3 ms·
This test is also being heavily misused and misinterpreted in some online communities. There are a lot of people posting CAC scan results after something like a
by Aurornis 1y ago
This test is also being heavily misused and misinterpreted in some online communities. There are a lot of people posting CAC scan results after something like a year of keto dieting in their 20s or 30s and using that to conclude that the saturated fat connection to atherosclerosis is a myth or that high cholesterol is fine.
These tests don’t have perfect accuracy and resolution, so low or zero results don’t mean that a lifetime of high cholesterol won’t catch up with someone in their 60s and 70s, yet a lot of podcasters and social media influencers are making those claims.
- leereeves 1y agoI agree the results after one year of a keto diet don't prove much, but getting that test seems like a good idea. I hope they'll keep testing and reporting the results for years, so we can learn more about the long term effects of a keto diet. And if it does cause problems, they'll want to know ASAP.
- Aurornis 1y agoCAC tests come with a non-trivial radiation exposure if someone is getting them every few years. The other problem is that they’re picking and choosing which tests to believe and which to ignore. They disregard their cholesterol tests because they don’t like the results, but embrace one or two CAC tests because they do like the results (when they’re young). However the CAC results are a lagging indicator of cumulative damage that has been done. Cholesterol tests are correlated with the rate of damage occurring. So embracing CAC and using it to justify ignoring LDL and others is the problem.
- leereeves 1y agoI think the unknown factor here is whether other benefits of keto over a standard American diet--possibly including reduced inflammation, BP, blood glucose, and body weight--balance out the effect of cholesterol. CAC measures actual damage already done, while cholesterol is just one of many factors. The downside, of course, is that once the damage is done, it's done, so it's a risk. (And as you said, they won't see the damage in their 20s.)
- Telemakhos 1y agoIs this a keto diet that's mainly leafy greens with healthy protein like salmon? Or is this the "keto" diet of bacon and steak and as much fast as one can shove in the food-hole?
- jrvarela56 1y agoI don’t understand why some prople claim that diet does not impact cholesterol. I did ‘keto’ with bacon/steak/chicken/etc for 3 months, got bloodwork done before and after and my LDL went through the roof.
- Aurornis 1y agoThere’s an offshoot of the keto community that has become die-hard cholesterol deniers. They don’t necessarily argue that keto doesn’t raise cholesterol. They argue that it doesn’t matter to have high cholesterol. They believe doctors and science are wrong on the subject. They think statins are evil. They embrace a few fringe doctors who agree with them. If you do try keto again, bacon and such are the worst way to do it. Getting your fat content from a monounsaturated source like avocado oil can be helpful. Taking statins is also a good idea.
- Buttons840 1y agoIn contrast, I had a high LDL of 190, largely genetic, and panicked and switched to a vegan diet. I had my LDL tested again 10 days later and it was 120. I couldn't keep up with the strict diet, but learned some good habits and to avoid saturated fat. My doctor hasn't recommended statins... yet.
- moltar 1y agoHave you seen/read cholesterol code? It doesn't deny cholesterol but rather has interesting, and unusual findings. https://cholesterolcode.com/ https://cholesterolcode.com/ There’s a good talk as well that presents this information in a very accessible way: https://youtu.be/jZu52duIqno?si=NCEf4UGtgHG9sBOP https://youtu.be/jZu52duIqno?si=NCEf4UGtgHG9sBOP
- david-gpu 1y ago
- quantumwoke 1y agoThis is correct advice, thank you. I am reminded once again that correlation != causation and that doing tests 'just to be sure' is not a healthy or safe way to live. There is a lot of literature out this on what makes a good screening test.
- AnotherGoodName 1y agoAlso age is huge so people shouldn't be reading much into a reading of 0 unless you're over 65. https://dirjournal.org/articles/coronary-artery-calcium-score-percentiles-data-from-a-single-center-in-turkey/dir.2023.232196 https://dirjournal.org/articles/coronary-artery-calcium-scor... (see table 2) Imagine claiming "my diet is great, i got 0% on my calcium score" when that just means you have the same score as 95%+ of people at age 40. By 55, 25% of people start showing some % of calcium and at 65, 75% of people have a reading on calcium score. So anyone under 45 being proud of a zero score is just silly.