4 ms·

Honestly feels very vibe-coded [1] [2] and would not really trust my money with something like this. I had to read the code to understand what it actually prot

Honestly feels very vibe-coded [1] [2] and would not really trust my money with something like this. I had to read the code to understand what it actually protects me from, as the README.md (other than telling me it's production-ready, professional, and protects me from so much!) tells me "Supports all major providers: OpenAI, Anthropic, auto-detected from URLs". OpenAI and Anthropic are "all" major providers [3]? [1] https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/blob/51395c36809aabc62d612b63250253d19e7f10f3/FINAL_AUDIT.md https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/blob/51395c36809aa... [2] https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f345ddba538deebcda9e23a2cdaeaa8 https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f3... [3] https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/blob/083ae9896459b7bc709bcb5767e5d7b4b9791e12/agent-guard.js#L710 https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/blob/083ae9896459b...

StevenWaterman 1y ago
The AI's idea of developing a startup is eerily reminiscent of a hacking scene in CSI
eqvinox 1y ago
It's incredible how emoji overuse has become a giant red flag for AI over-/abuse.
- jeffhuys 1y ago
  Well, that, and stuff like the commit descriptions. > Polish README: Remove downloads badge and clean up styling > - Removed downloads badge ___as requested___
diggan 1y ago
> [1] https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f345ddba538deebcda9e23a2cdaeaa8 https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f3... It's kind of crazy that people use these multi-billion parameter machine learning models to do search/replace of words in text files, rather than the search/replace in their code editor. I wonder what the efficiency difference is, must be 1000x or even 10000x difference? Don't get me wrong, I use LLMs too, but mostly for things I wouldn't be able to do myself (like isolated math-heavy functions I can't bother to understand the internals of), not for trivial things like changing "test" to "step" across five files. I love that the commit ends with > Codebase is now enterprise-ready with professional language throughout Like "enterprise-ready" is about error messages and using "Examples" instead of "Demo".
- johnisgood 1y ago
  I use LLMs, too, and that did give me a chuckle.
- throwawayoldie 1y ago
  This is the future of the field: amateur night that never ends. And this is why I'm looking for a new career at my advanced age.
  - jeffhuys 1y ago
    If you have any tips, feel free to enlighten me. Even though I'm "only" in my 30s I feel the future is uncertain - the original author of this post made one other post that was also clearly vibe-coded, but not many comments seem to point it out. It'll only get worse from here, depending how you look at it of course; hackers will have a WAY easier time as time goes on.
    - throwawayoldie 1y ago
      Still figuring it out, but if I do, I promise I'll circle back here and let you know. So far the best idea I have is to stay in software and ideally my current job for the moment, but phone it in, while I retrain as something else at night.
delusional 1y ago
> Close first customers at $99/month > The foundation is bulletproof. Time to execute the 24-hour revenue sprint. Comedy gold. This is one of those times where i cant figure out if the author is in on the joke, or if they're actually so deluded that they think this doesn't make them look idiotic. If it's the latter, we need to bring bullying back. Either way it's hilarious.
- jeffhuys 1y ago
  Well the author has many, many repositories like this. It seems like he's still stuck in the "If I just say to my AI that I want a production-ready package that people will pay me $99/month for, I'll get it eventually, right?" phase of discovering LLMs. The end-result is many commits saying "fixed all issues, enterprise-ready now as requested!" adding 500 lines of code causing more issues. The funniest part, to me, is that this only damages his image, instead of solidifying it. We've had so many applicants at my company recently where we go to their github, and they have 10 repositories all obviously vibe-coded together, acting like they made some amazing stuff. Instant deletion of application, no coming back from that - this person would NOT get a job here.

StevenWaterman 1y ago

The AI's idea of developing a startup is eerily reminiscent of a hacking scene in CSI

eqvinox 1y ago

It's incredible how emoji overuse has become a giant red flag for AI over-/abuse.

jeffhuys 1y ago
Well, that, and stuff like the commit descriptions. > Polish README: Remove downloads badge and clean up styling > - Removed downloads badge ___as requested___

diggan 1y ago

> [1] https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f345ddba538deebcda9e23a2cdaeaa8 https://github.com/dipampaul17/AgentGuard/commit/d49b361d7f3... It's kind of crazy that people use these multi-billion parameter machine learning models to do search/replace of words in text files, rather than the search/replace in their code editor. I wonder what the efficiency difference is, must be 1000x or even 10000x difference? Don't get me wrong, I use LLMs too, but mostly for things I wouldn't be able to do myself (like isolated math-heavy functions I can't bother to understand the internals of), not for trivial things like changing "test" to "step" across five files. I love that the commit ends with > Codebase is now enterprise-ready with professional language throughout Like "enterprise-ready" is about error messages and using "Examples" instead of "Demo".

johnisgood 1y ago
I use LLMs, too, and that did give me a chuckle.
throwawayoldie 1y ago
This is the future of the field: amateur night that never ends. And this is why I'm looking for a new career at my advanced age.
- jeffhuys 1y ago
  If you have any tips, feel free to enlighten me. Even though I'm "only" in my 30s I feel the future is uncertain - the original author of this post made one other post that was also clearly vibe-coded, but not many comments seem to point it out. It'll only get worse from here, depending how you look at it of course; hackers will have a WAY easier time as time goes on.
  - throwawayoldie 1y ago
    Still figuring it out, but if I do, I promise I'll circle back here and let you know. So far the best idea I have is to stay in software and ideally my current job for the moment, but phone it in, while I retrain as something else at night.

delusional 1y ago

> Close first customers at $99/month > The foundation is bulletproof. Time to execute the 24-hour revenue sprint. Comedy gold. This is one of those times where i cant figure out if the author is in on the joke, or if they're actually so deluded that they think this doesn't make them look idiotic. If it's the latter, we need to bring bullying back. Either way it's hilarious.

jeffhuys 1y ago
Well the author has many, many repositories like this. It seems like he's still stuck in the "If I just say to my AI that I want a production-ready package that people will pay me $99/month for, I'll get it eventually, right?" phase of discovering LLMs. The end-result is many commits saying "fixed all issues, enterprise-ready now as requested!" adding 500 lines of code causing more issues. The funniest part, to me, is that this only damages his image, instead of solidifying it. We've had so many applicants at my company recently where we go to their github, and they have 10 repositories all obviously vibe-coded together, acting like they made some amazing stuff. Instant deletion of application, no coming back from that - this person would NOT get a job here.