5 ms·
You Don't Need a Full-Size Pickup Truck, You Need a Cowboy Costume - https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowbo
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
You Don't Need a Full-Size Pickup Truck, You Need a Cowboy Costume - https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowboy-costume https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz... - March 15th, 2019
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42638394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42638394 - January 2025
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21631704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21631704 - November 2019
Ray Delahanty | CityNerd: Rural Cosplay is, Unfortunately, A Thing
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6q_BE5KPp18 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6q_BE5KPp18
(Americans buy trucks out of emotion and cosplay, not realized utility and rational TCO, based on the evidence and data)
- Aurornis 1y ago> Americans buy trucks out of emotion and cosplay This is a hilarious take for anyone who has spent any time living outside of a big city. Yes, there are some people who buy trucks because they want one but don’t actually use the truck features. Generalizing to “Americans are cosplaying” is just trolling.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoStudy Claims That Most Pickup Truck Owners Don’t Actually Use Them For Truck Stuff - September 2023 https://www.powernationtv.com/post/most-pickup-truck-owners-use-them https://www.powernationtv.com/post/most-pickup-truck-owners-... https://www.axios.com/ford-pickup-trucks-history https://www.axios.com/ford-pickup-trucks-history
- kortilla 1y agoFrom that own study it shows more than half are using it at least “occasionally” for “hauling”. I’d like to see the study on what percentage of people use all 4 seats in their car so you can dunk on people who buy 4 seaters next.
- master-lincoln 1y agoYou make it sound like it would be unreasonable to dunk on people wasting our society resources. Why not hit on people driving 4 seat cars when they drive alone most of the time? If it affects me it should be normal that I voice an opinion. Those cars use public space, roads, bridges that are affected more the heavier your car is. That also drives up the motor power needed which in turn increases public air pollution.
- kortilla 1y agoElectric cars weigh far more than a gas Toyota Corolla. You don’t want to go down that path
- master-lincoln 1y agoWhy do I not want to go down that path? Of course I do. It's a trade-off.
- Aurornis 1y agoYou’re spamming this same study throughout the thread without realizing that is uses a different and much stricter definition of “hauling” than the average person.
- masklinn 1y agoThis demonstrating the average person is an idiot who never needed a truck because their “hauling” can be done with a sedan or even a compact car. Which is rather the point.
- 15155 1y agoCould it be possible that while you can cram something in the backseat of a car, a truck bed might result in less damage to vehicle interiors and the object being moved?
- giraffe_lady 1y agoI live in a big city and two children under 10 have been killed by large pickup trucks within a half mile of my home in the last five years. Two that I know of anyway, because I'm acquainted with the families. One had been modified with a "bull bar" making it more dangerous to pedestrians. And 80% of americans live in urban areas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullbar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullbar
- troupo 1y ago> This is a hilarious take for anyone who has spent any time living outside of a big city. People outside of big city need big trucks about as often as people in the city. Source: lived in the middle of nowhere in North Carolina. Living outside of big city doesn't mean you're immediately a farmer who needs to haul tons of forage or lumber. The absolute vast majority of people don't.
- Ray20 1y ago>based on the evidence and data >Evidence and data show that cake taste better than bread, why are they starving? Let them eat cake I really wonder what kind of world people live in who write such articles and what kind of world people live in who seriously read them. It's hard to believe that they live among us, there must be some separate island in the ocean or something like that where they can write their articles in complete isolation from the rest of the world.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoEhh, vehicle affordability rapidly accelerating away as the middle class evaporates solves the problem if people can’t make financially rational choices themselves. As of this comment, the average price of a new full-size pickup truck is around $64,000, while the average price of a new mid-size pickup truck is about $42,690. This is before tariff impacts are baked in. Doesn’t include operating costs (fuel, insurance, maintenance), putting monthly payments around $1k/month (at least). Let them drive studio apartments around I suppose, if they can get financed and not repo’d in the near term. Would you cry for me if I wanted a Lambo but couldn’t afford it? You would not. This is different? Everyone is entitled to wildly conspicuous consumption? I argue no.
- Ray20 1y ago>affordability rapidly accelerating away as the middle class evaporates solves the problem But that complete bs. Vehicle affordability is not in any danger, average price of a new pickus trucks depends on the amount of money the population has. Even if the middle class completely disappears, people will just drive cheaper pickups. >Would you cry for me if I wanted a Lambo but couldn’t afford it? But they could. And that the reason why "the average price of a new full-size pickup truck is around $64,000"
- toomuchtodo 1y ago> But they could. And that the reason why "the average price of a new full-size pickup truck is around $64,000" Car Repos Hit Levels Unseen Since 2008 Financial Crisis - https://www.pymnts.com/transportation/2025/car-repos-hit-levels-unseen-since-2008-financial-crisis/ https://www.pymnts.com/transportation/2025/car-repos-hit-lev... - March 27th, 2025 Late Car Payments Hit Highest Rate in More Than 30 Years - https://www.pymnts.com/loans/2025/late-car-payments-hit-highest-rate-in-more-than-30-years/ https://www.pymnts.com/loans/2025/late-car-payments-hit-high... - March 6th, 2025 St Louis Fed FRED: Average Amount Financed for New Car Loans at Finance Companies - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DTCTLVENANM https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DTCTLVENANM I’ll see if I have access to the Cox Automotive pickup truck specific repo stats as soon as I’m not mobile. Based on the auto loan delinquency and repo rates, the evidence is fairly robust that people cannot afford these price levels. They get off the lot with the vehicle, certainly, that’s super easy due to easy credit, but then the clock starts ticking on when the car gets repo’d. (~100M Americans are sub 700 FICO subprime, 33-40% of consumers depending on credit reporting agency providing the data)
- monkeyelite 1y ago> Americans buy trucks out of emotion and cosplay, You don't need anything besides tent and food! Every person buys almost everything for emotion.
- jakelazaroff 1y agoSure, but large trucks come with a ton of very negative externalities.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoRight, carbon emissions, excess deaths incurred on others, etc.
- monkeyelite 1y agoThe original comment is just about how "irrational" it is. And truck owners pay more - for the vehicle, for tires, for registration, for gas, etc which are all taxed by the public to reflect their greater usage of public roads. You would need to argue that trucks have a disproportionate impac. For example, if I commute 2 hours to work in an Accord, is that a greater negative externality than owning a Truck a commuting 15 minutes? I suspect the answer is no - a truck is some small multiple of a smaller vehicle. What I see in this thread is that the narrow demographic here is merely expressing a preference - they don't like trucks, and they wish that could be imposed on others. Ultimately, you need to convince your fellow men in an election.
- amarshall 1y agoSmall multiplier, I think not. Pickup trucks weigh about 1.5x as much as a sedan (comparing Camry to F150). Due to the fourth power law, they should be taxed about 5 times higher than a sedan simply for road maintainence. I don’t have the numbers, but I doubt that is so. Toll roads typically charge per axle, and as below, gas tax is probably only about 2x. Ironically, EVs should pay more tax for maintenance since they are usually quite a bit heavier—though the OP truck is still ~600 lb lighter than an F150. Fuel economy is about half in a pickup vs. a sedan, so they pollute that much more. Gas tax obviously scales here, but do the other taxes? Does gas tax go towards remedying the pollution impact at all? I don’t know. Then there’s the safety impact on pedestrians and other vehicles. I don’t have numbers here, sorry.
- kortilla 1y agoThis is one of the dumbest takes I’ve seen on trucks. It attacks a straw man. If you buy something for one of its features and don’t use the others, it doesn’t have anything to do with cosplay. This is like saying people who buy electric cars should just buy race car driver costumes instead. Unbridled ignorance.
- jakelazaroff 1y agoMost race cars aren't electric though? That analogy makes no sense. If you buy a product that comes with a ton of negative externalities and then don't use the single feature that distinguishes it from other products, people will rightly judge you.
- modernpacifist 1y ago> Most race cars aren't electric though? That analogy makes no sense. No, they aren't. I attend a significant amount of track events as a driver and I will see maybe 1 electic car every few events. Besides the lack of charging infrastrucutre at most race tracks, the one positive of instant torque/power is significantly outweighed by their overall mass and significant heat generation. The latter tends to result in a Tesla S being unable to last more than 20 minutes at Laguna Seca or Sonoma before the battery pack overheats and reduces power output requiring the car to exit the track.
- kortilla 1y agoElectric cars have great acceleration. According to this thread that’s just pointless cosplay.
- jakelazaroff 1y agoThey also produce no tailpipe emissions and tend to have a lower carbon footprint, more storage space, a quieter cabin, no "hump" for the driveshaft, etc. There are lots of reasons you might choose an electric car other than the acceleration. On the other hand, a truck's single distinguishing feature is the bed.
- 1y ago
- jcgrillo 1y agoI'm shopping for a truck atm because I need one. I am pretty routinely overloading the towing capacity of my Land Cruiser, and a decent flatbed pickup would obviate the need to hook up the trailer most of the time. Being able to tow/haul 3-4cord of firewood logs in one go would be super convenient, I'll use that capability at least once per year. And if you're thinking "why not just rent?" I'll ask when was the last time you saw an equipment trailer rental with a winch capable of hauling logs up onto it? Paradoxically, at least in the context of this thread, my motivation to own a truck is safety and efficiency. A 12 valve Cummins pulling the GCVWR of a 1994-1998.5 3/4 ton Dodge will get right around 10mpg and do it safely.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI admit there are many of you out there, and have no problem with folks who need a truck for truck use cases. That's what trucks are for. I take issue with those buying them for non rational use cases (status, etc), "Pavement Princess" vehicle duty cycles.