3 ms·
At the end of the day Bitcoin is a networked technology. It's worthless to me if you/the store/landlord/taxman won't take it, and most of them don't, so its val
by fragmede 1y ago
At the end of the day Bitcoin is a networked technology. It's worthless to me if you/the store/landlord/taxman won't take it, and most of them don't, so its value is only between adherents, which means, sure, I can buy some, but then what? Use it to buy something sketchy online?
Meanwhile, anyone can go to chat.com and ask for code to do whatever they ask. Some questions it will answer well, others it will not. Because we're discussing this in the abstract, LLM good!/LLM bad! Grar!, and barely touching on details, like the programming language, the libraries, nevermind sharing the prompts, both camps are convinced they're right, with much more furvor than Bitcoin. Additionally the technology is evolving so fast that someone's bad experience from a couple months ago is already out of date. Meanwhile, how many times can you have the same argument about Bitcoin? There are a couple details here and there, but nothing structurally changed with Bitcoin since its inception. Which is a shame, if they'd managed to fork so transactions weren't horribly slow, maybe we'd be having a different discussion. But I digress.
The volume of emotion is different, not because of the money swimming around, of which there is a lot, but because we're arguing over things we see with our own eyes but aren't giving enough detail to have productive discussions about. Insulting people adds to the emotionally charged nature. Things like "If you find LLMs used, it's because you're a bad programmer/an idiot/only work on loser problems" or "AIs going to put you out of a job" don't encourage reasonable nuanced discussion. Insulting someone for liking Bitcoin doesn't cut as deep. No one's been working on Bitcoin for four decades and made it their whole (public) identity.
- Karrot_Kream 1y ago> No one's been working on Bitcoin for four decades and made it their whole (public) identity. It sounds like a large part of the problem is getting your identity wrapped up into this. Both the CEOs and the devs.
- fragmede 1y agoTo be clear, I was referring to programming ability when I was referring to identity, not AI. It's sometimes hard for me to forget that you are not your code.
- Karrot_Kream 1y agoYes I mean that too. I have no idea how you can "measure" programming ability. The whole concept confuses me. I've been coding since I was a kid and have contributed to FOSS and closed codebases. There's certainly programmers out there that I consider bad, but beyond that there's no way to measure how "good" someone is at coding. The fact that people can identify around their perception of programming skill is deeply confusing to me and makes these sorts of reactions even harder to understand.
- fragmede 1y agoProgrammers are just as emotional as the next human, no matter how much they want to believe otherwise, so almost all of them (myself included) think they're better than average, which can't actually be true. Skill is linked to prestige and loosely linked to pay, which gets linked back to prestige. Thus even without an actual measure of programming ability, if someone says "you couldn't program your way out of a paper bag", it's hard for most people not to feel insulted, linking back to prestige. Not everyone buys into that, or is impulsive enough to respond emotionally, of course, but it should at least make sense on a conceptual level.