4 ms·
The Linux Alternative Project
- newt0311 18y agoAnother great music players for terminal hackers: mocp Also, I resent the non-inclusion of emacs at least in the notepad, mIRC, and TeXnic center replacement sections.
- Zak 18y agoA couple problems come to mind with this. The first is that the page failes to mention a couple cases where a Linux-native version of the named program exists (Acrobat Reader and Limewire. The second is that they're using a pretty loose definition of an alternative; I can't see a Dreamweaver user being happy with Bluefish, for example.
- lallysingh 18y agoIndeed. The raw list is nice, but it'd be better to be honest about what each program does. A simple description line for many could cover that comparison, and/or a table where the featureset is more discrete.
- hboon 18y agoIs there an OS X equivalent?
- yef 18y agohttp://www.osalt.com/ http://www.osalt.com/ includes Mac, thanks dchest.
- dchest 18y agoI like this one better: http://www.osalt.com/ http://www.osalt.com/
- yef 18y agoNice list, but this really needs to be dumped into a Reddit implementation so we can vote and comment. Side project, anyone?
- dotan 18y agoIt actually has comments, which you can see by clicking the app links, but no voting. The whole app-to-app mapping is a silly idea, though. Is powerpoint an alternative for Visio? depends on what your trying to do. Gimp is a fine alternative for Photoshop if you're making a web logo, animated gif or lolcat, but maybe not if you're a printshop.
- omnipath 18y agoThere is no alternative for Microsoft Access. It's sad, but true.
- alecco 18y agoSQLite with any high level language, maybe with an ORM.
- gaius 18y agoErmm, no. Not even close. Access is a tool for building simple GUI database applications that also happens to contain an embedded database for said applications. This is what I meant in my GIMP comment; the Linux community doesn't understand what the users of any of this stuff are trying to do. So they just make something that looks a bit like it, and wonder why no-one seems interested in switching.
- hexis 18y agoNot so long ago, free software barely had browsers that were acceptable to the mainstream. Now it does. It'll get to Access, it just takes time. Free Software still has a lot of ground to make up, but it is gaining ground on proprietary software.
- gaius 18y agoYou might be right, but claiming that SQLite (a fine piece of software that I often use) is a substitute for Access in the here and now is unreasonable.
- tremendo 18y agohttp://www.kexi-project.org/ http://www.kexi-project.org/
- gaius 18y agoI have to wonder how much serious photo retouching anyone who thinks GIMP is an alternative to Photoshop really does. Without 48-bit colour, Pantone and gamma, GIMP isn't even on the table. Similar points can be made about many of the "alternatives". Superficially they may look the same, but they're written by people trying to replicate existing software without understanding the users first.
- yef 18y agoI think you nailed the problem with this type of software -- they lag behind the cutting edge because they copy features from the leaders rather than innovate on their own. (There are some exceptions to that, though, in the case where the project is driven by someone ambitious and passionate.) I think the point is that they provide free alternatives to the majority of users who need to use them, but who don't need the full feature set of a pay version. I use gimp and oocalc all the time, but I'm not a power user, so they tend to work out just fine.
- windsurfer 18y agoGimp does have 48-bit colour, ever since they added GEGL support. And really, Pantone? You can't even accurately display Pantone on monitors, as Photoshop tells you if you've even used that feature. You only use Pantone colours for the printer. Lastly, gamma? You can apply a gamma layer if you'd really like to. I don't see what the big deal is. I guess I should conclude this by saying "Stop spreading the FUD" but you likely just heard those buzz-phrases from a friend and are repeating them here. Gimp is a wonderful and professional program that performs quite well for most people's needs. It most certainly is "on the table".
- tdonia 18y agowhile it is true that you cannot accurately display Pantone on screen, Pantone colors are essential for getting things printed correctly & good graphic (print) designers know exactly how their screen representation might differ from the paper prints. I agree that the gimp is functionally good for many users, but right now it's caught in a weird space splitting 2 markets rather than committing to one. if it is intended to be a complete alternate to photoshop, great, make it so. you can start with the list above, but there are many other features beyond those that are similar but not the same. if the intent is not to be a replica of photoshop & rather to provide a photo editing tool that covers a wider market (that maybe doesn't need Pantone/print integrity) that's fine too - but then they've got a lot of work to do in making the experience friendly to that wider/non-photoshopper market. I don't think the parent was spreading FUD, rather, i think gimp needs to be more clear about setting expectations. maybe it's just a me-problem that doesn't apply outside this anecdote, but i've tried to get convinced by gimp many times through many versions and it's always hit that uncanny valley that inspired too much fear, uncertainty & doubt to become part of my everyday workflow.