> As for your question, I don't see what it proves. The author made a claim I showed the claim was false The author bases his argument on this and similar cl

> As for your question, I don't see what it proves. The author made a claim I showed the claim was false The author bases his argument on this and similar claims. Showing his claim is false says he's argument doesn't hold > and is only incorrect by a broad characterization I don't know of I'd really call a single item an "edge case" so much as generalization. But I do know I'd answer that question differently given your reframing.