12 ms·

So everything claude-flow¹ already does but worse (I guess?). ¹ https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow

by T0Bi 1y ago

nazgul17 1y ago
Except it's not in alpha phase
dchuk 1y ago
I’ll admit this looks comprehensive, but man oh man does this seem complicated and over doing it
himeexcelanta 1y ago
This looks like a yarn ball (in not a good way)
SOLAR_FIELDS 1y ago
That guy doesn't even understand how his own software works. Is anyone actually using this thing and putting their code into production?
- lubujackson 1y ago
  It's extreme dogfooding where he is making a mashed potato volcano where Claude agents are the potatoes and your sanity is the gravy.
- AbstractH24 1y ago
  Not only are people using them, they are building startups based on them. And then selling said startups.
jampa 1y ago
> IMPORTANT: Claude Code must be installed first: > [...] > # 2. Activate Claude Code with permissions > claude --dangerously-skip-permissions Bypassing all permissions and connecting with MCPs, can't wait for "Claude flow deleted all my files and leaked my CI credentials" blog post
- data-ottawa 1y ago
  I would like a simple tool to run Claude in a container with only read/write access to provided folders. I’ve set it up bespoke but the auth flow gets broken.
  - oarsinsync 1y ago
    Have you considered asking Claude code to write this for you?
  - T0Bi 1y ago
    I use the .devcontainer¹ from the claude-code repository. It works great with VSC and let's you work in your docker container without any issues. And as long as you use some sort of version control (git) you cannot really lose anything. ¹ https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/tree/main/.devcontainer https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/tree/main/.devcont...
    - deleted 1y ago
      [deleted]
  - SOLAR_FIELDS 1y ago
    Claudebox is what I was playing with. You need to mount the oauth access token in as an env. It’s not some crazy vibe coded framework, just around 1k lines of shell helpers to set it up.
  - beefnugs 1y ago
    This is the main problem with all the AI stuff, you really need: whitelist only network isolation, idempotent clean virtual machine creation and cleanup, automated git branches and merging strategies, full chain multi host logging to an external log collector (when something unexpected happens to should be able to review an entire event log of where it went wrong so you can improve), social-graph like tracking of what works and what doesn't, constant background model testing (to detect when censorship is going to bite you) or when a new better model for quality for cost effectiveness can be swapped in, anything background like agents needs an orchestrator so you can set up daily or weekly budgets to try and keep a handle on costs, some defined methodology to reduce long running agent based production down to actual reliable code on an ongoing basis The tooling required for any of this to approach actual engineering reliability levels is unbelievable really
dazzaji 1y ago
Ruv (of Claude Flow) seems to like the new Claude Agents a lot, and already is leveraging them in Claude Flow. He waxes positively on the topic here: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/reuvencohen_spent-the-afternoon-digging-into-claude-code-activity-7354702830080839682-tnuH https://www.linkedin.com/posts/reuvencohen_spent-the-afterno...
lvl155 1y ago
What did you make me read. Right off the bat, it says v2 alpha. Bro…

So everything claude-flow¹ already does but worse (I guess?). ¹ https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow

by T0Bi 1y ago

So everything claude-flow¹ already does but worse (I guess?). ¹ https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow https://github.com/ruvnet/claude-flow

nazgul17 1y ago

Except it's not in alpha phase

dchuk 1y ago

I’ll admit this looks comprehensive, but man oh man does this seem complicated and over doing it

himeexcelanta 1y ago

This looks like a yarn ball (in not a good way)

SOLAR_FIELDS 1y ago

That guy doesn't even understand how his own software works. Is anyone actually using this thing and putting their code into production?

lubujackson 1y ago
It's extreme dogfooding where he is making a mashed potato volcano where Claude agents are the potatoes and your sanity is the gravy.
AbstractH24 1y ago
Not only are people using them, they are building startups based on them. And then selling said startups.

jampa 1y ago

> IMPORTANT: Claude Code must be installed first: > [...] > # 2. Activate Claude Code with permissions > claude --dangerously-skip-permissions Bypassing all permissions and connecting with MCPs, can't wait for "Claude flow deleted all my files and leaked my CI credentials" blog post

data-ottawa 1y ago
I would like a simple tool to run Claude in a container with only read/write access to provided folders. I’ve set it up bespoke but the auth flow gets broken.
- oarsinsync 1y ago
  Have you considered asking Claude code to write this for you?
- T0Bi 1y ago
  I use the .devcontainer¹ from the claude-code repository. It works great with VSC and let's you work in your docker container without any issues. And as long as you use some sort of version control (git) you cannot really lose anything. ¹ https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/tree/main/.devcontainer https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/tree/main/.devcont...
  - deleted 1y ago
    [deleted]
- SOLAR_FIELDS 1y ago
  Claudebox is what I was playing with. You need to mount the oauth access token in as an env. It’s not some crazy vibe coded framework, just around 1k lines of shell helpers to set it up.
- beefnugs 1y ago
  This is the main problem with all the AI stuff, you really need: whitelist only network isolation, idempotent clean virtual machine creation and cleanup, automated git branches and merging strategies, full chain multi host logging to an external log collector (when something unexpected happens to should be able to review an entire event log of where it went wrong so you can improve), social-graph like tracking of what works and what doesn't, constant background model testing (to detect when censorship is going to bite you) or when a new better model for quality for cost effectiveness can be swapped in, anything background like agents needs an orchestrator so you can set up daily or weekly budgets to try and keep a handle on costs, some defined methodology to reduce long running agent based production down to actual reliable code on an ongoing basis The tooling required for any of this to approach actual engineering reliability levels is unbelievable really

dazzaji 1y ago

Ruv (of Claude Flow) seems to like the new Claude Agents a lot, and already is leveraging them in Claude Flow. He waxes positively on the topic here: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/reuvencohen_spent-the-afternoon-digging-into-claude-code-activity-7354702830080839682-tnuH https://www.linkedin.com/posts/reuvencohen_spent-the-afterno...

lvl155 1y ago

What did you make me read. Right off the bat, it says v2 alpha. Bro…