4 ms·
Google Keeps Making Smartphones Worse
- vinibrito 1y agoThere is purism with their librem phones, I wonder why the author didn't mention them in the end of the article.
- rasz 1y agoCan you record your own conversations on those?
- roughly 1y agoGenuine question - my impression of the Librem phones is they’re not particularly usable as phones - is a Librem an actually viable smartphone right now? Like, if I want to do all the normal stuff - use maps, message friends (say, text and signal), maybe even catch an uber - is a Librem a viable choice for normal phone use?
- kop316 1y agoI have been using a Librem 5 on Mobian for 3+ years, and the answer is yes. I can use sms/mms, have Signal Desktop installed, i can use Pure Maps for maps and navigation, and i can use Android Apps via Waydroid (though that is admittedly cumbersome).
- roughly 1y agoInteresting - I've looked at them before, but have always been hesitant. What kind of battery life are you getting, and how stable is it? What are the primary tradeoffs for you?
- fileoffset 1y agoGot a Librem5 and sold it immediately. Too large, too heavy, shitty, buggy software and the battery was terrible. This was admittedly a few years ago but I wouldnt touch them.
- kop316 1y agoA few years has made a huge difference in stability and usage I would offer. It sounds weird to say, but I like its size and heft now. I said it in a sibling comment, but yeah, battery life leaves a lot to be desired with heavy usage.
- kop316 1y agoSorry just saw this. Standby is 15 hours or so. If I am active with it, it drops closer to 4-5 hours. It's reasonably stable. The 3 GB limitation is kind of annoying, because a lot of apps like to use 400-500 MB each, so I really can only have one app open at a time. I don't use too many apps (the only social media I have is Mastodon), so there isn't much tradeoffs to me. Ironically, most of the tradeoffs I used to have to make, I helped fix. I made a meshtastic app, I helped to get GPS working with geoclue for navigation, I made a voicemail app. The main tradeoff for me is the battery really. But in a day to day scenario, I do sit in an office or at home, so it really just sits on one of two chargers.
- adithyassekhar 1y agoI read that as Google Keep, don't you dare.
- pajko 1y agoAn alternative could be https://commerce.jolla.com/products/jolla-community-phone https://commerce.jolla.com/products/jolla-community-phone
- Nevermark 1y agoI feel like we need another system. Proprietary is great, as long as it's not the only choice. Open source is another great choice. They are both a marriage of technology with quite different economic systems. With different pro's and con's. But a technological/economic system that highly incentivized suppliers of fine grain pick-and-choose modularity (in the form of both modular systems and individual modules), over bloat/irreversably-integrated products would be an incredible boon for choice. Because modularity = choice, maximum competition. Non-modularity = lack of choice, reduced competition. Then vertical proprietary systems could still compete, including leveraging integration when it provides benefits (performance, simpler choices, lower user-side complexity), but they would be competing with viable modular substitutes with a different benefit: they do what users want, and only what they want. Not saying I have a realistic economic model for how a very strong modularity incentive happens, but the question has been on my mind the last couple decades! Note that both proprietary and open-source provide haphazard modularity, but neither is pervasively modular today. Although the latter is reliably malleable, sort of atomically modular. But we the option for modularity at all levels clearly has huge untapped/unrewarded economic value.
- CodesInChaos 1y ago> Over the years, Google has moved many crucial features [...] push notifications, from the open-source project to its closed-source black box. Haven't push notifications always been part of the closed Google Play Services?
- CodesInChaos 1y agoThe author didn't even one of the worst abuses: Google pushes features like Safetynet and Web Environment Integrity, which use Hardware DRM to ensure software is running on certified hardware and OS. Even passkeys come with remote attestation to make sure the user can't control their own authentication keys.