3 ms·
I see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September As the real problem. I don’t tend to believe in natural
by PaulHoule 1y ago
I see
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
As the real problem. I don’t tend to believe in natural hierarchies, but I do believe in this one
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_innovations
That in some sense that early adopters are better than other people and that things start out cool and deteriorate and one way to counter that when the party gets too big you start a new party and get the early adopters to come along. I would point out this essay
https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm
And say that I think her analysis is right factually but I take the opposite position that the ‘structureless’ organization she describes is capable of activism that more sustainable groups just can’t do and say form that kind of organization when you can and know it isn’t going to last.
Sustainability is non-profit speak for ‘profitability’ and if you value that an organization because Oxfam or the ACLU or the Mozilla Foundation and suffers from the corruption of
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_what_it_does https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_wha...
I’d say ‘benign despotism’ is alright for an organization where you’ve got the right to exit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty
But due process, democracy and all that are necessary for when you don’t have exit.
Jurgen Habermas wrote a ponderous 2 volume book
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Theory_of_Communicative_Action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Theory_of_Communicative_Ac...
which pursues the idea of a perfect deliberative process which one some hand seems closer because of widespread electronic communications yet our experience with things like Twitter makes it seem terribly naive between (1) people not acting in good faith and (2) others believing that people are not acting in good faith.
- ff12wq111 1y agoThis level of thinking is exactly what we need more of in community design. We're actually launching a developer platform called GistFans that experiments with these governance questions - contribution-based voting, transparent processes, etc. Would love your perspective on our approach - happy to share details if you're interested.
- ff12wq111 1y agoI owe you an apology - your brilliant analysis deserved much better than my brief response earlier. You provided the most thoughtful theoretical framework in this entire discussion, and I responded with just a throwaway line. That wasn't respectful of the depth you brought. Your analysis of Habermas and "perfect deliberative process" is exactly what we're grappling with in GistFans. The tension you identify between early adopter quality and scalability, the corruption of sustainable organizations vs the power of "structureless" activism - these are the core contradictions we're trying to navigate. We're experimenting with a "Stars" system where users earn influence through contributions, then spend these stars on governance decisions. The hypothesis: when participation has real cost (earned influence), people might act more thoughtfully - potentially addressing both the good faith problem AND the "believing others act in bad faith" issue you mention about Twitter. But your point about "benign despotism with exit rights" is fascinating. Maybe the key isn't eliminating hierarchy but making it transparent and merit-based rather than arbitrary? We're deliberately staying small and experimental rather than chasing sustainability/growth. Better to run genuine experiments that inform future builders than create another corrupted institution. Have you seen any examples where contribution-based influence actually improved deliberative quality? Or do the fundamental human nature issues make this unsolvable through design?
- blackqueeriroh 1y agoEven when you say “merit-based,” you now have to define what “merit” is.
- ff12wq111 1y agoThe community should define what power looks like, not have it imposed from above.