3 ms·
I see that this opinion piece by a journalist (so described in the biographical squib on GigaOM) has reached the front page of Hacker News. As a definition, I'l
by tokenadult 14y ago
I see that this opinion piece by a journalist (so described in the biographical squib on GigaOM) has reached the front page of Hacker News. As a definition, I'll say that a journalist is "a reporter who writes for an editor," a definition I heard quite a few years ago to deny that certain solo bloggers are journalists. I think the issue of writing for an editor is important, because I have been a reporter who wrote for an editor (at an obscure company in Taiwan that published English-language trade magazines for international businessmen procuring products in Taiwan). I later became an editor for the same company, and learned how to read raw manuscripts from cub journalists while still doing some beat reporting of my own.
Journalism is not easy. Finding a source who will tell you the facts and not lie to your face is harder than you might think. Finding reference materials that accurately represent the world of reality is still not trivially easy, even in this age of the World Wide Web. (Some subjects, notably some medical subjects, are notoriously misrepresented on the Web. Wikipedia is plagued by edit wars
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Race_and_intelligence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Lamest_edit_wars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Lamest_edit_wars
and is still not based on reliable sources for many of its key amateur-edited articles.)
Even if a journalist carefully gathers correct facts about the external world, the journalist is swimming uphill, because the journalist is writing for readers who on many subjects already have their minds made up. I almost think the title of this submission should be followed up with a submission titled "Can't human beings acknowledge that all humans are human?" because confirmation bias
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias
(yeah, this is a rare example of a good Wikipedia article on a controversial subject) is a common feature of the thinking of all human beings, so it's not easy for anybody to learn new knowledge simply from observing the facts of the world. Persistent misconceptions persist because they fit the cognitive biases of the human mind.
So rather than give in to the cognitive bias of tribalism, decrying journalists as members of the other tribe, while praising HN participants as smarter than journalists, I'll suggest that each of us lay out our observations of facts, examine one another's statements, and generally proceed with tolerant awareness of our own foibles and yet bold pursuit of truth.
On the issue of the submitted article, if someone employed by a news organization makes a factually unsupported comment slurring a big part of his audience, I'm okay with his employers seeking a new person to fill that position. There is a meaningful distinction between a journalist, a reporter who writes for an editor, and a freelance commentator, and if the person who makes off-the-cuff remarks disparaging other people gets good enough at that, he can gain a job like Stephen Colbert's--IF he shows a sense of humor about himself as gentle as Colbert's.
- 001sky 14y agoI find the 'strategy' of defense in the article rather odd, and misplaced. The problem with the article is it frames the issue as one of "bias" but , as you point out, that is a strawman, and this is not your normal case of Bias. Its not the reporting of some true things at the omission of others. Its not asking questions that lead to a similar result. (1) Fabrication vs Bias. The "journalist" has no data to support his suggestion. It is malicious in intent. It isn't that it is a "bias" to one side or the other. Its the tactical depoloyment of that. Making stuff up and putting words into people's mouths are not reporting the news. Its not even biased reporting. Its propoganda. (2) Humor defence. Is weak. Its a racially tinged remark. What if it was sexist? What if he was Joking about rape? What if he was fabricating about rape as a joke? Make jokes about rape and you will end up in court for creating a hostile work environment. [edit: Political affiliation is not a protected class, but do you want to create a nasty environment based on political beliefs? Even if its ok in news, what about engineering? Recruiting Strategy?] (3) PR spin. The individual that was fired was a part of the eco-system. He surely has friends and connections that he's worked with. Do these people also look foolish now? Probably, a bit. We should expect some articles coming forth to protect the subjects reputation a bit. By doing this, the authors are of course acting in their own self interest. And, the way the article puts it, this Yahoo! was dismissed somewhat with predudice (They counted to 1...) and most folks don't want to be associated with that. (4) CEO Spotlight. The bias was anti one party. Thus, implicitly, it was pro the other. Even if this remark was in your favour, would you want to be associated with manipulative, fabricating, bull-baiter employee? Would you want to have this guy be in charge of the News? At a professional level, Yahoo handled the situation well. Like a band-aid, the did one-quick ouch. At a personal level, you sort of feel bad for the guy that got fired. But the fact that it bordered on an ethics issue directly related to his job performance tempers the sympathy.