3 ms·
I asked this same question last week and got some good answers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44630224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44630224 Thr
by __MatrixMan__ 1y ago
I asked this same question last week and got some good answers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44630224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44630224
Three things that stood out to me:
- Terrestrial plants evolved from green algae. There are other colors of photosynthetic algae. The advantage of absorbing red and blue may have been about avoiding competition with nearby red algae (which absorbs green), and about how blue light penetrates more deeply.
- The trick is not capturing as much energy as possible, but rather capturing and routing energy to the reaction centers such that it neither overshoots nor undershoots the energy necessary for the reaction. This works better with two absorption peaks instead of one (more here: https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-are-plants-green-to-reduce-the-noise-in-photosynthesis-20200730/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-are-plants-green-to-reduc...). The absorption peaks of chlorophyll are both adequately distant from one another, and also more or less centered on the visible (i.e. most energetic) spectrum emitted by the sun.
- The idea that the green-yellow region of the visible spectrum is most energetic is, if not a misconception, at least more complex that it seems (https://www.oceanopticsbook.info/view/light-and-radiometry/level-2/common-misconception https://www.oceanopticsbook.info/view/light-and-radiometry/l...).
- schobi 1y agoI agree with the overall discussion, but in the last link (Curtis Mobley Ocean Optics Book) the argument is broken. Mobley plotted two graphs of the solar irradiation and a black body fit. The only difference is supposed to be the x axis with a plot over frequency or wavelength. This is a non-linear mapping and a different shape is expected. But the result is that the peak irradiation level is at either 501nm or 882nm (when converted back). That can't be right. The labeling of the x axis does not change the maximum. What he meant to do was to plot either the solar irradiation in W m^-2 nm^-1 or as the number of photons. With lower energy photons (towards the red) the same irradiation level will consist of more photons. This shifts the maximum number of photons towards higher wavelengths. 880nm sounds plausible.
- bradrn 1y agoNo, see previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44632819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44632819