4 ms·
> as a vibe coding skeptic, I was amazed. The interesting thing about all of this vibe coding skepticism, cynicism, and backlash is that many people have their
by Aurornis 1y ago
> as a vibe coding skeptic, I was amazed.
The interesting thing about all of this vibe coding skepticism, cynicism, and backlash is that many people have their expectations set extremely low. They’re convinced everything the tools produce will be junk or that the worst case examples people provide are representative of the average.
Then they finally go out and use the tools and realize that they exceed their (extremely low) expectations, and are amazed.
Yeah we all know Claude Code isn’t going to generate a $10 billion SaaS with a team of 10 people or whatever the social media engagement bait VCs are pushing this week. However, the tools are more powerful than a lot of people give them credit for.
- Freedom2 1y agoIt doesn't help that a lot of skeptics are also dishonest. A few days ago someone here tried to claim that inserting verbose debug logging, something Claude Code would be very good at, is "actually programming" and it's important work for humans to do. No, Claude can create logs all across my codebase with much better formatting far faster than I can, so I can focus on actual problem solving. It's frustrating, but par for the course for this forum. Edit: Dishonest isn't correct, I should have said I just disagree with their statements. I do apologize.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoThat's not what dishonesty means. That's just someone who disagrees with you
- Freedom2 1y agoThank you for calling out my inaccuracy. One thing I'm always appreciative for in HN is the level of pedantry day after day.
- tecleandor 1y agoThat's not pedantry, pedantry would be if it were a very minor or technical detail, but being dishonest doesn't have anything to do with having a different opinion. But this comment might step a bit into pedantry.
- radley 1y ago> But this comment might step a bit into pedantry. Especially if I point out that they said "are also", not "are".
- y1n0 1y agoThat's not what pedantry means.
- radley 1y agoNo, some skeptics are actually dishonest. It's part of trolling, and trolling is in fashion right now. Granted, some skeptics are fair, but many do it strictly for the views, without any due diligence.
- qsort 1y agoPeople are using different definitions of "vibe coding". If you expect to just prompt without even looking at the code and being involved in the process the result will be crap. This doesn't preclude the usefulness of models as tools, and maybe in the future vibe coding will actually work. Essentially every coder I respect has an opinion that is some shade of this. There are the social media types you mention and their polar opposites, the "LLMs have no possible use" crowd. These people are mostly delusional. At the grown-ups table, there is a spectrum of opinions about the relative usefulness. It's not contradictory to believe that the average programmer right now has his head buried in the sand and should at least take time to explore what value LLMs can provide, while at the same time taking a more conservative approach when using them to do actual work.
- jaredsohn 1y ago>maybe in the future vibe coding will actually work Vibe coding works today at small enough of scale. I'm building a personal app to help me track nutrition and I only needed to get involved in the code when Claude would hit its limits for a single file and produced a broken program (and this was via the UI, not Claude Code.) Now at ~3000 lines of python. After I told it to split it into a few files I don't think I've had to talk about anything at the code level. Note that I eventually did switch to using Claude Code which might have helped (gets annoying copy/pasting multiple files and then my prompts hit max limits). I just prompt it like an experienced QA/product person to tell it how to build it, point out bugs (as experienced as a user), point out bad data, etc. A few of my recent prompts (each is a separate prompt): >for foods found but not in database, list the number of times each shows up >sort the list by count descending >Period surplus/deficit seems too low. looking at 2025/07/24 to 2025/07/31 >do not require beige color (but still track it). combine blue/purple as one in stats (but keep separate colors). data has both white and White; should use standard case and not show as two colors
- apples_oranges 1y agoIn case some people having realized it by now: it’s not just the code, it’s also/mostly the marketing. Unless you make something useful that’s hard to replicate.. I have recently found something that’s needed but very niche and the sort of problem that Claude can only give tips on how to go about it.
- pixl97 1y agoI guess I'm not sure why people think AI is going to be very useful on niche problem without spending a massive computation budget. Any niche problem requires original work or deep searching for something that can complete it. There is no free lunch.
- throwawaymaths 1y agowhat if you could get something as good as claude on a 8-13b model. if you could quantize you could run it even on a 4090 easily.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoIm a vibe code skeptic because I dont consider it coding. I assume it can write some decent code, but that's not coding.
- exe34 1y agoCoding can only be done by replicators born out of carbon, I imagine?
- shortrounddev2 1y agoNo, coding can be done by machines. But if you're telling a machine what to program, you're not coding. The machine is. Youre no longer a programmer, you're just a user.
- awesome_dude 1y agoUmmm, my entire career I have been telling machines what to program, the machines are taking my garbage C/Go/Python/Perl/whatever prompts and translating it to ASM/Machine code that oher machines will use to do... stuff
- shortrounddev2 1y agoThey're substantively different. Using a compiler requires you to have an internalized model of a state machine and, importantly, a formal language. C, assembler, java, etc. are all essentially different from using the softness of the English language to coerce results out of a black box
- awesome_dude 1y agoNo, not at all. In both all you need is the ability to communicate to the machine in a way that the machine can convert your ideas into actions. The restricted language of a compiler is a handicap, not evidence of a skill - we've been saying forever that "Natural Language" compilers would be a game changer, and that's all that an AI really is Edit: It appears that this discussion is going to end up with a definition of "coding" Is it coding if you tell the computer to perform some action, or is it coding if you tell it how to do that in some highly optimised way (for varying definitions of optimised, eg. Memory efficient, CPU efficient, Dev time efficient... etc)
- yumraj 1y ago> Yeah we all know Claude Code isn’t going to generate a $10 billion SaaS with a team of 10 people… Not trying to argue, since I don’t have counter evidence, but how can you be so sure?
- stickfigure 1y agoI think it's some variation of the efficient markets hypothesis. There are no problems that are both that lucrative and that easy to solve; if they existed, they would get dogpiled and stop being lucrative. Even in this day and age, $10B of revenue is an incredibly high bar. On the other hand, $10B as valuation (not revenue) just requires a greater fool. Maybe it's possible, but I doubt there are too many of those fools available.
- yumraj 1y agoYeah, $10B revenue is insane. I interpreted the parent as saying $10B valuation.
- akra 1y agoThe question is not whether you can or can't, but whether it is still worth it long term: - There is a moat of doing so (i.e. will people actually pay for your SaaS knowing that they could do it too via AI) and.. - How many large scale ideas do you need post AI? Many SaaS products are subscription based and loaded with features you don't need. Most people would prefer a simple product that just does what they need without the ongoing costs. There will be more software. The question is who accrues the economic value of this additional software - the SWE/tech industry (incumbent), the AI industry (disruptor?) and/or the consumer. For the SWE's/tech workers it probably isn't what they envisioned when they started/studied for this industry.
- satyrun 1y agoIt seems obvious to me it is the consumer who will benefit most. I had been thinking of buying an $80 license for a piece of software but ended up knocking off a version in Claude Code over a weekend. It is not even close to something commercial grade that I could sell as a competitor but it is good enough for me to not spend $80 on the license. The huge upside is that I can customize the software in any way I like. I don't care that it isn't maintainable either. Making a new version in ChagGPT5 is going to be my first project. Just like a few hours ago I was thinking how I would like to customize the fitness/calorie tracking app I use. There are so many features I like that would be tightly coupled to my own situation and not a mass market product. This to me seems obvious of what the future of software looks like for everything but mission critical software.
- troupo 1y ago> The interesting thing about all of this vibe coding skepticism, cynicism, and backlash is that many people have their expectations set extremely low. Or they have actually used all these tools, know how they work, and don't buy into hype and marketing.
- exfalso 1y agoHmm not my experience. I've been aggressively trying to use both Cursor and Claude Code. I've done maybe 20-30 attempts with Code at different projects, a couple of them personal small projects. All of them resulted in sub-par results, essentially unusable. I tried to use it for Python, Rust and Bash. I also tried to use it for crawling and organizing information. I also tried to use it as a debugging buddy. All of the attempts failed. I simply don't understand how people are using it in a way that improves productivity. For me, all of this is so far a huge timesink with essentially nothing to show for it. The single positive result was when I asked it to optimize a specific SQL query, and it managed to do it. Anyway I will keep trying to use it, maybe something needs to click first and it just hasn't yet.
- bamboozled 1y agoInitially I loved it, overtime I agree with people that call it a slot machine, unless you’re very deliberate with it, it’d just that. Gambling.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoThis isn’t a fair representation at all. I’ve been delighting all of my tedious tasks with as much context as I would give a person, and my personal win rate at this is substantially higher than I expected. If you give it trash and expect gold, sure, gambling.
- bamboozled 1y agoWhich is what I meant by, "you need to be very deliberate with it", you have to spend a lot of time on the inputs to get good outputs. Which makes it feel a fair bit less like "Intelligence" and a lot more like a calculator.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoContext is everything. Whether they were talking to your junior employee, or to an LLM, if you don’t say what it is, you want don’t be surprised when it’s left to interpretation and comes out wrong. Specifically, Claude coat is really good at making markdown files of plans and if you review them add in context, you can let it run a little more free than you would otherwise. If you don’t feel like giving it, the right amount of context, make the job smaller, where there’s just less of it to begin with. I wouldn’t tell my interns to change the formatting of these printf statements, because I don’t feel like it, but Claude does that stuff pretty great and doesn’t complain as much.