3 ms·
Yeah the severance is nice but the execution is lame. If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't have a job anymore, you
by SoftTalker 1y ago
Yeah the severance is nice but the execution is lame. If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't have a job anymore, you shouldn't be a manager or executive. Maybe it's a very distributed team, I guess then there's isn't a great way to do that.
- geodel 1y ago> If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't... This is just bullshit. Managers don't have to do any such thing as it may become unnecessarily confrontational. Similarly lot of people resign via email. There is no need to have "guts" to tell manager in their face.
- chrisco255 1y agoI mean, if you want to burn a bridge you can do so. Sometimes it's warranted. However, if you have a good relationship with your manager then it's absolutely ideal to tell it to their face (or with a 1 on 1 call). It's not about guts it's about mutual respect. Likewise for layoffs.
- geodel 1y agoRight. If situation allows doing face to face is nice. But thing as they are lately doing via canned message or email is perfectly fine and one need not think any less of manager or employee just based on their communication method.
- ilc 1y agoYou can do both. You should ALWAYS write a formal resignation letter that's about 3 lines at most, before talking to the manager. It just stops a ton of confusion, hope, etc. It allows that discussion to focus on "Do you want the two weeks?" and "What do you want me to do with those two weeks if you want them." Part of being a good employee is making things clear to your manager.
- mingus88 1y ago150 people is huge. The logistics of doing this in person just don’t make sense. Are you going to send out hundreds of calendar invites spread across weeks for the sole purpose of being nice to people? Are affected employees expected to queue up to get their personal “you’re fired” before their access is cut?
- rdoherty 1y agoI worked at Yahoo in 2008 when they laid off thousands and yes every single person got a calendar invite and met in a meeting room 1:1 with a manager. It was difficult but they did it. Times definitely have changed.
- xp84 1y agoWow, just the logistics of that is impressive. I feel like I would watch a 60-minute documentary on pulling that together because it no doubt took dozens or hundreds of people weeks of logistics to do that, and unlike almost any other major project, literally no one involved was happy about any part of it.
- resize2996 1y agoDoing unhappy work at Yahoo probably wasn't unusual in 2008
- xmprt 1y agoDid the people who got a calendar invite know that they were getting laid off in advance?
- Macha 1y agoI worked at Yahoo some years later and the process was the same when I was there. Yes, people generally put two and two together when there was a calendar invite with their manager and HR. We were in a European office though, so layoffs aren't American-style "escorted from the office with immediate effect".
- dennis_jeeves2 1y ago> If you don't have the balls to tell an employee to his or her face that they don't have a job anymore, you shouldn't be a manager or executive. What if your balls get ripped off? Just saying...
- neilv 1y ago> Maybe it's a very distributed team, I guess then there's isn't a great way to do that. If you want to do it all at once, for all time zones... If there's overlapping "core hours" for different time zones, or you can schedule an all-hands videoconf time, you can do it then. Or do one for the global West, and one for the global East (which will have different cultural nuances anyway, and possibly separate management structures). It's not that different than in-office. Except, for in-office, remaining colleagues see a person boxing up their stuff and walking out with their stuff in a box, or (worse) security escorting the people off the property. And then there's usually the desk of a terminate colleague there as a visual reminder for awhile. One in-office layoff I saw, they arranged for all the people to be laid off to have impromptu meetings with their managers, and to go to conference rooms, at the same time... and then notified everyone still at their desks to go to an all-(remaining)-hands meeting, in a different office space, where they were told of the layoffs. Most of the axed people were already gone when the others returned. It might have been good intentions, but I'm not sure that was a good move. It's a tricky problem, whether in-office or remote. Partly because the situation isn't right. ICs are more often let go because management failed, rather than any fault of the ICs.
- SoftTalker 1y agoI was part of one mass layoff. They had two meetings at our site, one for the people being retained and one for the people being let go. We had an idea what was happening but you didn't know until your meeting started which group you were in. It was done in person though not via a video message.
- xp84 1y ago> the situation isn't right. ICs are more often let go because management failed, rather than any fault of the ICs. That is pretty much guaranteed to happen though, unless you have a system where the assumption is employment for life at all costs. Management's job is to make decisions, many decisions won't work out, and for some of those, the consequences mean some change in what roles are going to be needed. Sometimes it's a management success that means a certain role isn't needed too ("we successfully rolled out software to book business trips, so we don't need 17 travel bookers anymore"). And anyway, let's stipulate that managers should also be punished by being sacked for any big mistake: That wouldn't save ICs, since if you're, say, pivoting away from making furniture, you still don't need the furniture makers, even if you sack the "VP of Furniture" or the CEO. And it'd be stupid to appoint a new VP of Furniture over and over to keep trying to 'make furniture happen' just to save the jobs.
- jfengel 1y agoDoing that for 150 people is a pretty long, ugly day, while everybody waited for their turn. You could gather everybody in the same room, and announce it there, but that's still not really face-to-face. Delegating it to their direct managers is even worse. They're generally not the ones who made the decision. Even if they were the ones who submitted a list of their people they could live without, it was the higher-ups who approved the layoff en masse. There's just not a great way to give bad news. A video sucks, but it attracts attention only because it's different from the other sucky ways people do it.
- themadturk 1y agoI worked for Weyerhaeuser, a major US forest products firm in the Seattle area during the early 2000s. In 2009 they decided to get out of the forestry products business and become nothing more than a land owner. Multiple thousands of workers were let go. At least at the company headquarters, managers met with every worker to tell them whether they'd been laid off or not. The announcement came in the summer, a couple of months before the actual lay-off date, and salary and benefits were extended until year end. It was by far the most humane layoff I'd ever experienced.