3 ms·
What do you mean by accessible without authentication? My server will serve example.com/64-byte-random-code if you request it, but if you don’t know the code, I
by bo1024 1y ago
What do you mean by accessible without authentication? My server will serve example.com/64-byte-random-code if you request it, but if you don’t know the code, I won’t serve it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- prophesi 1y agoObfuscation may hint that it's intended to be private, but it's certainly not authentication. And the keyspace for these goog.le short URL's are much smaller than a 64byte alphanumeric code.
- hombre_fatal 1y agoSure, but you have to make executive decisions on the behalf of people who aren't experts. Making bad actors brute force the key space to find unlisted URLs could be a better scenario for most people. People also upload unlisted Youtube videos and cloud docs so that they can easily share them with family. It doesn't mean you might as well share content that they thought was private.
- bo1024 1y agoI'm not seeing why there's a clear line where GET cannot be authentication but POST can.
- prophesi 1y agoBecause there isn't a line? You can require auth for any of those HTTP methods. Or not require auth for any of them.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- wobfan 1y agoI mean, going by that argument a username + password is also just obfuscation. Generating a unique 64 byte code is even more secure than this, IF it's handled correctly.