11 ms·
Pesticides have no effect whatsoever on bacteria. And dung from plant fed animals is harmless. And all bacteria is not equal, so it's doesn't matter how much t
by ars 14y ago
Pesticides have no effect whatsoever on bacteria. And dung from plant fed animals is harmless.
And all bacteria is not equal, so it's doesn't matter how much there is - it matters what kind. Cheese is just full of bacteria, so are pickles, and yogurt. Food grown using antibiotics will have more of the dangerous resistant kind, rather than the beneficial kind.
With the sprouts it was not the organic that was the issue - it's simply that it's sprouts. Sprouts are wet, not cooked, and not washed. It's a perfect environment for bacteria if you are not careful.
I don't think non-organic sprouts even exists - they grow in less than a week, why would you put pesticides on it?
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"And dung from plant fed animals is harmless." Nonsense. Animal dung can carry everything from tapeworms to salmonella to E. coli. Update: added link. http://umaine.edu/publications/2510e/ http://umaine.edu/publications/2510e/
- encoderer 14y agoWhat I think the guy is getting at is a holistic view here. That the manure from animals raised in healthy conditions-- meaning low density, no antibiotics, natural diet--is a safe and ecologically sound fertilizer. It is, after-all, how farming developed over thousands of years. Sorry if that sounds too Michael Pollan for you but I think it passes as both common sense and historically accurate.
- kalleboo 14y ago> It is, after-all, how farming developed over thousands of years You may be right about it being safe, but I'd be careful about using this logic. Over "thousands of years", we had a life expectancy at birth of 30 years, indicating that among other things the food supply may not have been very safe.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoRight. Not to mention the ever-present fear of famine. Going back to low-tech, low-energy, localized production is a recipe for the return of large-scale famine.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoWhich is also nonsense. Animals raised without antibiotics and vaccinations carry a horde of diseases.
- Turing_Machine 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoonosis#Partial_list_of_zoonoses http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoonosis#Partial_list_of_zoonos... Click through a few of these and note how many of them are spread by animals in living in a low density, no antibiotics, natural diet environment.
- encoderer 14y agoSuch as? I'm far from an expert but this has been an interest of mine for years -- deeper than just watching Food, Inc. You're right that livestock in feedlots carry awful diseases. But in proper conditions--you could even say humane conditions--they don't inherently carry any more diseases than you or I. I mean, what are you arguing for exactly? That we shouldn't use natural sources of NPK? Try your hand at explaining that.
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"they don't inherently carry any more diseases than you or I." I don't eat crops fertilized with human feces, either. "That we shouldn't use natural sources of NPK? Try your hand at explaining that." I don't like famines that kill millions of people.
- Turing_Machine 14y agoI also don't think I'd care to live in a world where 90+% of us were illiterate peasants bound to the soil (serfs if we were lucky, slaves if not), spending our entire lives on hand-cultivation of crops. That was the norm essentially everywhere on the planet right up until the development of modern, mechanized agriculture.
- encoderer 14y agoDo you think there's no natural manure fertilizer on your crops? You've got an interesting argument here. You're against organic food because it's more likely to spread bacteria and parasites? But you've not really offered any facts, just blanket statements. I'm going to bow-out of this now -- apologize if I'm reading this wrong but this all seems too trollish for my tastes.
- ars 14y agoAnimal dung when fresh can carry all that, sure. But you are supposed to compost it first, and mix it into soil. Both of which will kill the harmful organisms.