4 ms·

Ah yes, "exacting young man debunks charming tale with touching moral, to the benefit of nobody". A tale as old as time.

• dxdm 1y ago
  It is good to be able to recognize charming tales and other biases and influences in a narrative. Having them pointed out counteracts the readiness of people to take things at face value. Knowing that something is a tale does not have to take away from it. I don't know what irked you about the other comment, but I think there's a positive side to it.
  • coldtea 1y ago
    >Knowing that something is a tale does not have to take away from it. Oh, but it does. Here's "a thing that happened" vs "here's a tall tale" means whatever message is approached very differently.
    • vntok 1y ago
      "You know the great story you've been telling others for years as truth? It was in fact a lie" is much much worse. Better to know up front that a tale is only a parable.
    • dxdm 1y ago
      > Here's "a thing that happened" vs "here's a tall tale" means whatever message is approached very differently. I agree. I meant to point out that tales can be entertaining and/or instructional, too, even while we're aware of what they are. ("Knowing that a story is fictional does not take away from it", maybe I should've written that.) My point still stands, though: knowing a tale from a "thing that happened" is important, and what you said underscores why.
• pxc 1y ago
  I think it still works fine as a parable, and it doesn't hurt to know a little bit more about how the trees are Oxford are really kept.