3 ms·
So. I teach at a university and I do give an "assignment" exactly like this. In a few of my classes, I have final projects that teams work on. I also have pres
by jrm4 1y ago
So. I teach at a university and I do give an "assignment" exactly like this.
In a few of my classes, I have final projects that teams work on. I also have presentations. I used to require them of all students; and quickly learned this is a good way to waste valuable time.
Now, all my presentations are completely optional for NO CREDIT. You don't get penalized if you don't do them, and perhaps more importantly, I give ZERO EXTRA CREDIT for doing them.
As you can imagine, every single presentation I've gotten from this has been absolutely worth it.
- DANmode 1y agoWhat were the best three?
- jrm4 1y agoHmm, I mean been doing this for years. Some were interesting because they DIDN'T accomplish much and things went bad but then we could kind of post-mortem in the class. Others had some pretty cool things that ended up in real life; I believe the official timers for the Florida Supreme Court testimony things came from one of my classes.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tsukikage 1y agoWhat proportion of students bother?
- jrm4 1y agoIt seems to go in waves? Rarely is it one or two, I imagine there's some peer pressure thing going on. Something like all or nothing.
- neffy 1y agoI do the same in my classes, and it´s common practice in many courses my dept which may help, as the students know what is expected of them. I don´t think it's wasting time. It motivates the students to know that they have to present in front of their peers, helps the shy ones get practice, and yes the quality varies, but it´s a very good way to share information within the class about different projects, even with a not so good presentation.
- coderatlarge 1y agowhich students fail your class?
- jrm4 1y agoI get very few failures, but that's a selection thing; it's a junior senior "big picture" IT class.
- coderatlarge 1y agounderstood thanks - but in those few cases how do you even determine who fails?