2 ms·
> concept of nations is perhaps two centuries old at best Concept of nation states. Nations and states, separately, are an older concept. > they were often si
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> concept of nations is perhaps two centuries old at best
Concept of nation states. Nations and states, separately, are an older concept.
> they were often simply under the dominion of one imperial power or another
For millennia. Often because inter-ethnic conflicts required an external security guarantor to keep a lid on the chaos.
One could argue this history of chaos goes back to the Hittites and Bronze Age collapse.
- Apocryphon 1y agoDuring the times there was an external security guarantor, conflict would by definition go down (assuming the external power was sufficiently potent and stable). So you can't say that both chaos and dominion were happening simultaneously at all times. > One could argue this history of chaos goes back to the Hittites and Bronze Age collapse. And one could claim that the history of chaos in Central Europe goes back to the dissolution of the Carolingian Empire, or the Ostsiedlung, or perhaps even before the Romans made contact with the Germani.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> you can't say that both chaos and dominion were happening simultaneously at all times Nobody said this. > one could claim that the history of chaos in Central Europe goes back to the dissolution of the Carolingian Empire, or the Ostsiedlung, or perhaps even before the Romans made contact with the Germani Well, yes. It’s a nexus of navigable waterways. It has taken millennia of negotiating, atrocity and—ultimately—an external security guarantor twinned with mutual forgiveness to attain, for a short period, peace.