4 ms·
Saw a bee lecture recently [1]. Honeybees aren’t native to North America [2]. The native pollinators, such as bumblebees, are outcompeted by honeybee hives [3]
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Saw a bee lecture recently [1].
Honeybees aren’t native to North America [2]. The native pollinators, such as bumblebees, are outcompeted by honeybee hives [3]. Those honeybees then selectively pollinate certain plants, reducing biodiversity further [4].
Honeybees, however, unlike local pollinators, can be industrially distributed to industrial agriculture. So they get a lobby. Meanwhile, well-meaning folks put a honey beehive in their backyard and inadvertently wipe out the local bumblebee and butterfly populations.
[1] https://uwnps.org/event/6-26-25/ https://uwnps.org/event/6-26-25/
[2] https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/are-honey-bees-native-north-america https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/are-honey-bees-native-north-americ...
[3] https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/em-9524-impact-beekeeping-native-bees-urban-settings https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/em-9524-impact-bee...
[4] https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ecs2.4085 https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002...
- mattgrice 1y agoIt's true but honey bees are still extremely economically important. And very useful because their hives are large and portable. The billionaire Resinick pomegranate/pistachoi/almond oligarchs put quite a bit of effort into native bees which seemed quite successful but they shut it down I think about 5 years ago. I can't find the article now. Gen X+ might remember them as owners of the 'Franklin Mint' hawkers of knickknacks you either are or soon will be throwing into a dumpster. They are BTW also largest renters of honeybee hives in the US.
- tptacek 1y agoRight, it's interesting from a technical perspective, but it's a story about battery-farmed livestock, not about North American ecology. My guess is they'll figure out how to keep growing more bees. The prices of honey bee queens have been pretty stable for the past 15 years.
- mattgrice 1y agoI think it is not a great analogy. As Jeremy Bentham wrote, “The question is not: can they reason? Nor, can they talk? But can they suffer?” I have relatives that do or have raised bees (as a hobby). Can bees suffer? I don't know. I kind of think a bee can experience suffering in a small degree. I'm not going to run the experiments on that because I'm not a sociopath. Also arguably the hive is the basic unit of the honeybee organism, not the bee itself. I do know for certain hogs can suffer. I'm a farm boy from Iowa. I've been around them from a young age and I hate everything about them. I hate the smell, I hate the way their meat tastes to me like they smell, I hate how if you are small enough and don't take care, they are mean enough to knock you down and eat you. I'm probably one of the few people on HN who have actually experienced in person what a hog confinement facility looks and smells and sounds like. I wouldn't wish it on my worst hog enemy. It is a vision of hell, illegal to film in Iowa, and in no way comparable to how we treat bee hives.
- tptacek 1y agoI am for complicated reasons unusually familiar with battery hog farms. I'm not making an ethical comparison; I'm just saying: ecologically speaking, American honey bees are an industrial product, not part of our fauna.
- jibal 1y agoYeah, that was an odd turn.
- vixen99 1y agoMeanwhile: https://www.sciencealert.com/fish-suffer-up-to-22-minutes-of-intense-pain-when-taken-out-of-water https://www.sciencealert.com/fish-suffer-up-to-22-minutes-of...
- mrweasel 1y ago> And very useful because their hives are large and portable. I have no proof of this, this is just my theory, but the "portable" might be the issue. I think industrial beekeepers in the US might be part of the problem. Yes you can technically move the bees, but should you? You're moving around disease, you might be overworking and stressing the bees. Meanwhile you have farmers create massive fields with nothing but corn, grass, wheat, whatever, leaving you with essentially green deserts from the pollinators perspectives. Again just a theory of mine, but the reliance of "portable" bees is what's causing the problem. Other countries have beehives for rent, but they aren't moved constantly. Often they stay in the same location all year and the bees are allowed to follow their natural cycles. Trucking around hundreds of hives always seems rather stupid.
- hinkley 1y agoIf you pay close attention in Seattle, you'll find that bumblebees are particularly fond of making nests in the hollows of the loose boulder retaining walls that are still in fashion in the region. It's hard to catch them because they have much smaller numbers per nest and thus less traffic per minute, but they do.
- WalterBright 1y agoI let the wildflowers grow in my lawn, and in the summer there's a constant hum from the bees. I enjoy the sound and their industriousness. My only problem is the invasive plants which are determined to overwhelm everything.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoOut of left field, but do you have any sources on developing small riparian environments to promote dragonfly populations? I recently learned that a popular anti-mosquito trick by painters in my area is to put a fake dragonfly on their cap. Which led me to wonder where the actual buggers have gone.
- hinkley 1y agoThey're all in my yard, and I honestly don't know why. I'm almost half a mile from the nearest wetland. I think it's tall weeds. They seem to be like cats and want to perch on high spots.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> They seem to be like cats and want to perch on high spots I love this.
- mc32 1y agoUnfortunately, so do ticks... (grass blades)
- 0898 1y agoSo what you're saying is that honeybees just have good bee-R?
- taeric 1y agoI mean, somewhat true, but probably a touch oversold? I don't think people putting in a single beehive are doing much to impact a neighborhood. Probably less than having a house cat. Which, is not nothing, but is not ecosystem changing, either. I'm reminded of how much we were taught that monocrops were bad things in grade school. And yet, you'd be hard pressed to name a popular food that isn't grown in giant monocrop fields.
- micromacrofoot 1y agoThe damage is largely already done because the non-native bees are now a feral invasive species that have out competed natives, and the invasive honey bees haven't co-evolved to pollinate native plantlife
- tptacek 1y agoMy understanding is that there are in fact very few feral honey bee colonies in the US ("if you see a honey bee in your yard, chances are someone owns it") and at some points over the last 20 years feral honey bee colonies had essentially been eradicated by the Varroa mite.
- micromacrofoot 1y agoI get swarms trying to establish new colonies every summer, and I'm in a major city where most people don't have any yard space.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> probably a touch oversold? I don't think people putting in a single beehive are doing much to impact a neighborhood Probably not, especially if they’re in an urban environment. The bees being shipped to farms, on the other hand, are ecologically destructive (as well as economically invaluable). My takeaway is not that honeybees are evil. It’s that we need more pollinators in more stripes, and that the agricultural industry has successfully confused pollinators in general with honeybees in particular.
- 1y ago
- kulahan 1y agoMason Bees are hilarious bees native to North America that don't fly very well, so they just kinda dive-bomb flowers to get pollen. This is important because that heavy slam (well, heavy for a flower) is enough to distribute pollen into the air. These bees are fat, fuzzy, and winter over by crawling into holes and sealing themselves inside with some mud-spit. It's VERY easy to create homes for these guys - if you've ever seen someone with a large log that has lots of little holes drilled in it, they were likely prepping a Mason Bee habitat. Ideally, they burrow into hollow, dry grass stems that broke off at some point in the fall. I try to tell people about this bee because it's so easy to make homes for them. Just make sure to move the home every year, or it becomes too easy for predators to find them. edit: also worth mentioning this bee is so docile, it usually only stings when it's squeezed or wet, and its sting is very light, and the hook is unbarbed. Better than honey bees in so many ways.
- morgoths_bane 1y agoYou have now convinced me to be the biggest supporter of mason bees now, thank you.
- tptacek 1y agoDuring the season we had a bunch of mason bee nests inside the hollow metal of our porch furniture. Supposedly, mason bees can sting, but the sting is barely perceptible.
- mattgrice 1y agoI've got a ton of mason bee tubes. They are awesome. To use a silicon valley analogy, nobody has figured out how to scale out mason bees. Not to the > 200sq miles of pomegranates, pistachios, and almonds owned by the Resnicks. The Resnicks funded some in-house research and apparently considred it a failure. It's probably possible. Might not even be hard once you know the trick, but it's certainly not a slam-dunk.
- pamelafox 1y agoI love native bees, I've been trying to find ways to incorporate native bee facts into my tech talks. The "Insect Crisis" book was a nice overview of issues like overuse of honeybees, plus others. Highly recommend planting native pollinator-friendly plants in garden if you want to meet adorable, hilarious, beautiful native bees! My current fav is the Fine Striped Sweat Bee, where the females are 100% turquoise. Dazzling! https://bsky.app/profile/pamelafox.bsky.social/post/3lv3eycluoq27 https://bsky.app/profile/pamelafox.bsky.social/post/3lv3eycl...
- ethbr1 1y agoTo me, one of the most fascinating facts about pollinators in general is their interconnectedness, which spirals off into a myriad of everyday touch points for most people. One fact a friend shared recently was that magnolia trees pre-date many modern pollinators. >> At the time of their evolution, many common pollinators we think of today, such as bees, butterflies, and moths had not evolved yet. As a result, magnolias developed flowers for pollination by beetles and flies, which were the primary insect pollinators 100 million years ago. https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2018-05-05-magnolia-pollination https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2018-05-05...
- micromacrofoot 1y agoYes thank you, we're supporting the wrong bees!
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> we're supporting the wrong bees Our farms don’t work with bumblebees. Honeybees are fine. The problem is thinking we only need honeybees. We need more bees of all kinds. And in some cases, yes, that may mean fewer honeybees.
- micromacrofoot 1y agothe non-native honeybees used in commercial farming are responsible for the diminishing numbers of native honeybees that co-evolved to pollinate native plant life https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-81967-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-81967-1 we've been screwing up the global ecosystem for hundreds of years at this point with farming techniques spread by european colonization
- giantg2 1y ago"The native pollinators, such as bumblebees, are outcompeted by honeybee hives" ... in urban environments, and it' still debatable. Your #2 source provides additional details. There are a lot of other dubious claims here that the sources seemed to contradict each other. Something you didn't bring up is that people raising honeybee can benefit other pollinators due to changes in human behavior such as planting beneficial plants and refraining from pesticide use.
- tptacek 1y agoPeople can plant beneficial plants without introducing invasive competitors.
- giantg2 1y agoThey can, but they don't. You missed the point. Awareness through exposure to beekeeping can change human behavior in a beneficial way. If you read some of the previously linked articles, you will see that it is still debateable if the competitors are actually causing any real problems for native bees. If the problems are debatable and on a low scale, then it's possible the benefits are a net positive.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> can, but they don't Do we have evidence backyard beekeeping promotes these behaviours better than directly messaging folks to plant pollinator-friendly gardens? (Genuine question.)
- giantg2 1y agoI don't know of any studies looking at this specifically, but there are numerous groups and programs that use honeybees as an outreach tool for environmental education. There are studies about the effectiveness of experiential learning vs classroom only learning. One indicator that this is working is the fact that most people in general think about honeybees when you say the bees or pollinators are dying. The steps of reducing pesticide use and planting pollinator friendly yards is universally beneficial. https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/careersandeducation/how-bee-u-nyc-brings-environmental-stewardship-and-pollinator-education-to-urban-communities/ar-AA1IHA5g https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/careersandeducation/how-bee-... https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8569223/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8569223/
- mortsnort 1y agoConvincing hipsters to switch their urban hives to more obscure bees actually seems achievable.
- wappieslurkz 1y agoIf you were ever wondering why (us) vegans don't eat honey: this is one of many reasons.