3 ms·
> I can see that comprehension is not your strong suit. Here is what you said: "Because the defense must first provide some evidence that a mistake was, or cou
by lutusp 14y ago
> I can see that comprehension is not your strong suit.
Here is what you said: "Because the defense must first provide some evidence that a mistake was, or could have been made"
It's false, I corrected you. A statistical probability of a false positive is not evidence that a mistake was, or could have been, made. It is a statistical prediction for a particular outcome, and it's not a mistake -- the practitioner is assumed to be performing the procedures as specified, and is blameless.
If I say that, given the usual distribution of population IQs (mean 100, SD 15), that 4.78% of the population will have an IQ at or above 125, is that a mistake? Will someone be brought up on charges of negligence?
- rprasad 14y agoLogically, you are correct, and if that's what you originally meant than I misunderstood you. Legally, that's not how the law works. And in all fairness, when dealing with the law, what is "legal" trumps what is "logical."
- lutusp 14y ago> Legally, that's not how the law works. Actually, it is. Contrary to your claim, a statistical outlier, a false positive, is not called a "mistake" and no one is brought up on charges. The legal term is typically "Act of God" or another similar term. > And in all fairness, when dealing with the law, what is "legal" trumps what is "logical." Sometimes. Not this time.