release date (Aug 9th).
- riedel 1y agoWe are really happy with proxmox for our 4 machine cluster in the group. We evaluated many things, they were either to light or to heavy for our users and/or our group of hobbyist admins. A while back we also set up a backup server. Forum is also a great resource. I just failed to contribute a pull request via their git email workflow and I am now stuck with a non-upstreamed patch to the LDAP Sync (btw. the code there is IMHO not the best part of PVE). In general, while the system works great as a monolith, extending it is IMHO really not easily possible. We have some cludges all over the place (mostly using the really good API), that could be better integrated, e.g. with the UI. At least I did not find a way to e.g. add a new auth provider easily.
- woleium 1y agoCan’t it use pam? so many options for providers there.
- riedel 1y agoIt was mostly about syncing groups with proxmox. Worked by patching the LDAP provider to support our schema. Comment was more about the extensibility problem when doing this. Actually when you say this, I wonder how PAM could work, only ever used it for providing shell access: we typically do not have any local users on the machine. Never used PAM in a way not providing any local execution privileges (which is the whole point of a VM host).
- woleium 1y agopam groups are not synced into proxmox for permission management :( Apparently with OIDC (with group claims), Proxmox can map group membership from OIDC tokens and autocreate or map groups dynamically at user login
- yla92 1y ago> The Proxmox VE mobile interface has been thoroughly reworked, using the new Proxmox widget toolkit powered by the Rust-based Yew framework. First time hearing about Yew (yew.rs). First time hearing about it. Is it like writing frontend code in Rust and compiled to WASM ? Is anyone using it (other than Proxmox folks, of course).
- dylanowen 1y agoI'm using it for a browser extension, just because I wanted to code more in rust. It's great at what it does and has all the same paradigms from React. The best use case though, would be if all your code is already rust. If you have a complex UI I'd probably use react and typescript.
- tlamponi 1y ago> Is it like writing frontend code in Rust and compiled to WASM ? Exactly, it's actually quite lightweight and stable plus mostly finished, so don't let the slower upstream releases discourage you from ever trying it more extensively. We build a widget library with our products as main target around Yew and native web technologies, you can check out: https://github.com/proxmox/proxmox-yew-widget-toolkit https://github.com/proxmox/proxmox-yew-widget-toolkit And the example repo: https://github.com/proxmox/proxmox-yew-widget-toolkit-examples https://github.com/proxmox/proxmox-yew-widget-toolkit-exampl... For code and a little bit more info. We definitively need to clean a few documentation and resource things up, but we tried to make it so that it can be reused by others without tying them to our API types or the like. FWIW, the in-development Proxmox Datacenter Manager also uses our Rust / Yew based UI, it's basically our first 100% rust project (well, minus the Linux / Debian foundation naturally, but it's getting there ;-)
- xattt 1y agoUgh, I’d love to make the leap, but I don’t want the headache of trying to get SR-IOV going again for my integrated Intel graphics.
- throw0101c 1y agoI've heard good things about XCP-ng [1] as well: anyone use both that can lay out the pros/cons of each? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XCP-ng https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XCP-ng
- nirav72 1y agoI can't speak for pros and cons with XCP-Ng. I've been meaning to try out XCP-ng. But feel like there just isn't a large enough community support around it yet. At least not like Proxmox, which has seen a surge in usage and popularity after the Broadcom fiasco.
- unixhero 1y agoMaybe a surge of newcomers, but the community was strong before and irrespective of the fiasco.
- nick__m 1y agoWe tried both at work and thet were more or less equivalent but proxmox appears to have more momentum behind it. Also distributed storage in proxmox is based on ceph while xcpng use the obscure xostor
- throw0101c 1y agoHighlights of the release (release notes): * https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Roadmap#Proxmox_VE_9.0 https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Roadmap#Proxmox_VE_9.0
- grmone 1y ago"Proxmox VE is using a newer Linux kernel 6.14.8-2 as stable default enhancing hardware compatibility and performance." kernel.org don't even list version 6.14 anymore. do they backport security patches on there own?
- Arrowmaster 1y agoI don't know what they are currently doing, but historically Proxmox uses Debian as the OS base but with Ubuntu as the kernel source. So they rely on the Ubuntu security team backporting security patches for the kernel.
- whiztech 1y agoSeems like it still is: https://git.proxmox.com/?p=pve-kernel.git;a=shortlog https://git.proxmox.com/?p=pve-kernel.git;a=shortlog
- nativeit 1y agoI wouldn’t expect it to be, as kernel.org don’t list distribution kernels. (Ignore this if it’s irrelevant and I’m missing the point, which is always a distinct possibility) > Many Linux distributions provide their own "longterm maintenance" kernels that may or may not be based on those maintained by kernel developers. These kernel releases are not hosted at kernel.org and kernel developers can provide no support for them. > It is easy to tell if you are running a distribution kernel. Unless you downloaded, compiled and installed your own version of kernel from kernel.org, you are running a distribution kernel. To find out the version of your kernel, run uname -r:
- PeterStuer 1y agoI have only recently moved to proxmox as the Hyper-V licensing became too opressive for hobby/one-person projects use. Can someone tell me wether proxmox upgrades are usually smooth sailing, or should I prepare for this being an endeavour?
- thyristan 1y agoNever had a problem with them. Just put each node in maintenance, migrate the VMs to another node, update, move the VMs back. Repeat until all nodes are updated.
- woleium 1y agoif you are using hardware pass through for e.g. nvidia cards you have to update your VMs as well, but other than that pretty painless in my experience (over 15 years)
- zamadatix 1y agoThe "update" step is a bit of a "draw the rest of the owl" in the case of major version updates like this 8.x -> 9.x release. It also depends how many features you're using in that cluster as to how complicated the owl is to draw. That said, I just made it out alright in my home lab without too much hullabaloo.
- pimeys 1y agoDid you do the backup and full reinstall or just with apt? I should do the same update this weekend. .
- zamadatix 1y agoJust with editing the apt sources and running apt commands. There is a nice pre-conversion checker which will alert you to anything special you have to (or may want to) do prior to beginning that process.
- guerby 1y ago
- redundantly 1y agoI like Promox a lot, but I wish it had an equivalent to VMware's VMFS. The last time I tried, there wasn't a way to use shared storage (i.e., iscsi block devices) across multiple nodes and have a failover of VMs that use that storage. And by failover I mean moving a VM to another host and booting it there, not even keeping the VM running.
- SlavikCA 1y agoProxmox has built-in support for CEPH, which is promoted as VMFS equivalent. I don't have much experience with them, so can't tell if it's really on the same level.
- thyristan 1y agoProxmox with Ceph can do failover when a node fails. You can configure a VM as high-availability to automatically make it boot on a leftover node after a crash: https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/High_Availability https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/High_Availability . When you add ProxLB, you can also automatically load-balance those VMs. One advantage Ceph has over VMware is that you don't need specially approved hardware to run it. Just use any old disks/SSDs/controllers. No special extra expensive vSAN hardware. But I cannot give you a full comparison, because I don't know all of VMware that well.
- woleium 1y agoYes, you can do this with ceph on commodity hardware (or even your compute nodes, if you are brave), or if you have a bit of cash, something like a netapp to do NFS/iSCSI/NVME-oF Use any of these with the built in HA manager in proxmox
- redundantly 1y agoAs far as I understand it, Ceph allows you to create distributed storage by using the hardware across your hosts. Can it be used to format a single shared block device that is accessed by multiple hosts like VMFS does? My understanding is this isn't possible.
- nativeit 1y agoStill use/love Proxmox daily. Congrats to the team on the latest release!
- avtar 1y agoI would see Proxmox come up in so many homelab type conversations so I tried 8.* on a mini pc. The impression I got was that the project probably provides the most value in a clustered environment or even on a single node if someone prefers using a web UI. What didn't seem very clear was an out-of-box way for declaring VM and container configurations [1] that could then be version controlled. Common approaches seemed to involve writing scripts or reach for other tools like Ansible. Whereas something like LXD/Incus makes this easier [2] by default. Or maybe I'm missing some details? [1] https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/default-settings-of-containers-and-virtual-machines.129311/ https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/default-settings-of-contai... [2] https://linuxcontainers.org/incus/docs/main/howto/instances_create/#pass-a-configuration-file https://linuxcontainers.org/incus/docs/main/howto/instances_...
- cyberpunk 1y agoThere are various terraform providers for proxmox.
- whalesalad 1y agoYeah, this is the way. You end up treating Proxmox like it is AWS and asserting your desired state against it.
- cassianoleal 1y agoYou don't. The existing providers only deal with spinning up VMs and containers. Most of the operations and configurations that exist in Proxmox are not present in the providers, like SDN, firewall and the various storage options. The reason is that the API is all over the place and really badly documented. Note that I still quite like the product. I have a 2- (soon to be 3-) node cluster at home and at this moment I have no plans to migrate away from it. I looked into Incus but it's also far from mature, with an API and general data structure being full of inconsistencies, and again the documentation is not quite there.
- m463 1y agoI have similar feelings. I really wish proxmox had nicer container support. If a proxmox container config could specify a dockerfile as an option, I think proxmox would be 1000% more useful (and successful) Instead with LXC and their config files, I feel like i have to put on a sysadmin hat to get a container going. Seems like picking up an adding machine to do my taxes. (also, lxc does have a way to specify a container, but it is not used) Instead I have written scripts to automate some of this, which helps, There is also cloud-init, but I found it sort of unfriendly and never went anywhere with it.
- krisknez 1y agoI would love if Proxmox had a UI for port forwarding. I hate doing it through the terminal. I like how LXD has a UI for that.
- BodyCulture 1y agoSeems like it still has no official support for any kind of disk encryption, so you are on your own if you fiddle that in somehow and things may break. Such a beautiful, peaceful world where disk encryption is not needed!
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoFor my homelab I switched from ESXi to Proxmox a few years ago because the consumer-level hardware I mostly used didn't have Intel network cards and ESXi didn't support the Realtek network devices that were ubiquitous in consumer gear at the time. Love Proxmox, it's done everything I needed of it. I don't use it to anywhere near it's potential, but I can vouch for the robustness of its backup process. I've had to restore more than handful of VMs for various reasons, and they've all been rock-solid upon restoration. I would like to use its high-availability features, but haven't needed them and don't really have the time to tinker so much these days.