3 ms·
The lede paragraph in this interesting article raises the key question: "Scientists, lawyers and politicians have raised new concerns over the quality of foren
by tokenadult 14y ago
The lede paragraph in this interesting article raises the key question:
"Scientists, lawyers and politicians have raised new concerns over the quality of forensic evidence testing - so is the criminal justice system too reliant on lab tests without realising their limitations?"
I'm grateful for some of the specialized publications on a skeptical worldview, such as Skeptic magazine and Skeptical Inquirer magazine and some of the websites and books recommended in those magazines, for teaching over the last decade or more that even "scientific" approaches to questions that come up in court cases have often never been validated. I was surprised to discover that even the old technique of matching fingerprints is still the subject of a lot of recent scholarly studies
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=fingerprint+matching+validation http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=fingerprint+matching+val...
https://uchastings.edu/hlj/archive/vol59/Koehler_59-HLJ-1077.pdf https://uchastings.edu/hlj/archive/vol59/Koehler_59-HLJ-1077...
and that there is NOT full validation of all the techniques that have long been used to show fingerprint matches between criminal case suspects and fingerprint impressions found at a crime scene. The article submitted here makes the important point even the latest gee-whiz technology, DNA typing, which is usually the key to solving crimes on television drama shows, has significant limitations. Sometimes DNA samples are poorly gathered, and sometimes DNA test results are ambiguous.
It takes a combination of multiple lines of evidence that are consistent with one another best to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Lawyers for criminal defendants do the right thing when they argue vigorously over every factual basis for the state's claim that an accused defendant is guilty. I was an appellate clerk once upon a time for a state supreme court that reviewed all first-degree murder convictions in the state. I had to read a lot of case files with gory crime scene photographs and lots of transcripts of witness testimony to events and expert witness testimony about the findings of scientific tests. Sometimes a case is supported by so many lines of evidence that no reasonable appellate judge could doubt the sufficiency of the evidence shown at trial. Other times a conviction at trial is reversed on appeal not because of factual innocence, but because of legal errors by the prosecution. But every once in a while, even after a conviction at trial under the standard of presuming innocence beyond a reasonable doubt, a very reasonable doubt that wasn't considered fully at trial is preserved in the court record and forms the basis of reversing the trial court judgment on appeal. No one line of evidence is foolproof, not even DNA.