3 ms·
Post-2000 the problem is not that we lack a theory of quantum gravity, it's that there are a large number of approaches to quantum gravity [1] but no experimen
by PaulHoule 1y ago
Post-2000 the problem is not that we lack a theory of quantum gravity, it's that there are a large number of approaches to quantum gravity [1] but no experiment that can pick out one of them. The most valuable theoretical work now is that which proves certain approaches are dead ends -- the demolition of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doubly_special_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doubly_special_relativity is one of the best things that happened in the last 20 years as I see it.
So, to parody the VISA ad, "new theory of quantum gravity: 50 cents, experiment that reveals something about quantum gravity: priceless"
[1] I count 25 here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Candidate_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Candidate_theo...
- pajuhaan 1y agoI totally agree; the inability to experimentally falsify most quantum gravity theories is indeed a huge pain that has haunted theoretical physics for over 80 years. But here's a thought: what if a completely new approach emerged, one that didn't start with 11-dimensional strings, M-theory, or quantizing General Relativity directly? after all, 100% quantum gravity candidates still assume the standard 4-dimensional spacetime as described by GR +smt extra, then attempt to quantize it! But imagine if we had a fundamental theory from which gravity and GR themselves emerged naturally and effortlessly—making General Relativity merely an emergent phenomenon of something "much simpler" Wouldn't a theory like that be worth more than 50 cents?